Jim & Mike’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

My brother and I used to get breakfast here a lot because it was cheap and pretty good for a pizza shop. Recently though, they increased their prices quite significantly. Whereas it used to be about $ 4 – 5 for an order of pancakes, it is now closer to $ 6 – 7. By no means expensive for breakfast, but if you add bacon or potatoes you’re looking at a $ 10 – 12 meal. The service is okay. The two gentleman there aren’t usually on the friendly side, but they’re not mean either. The atmosphere is kind of depressing, usually empty with ESPN playing on an old TV and some games in the corner. The breakfast is fantastic and enormous, which makes up for the price. I don’t feel like eating for the rest of the day after getting the pancakes. Be warned though, do not go near dinner. The pizza is gross and their side items (especially the mozzarella sticks) are close to nauseating.

Will never go back! Got our order all wrong and of course it’s take out. They wanted to blame us when it was their error. Everyone makes mistakes but own it and apologize or make good on it. Got the wife so upset by arguing with her that we will never use again. Food was always just OK but the service is just bad along with their attitudes. Don’t waste your time or money.

Solid pizza and solid good fries. Can’t go wrong on this one. We always stop by here when we are in Pitman.

Terrible!
I went for my lunch break. Ordered a salad because I thought ordering something that didn’t need cooking would be fast. It took 45 minutes for them to make my salad, I had to tell them to make it to go because I didn’t have time. The place was not even busy, there were three other people in the restaurant while I was there (and the phone only rang twice for delivery).
Also, the salad was terrible (I know a pizza place is not the place to get good salad). It was soupy with dressing and dripping out of the sides of the container.
I won’t be going back.

Lived in Pitman for a short time when I was in college and ate at Jim & Mike’s a few times. Granted that was a while ago… but nothing in Pitman ever changes. Pitman is one of those classic American towns where nothing ever changes– time stands still! Jim & Mike’s is your typical pizza joint, with your typical menu and typical booths. The previous review was on the mark. It’s the kind of place you go order out from if you happen to live nearby, but don’t go out of your way for.

I used to go here a lot with my family as a kid. Went back last night for the first time in years. Despite a lot of booths, they seem to have a mostly takeout clientele.
It’s a typical pizza parlor setting. Nothing fancy. Hard booths and some game machines. The panzarotti was a HUGE pizza turnover (not fried like the original panzarotti. But my aunt loved it. I ordered a chicken sandwich. They clarified (steak or sandwich) and I said sandwich. I got a chicken cheesesteak. I specifically said no cheese. Whatever.
If you’re in the area and need food, this is a place to go.