Conicella Pizza

Best pizza in Greenfield.
Food:
This pizza is the pizza that looks like it does in cartoons.
Reasonably priced.
DO IT OR ELSE.
Ambience:
Get your food and get out.
Staff:
All you want out of a pizzeria staff in Greenfield. Read between the lines, people.
Always willing to give extra dipping sauces!
I think they are cash only, you’ve been warned.

Solid old-​school pizza. Plenty of cheese, good sauce and a nice hand with the toppings. Sauce doesn’t have that cooked-​down flavor and is pretty bright. Good dough with a nice airy crust with a slight crisp, but a good chew. Hoagies are solid as well — we had an Italian– ham, cap, salami and provolone. Crusty/​chewy sub roll (Breadworks? Mancini’s? Whatever — it’s a good roll. We had their $ 18 special — large 16″ cheese (we added X-​cheese and sausage for $ 3), whole Italian hoagie, and 2-​liter pop. $ 22 with tax and the extra toppings. Better quality than Rialto. On par with Big Jim’s. Good value and really friendly owners. Cash only.

This is a small pizza place in Greenfield with take-​out and delivery. The pizza is excellent and pizza bagels are delicious. They also have a variety of sandwiches. The meatball hoagie is one of the best I’ve had in Pittsburgh. I recommend.

I loved this place when I lived in Pittsburgh. Fast delivery and cash-​only means the price is right.
Pizza was always a cheesy, greasy pile of delicious. Calzones were stuffed with yummy things. Hoagies were absolutely decadent.
Oh, I miss this place.

Is always one of my favorites. As far as pizza in the city of pittsburgh not many come close.
I always enjoy my experiences. All around one of the best mom&pop shops in the area.

This pizza IS PIZZA! SOOO DELICIOUS! The crust is perfect, sauce delish and enough cheese to satisfy the cheese lover in all of us! GO! You will be happy happy happy! They are cash only! This was my FIRST time having it and I live close enough to become a regular! Directly across from St. Rosalia church in Geeenfield!

When I come to Greenfield, Conicella’s the the best place to eat, it would be nice if they took credit cards for customer convenience but l am sure they will catch up to modern times. They have the best steak hoagies though.

The pizza bagels are the best. Everything is good but you have to try the bagels with extra cheese. Get a sausage and a pepperoni bagel and try each.

I stopped by here this past Saturday evening by myself to pick up a pizza for dinner. I don’t know that I would have found Conicellas on my own but luckily some fellow elite Unilocalers recommended them to me at one of our events. I ended up calling Conicellas at around 7:00 and was told that my pizza would be ready in 20 minutes. So I plugged the location in Google maps and off I went. I am actually quite glad that I had the maps app too as Conicellas is a little further down Greenfield Avenue than I expected and right across from a church/​school. The outside of the place isn’t much to look at and the inside consists of a small area to pick up your pizza and that’s about it. Whenever I arrived at 7:30, my XL cheese pizza was ready and I paid $ 12 cash and was out the door.
As with all pizzas, the pizza here can be broken down into its three major components: sauce, crust and cheese. The sauce on Conicellas pizza didn’t really have any spices in it that I could taste. Don’t confuse it with boring or bland though as the tomatoes brought a brightness to the pie and I enjoyed the slight acidity to them which helped to balance the cheese. Speaking of the cheese, it had a nice flavor to it and there was an ton of it. As a matter of a fact, the first piece that I tried to eat had half of it slide off because of its proportion to the thin crust. Last but not least was the thin crust which I thought was fantastic. It was super crispy and on the first two pieces that I ate I audibly crunched through each piece. Then after it sat for a little while the center of the pie became less crunchy while the back was still nice and crisp. It had a nice flavor too and I think I could taste a little yeastiness in the middle of the crust at the back of the pizza.
The bottom line for me is that I will head back to Conicellas again in the future. As a matter of a fact I plan to take my wife in the near future as I am absolutely positive that sure will love this pizza, especially the crispy crust.

The calzones are delicious and affordable. Something this good would cost $ 5 – 7 more in most places. Fresh dough, quality ingredients – you can’t go wrong. Hoagies are a little more basic, but their hot sausage and Italian have great flavor and generous amounts of cheese. There is never a sense that they have skimped on their food. If you are lucky enough to live in their delivery area, order here and not a chain.

We stopped in here on our way to a wedding and decided to try the pizza since my friend had told me when she spotted this place it had an «authentic» pizzeria feel. We walked in and there was only one man working and he told us that they only accepted cash. Since we did not have any cash on us we walked up the road to the atm and took out some cash. We both ordered the small pizza and they were a good size. The crust was fluffy and definitely could feed two people as long as you didn’t have huge appetites. My friend asked the man about the history of the place and he had said they’ve been in business over 30 years. There are no tables and this place is completely takeout but we enjoyed this pizza.

This is a total no-​frills, no gimmicks, greasy pizza shop. We like the hand tossed crust and basic tomato sauce. They are always friendly and have my order ready for pickup in 15 minutes. I hope they stay in business as long as I live in Greenfield!

Great pizza & hoagies! Good cooks & prices. You can get a beer at the bar across the street while you wait for your food.

I live nearby and this is the best pizza I’ve found in the area. Always really good and affordable. I love it!

Excellent pizza! From the generous toppings and tasty cheese all the way to the bottom of the wonderful crust, this is some of the best pizza I have ever tasted. Try it for yourself– you won’t regret it!

This is my go-​to pizza delivery place. They have a special where you get a two topping large pizza with a 2-​liter for $ 16 I always get. I love their sausage and green pepper pizza. They also have all the old Pepsi signage relics from the 80s. Delivery is always on time and reliable, cash only

I have stopped there a few times for an Italian Sub & it smelled so good that I pulled over & ate one in my car.
Decided to try the pizza and Wow! It not only looked like it would taste great but it actually tasted great.
Just heated up the leftovers and realized how flavorful the crust was because sometimes the sauce & cheese hides what they are rested on.
Great experience!!!

I know it’s a big deal to announce this in Pittsburgh but after living here for 4 years and eating my way around the east end options I am ready to announce my absolute favorite pizza. Here it is. And is everything a pizza place should be. It is the best cheese, best sauce, best grease, and best dough I can have delivered to my door. I am so happy its right in my neighborhood. Sausage, olive, pepper is the way to go. Damn. It’s great delivery too, always smoking hot. I am not talking specialty pizza or fancy smancy cooking styles. I am talking the type of pie your mom and dad ordered on a friday night after giving up on cooking. And it is familiar and delicious.

With no menu to be found online we took a gamble and called in an order for a large sausage and mushroom pizza and a chef salad.
I went to pick it up so I could check the place out and it was just a solid little pizza place (no seating) with friendly people. The pizza was very good, I highly recommend the sausage. The salad was not exceptional but solid.
Total bill came out to $ 17 even and with a free 2liter of coke. It’s a great alternative to the delicious but pricey Murray Ave pizza shops.

Place like this are why Unilocal is great. Having tried every pizza in a 10 mile radius we decided to give this place a shot. It sure as hell doesn’t look like much but we ordered for delivery and let me tell you there is a reason this place survives.
I have to say this i some of the best pizza around. My wife got sausage and it was great. The peperoni was pretty good but get the sausage and you won’t be disapointed.
The food arrived promptly and hot. This si our new go to pizza place.