Mario’s Pizza

Great pizza and more! Pizza base is just right (a nice balance btw thin & medium) toppings generous, good sauce. Hoagies very good. Good & fast delivery. Would highly recommend!

I ordered pizza an hour and a half ago, and I dont have it yet. I better not get charged. I ordered through GrubHub, and they (Mario’s) said that it would take longer than expected. However, the sketchy part was that it was well past their posted closing time.
***Update*** I did get charged for the pizza and did not even receive it. What a waste.

Only getting 3 stars because the food is always good. On several occasions I have waited an hour and a half for SALAD. I don’t understand why it takes this long. Right now going on 2 hours for steak salad and bread sticks.

Right off the bat, let me say it took almost 2 hours from when I sent the order through GrubHub to when my order came. It’s a Monday night. That wasn’t cool.
But I got a big hunk of cheesy garlic bread, bacon cheese fries, and a small half salami/​olive/​onion, half pepperoni/​mushroom pie. It was all REALLY good! The garlic bread was pungent and extra cheesy. They serve the cheddar cheese sauce on the side for the fries so they don’t get soggy, and it’s the super salty processed cheese you want, too. And the pie was really good. Perfectly cooked crust and the sauce is just acidic and tangy enough. A little uneven distribution of the toppings, but I can’t hate on that.
I called when my order was late and Lou, the guy I talked to, was really nice and genuinely sounded like he cared. Plus he gave me a $ 10 credit the next time I call. Can’t hate on that. Great food! Just be prepared to wait.

Really I love this Mario special pizza, one of my favorite pizza in Pittsburgh I ordered almost 30 times thanks guys you are doing great job

If I could give zero stars I would. Literally trying to stomach this food right now and even the pizza tastes like old grease. Food came cold. Only reason I ordered from here was because GrubHub has a ⁵⁄₅ rating for it. Food is repulsive. Service was late. «Orange soda» was really Mountain Dew. Cinnamon sticks were just breadsticks with cinnamon. Mild hot wings were in a pool of grease with two splashes of hot sauce. GROSS. I’m gonna have a heart attack

This place is near my home and my wife liked it so we continued ordering from here despite my dissatisfaction. No longer though. My wife felt ill after her latest order, chicken salad, so fortunately I will no longer be forced to order from here.
While previously there have been no issues with the food I have experienced numerous service issues. One time I was provided with the wrong order and did not realize it till I arrived home after picking it up. The ticket included with the order was correct and I did not want to open everything since it was stapled in the bag.
This isn’t the worst thing in the world. They were clearly busy and stuff happens. The next time I returned they charged me $ 10.00 though because the wrong order I received cost more than my order and they indicated I should have notified them my order was incorrect.
They are also consistently off on their pick up times. I generally end up standing around for 10 minutes waiting for my order even though I generally arrive 5 — 10 minutes after the expected wait time since it became clear there was no way the food would be ready in that window.
My review is 2 stars instead of 1 because their stromboli is delicious.

Delivery is absolutely terrible. The food took TWO HOURS to get here, and when I called to ask about the delivery time the person that answered the phone simply told me «We’re understaffed so everything is slow.» When I asked if they could contact the driver to see how much longer it would be I was hung up on. By the time the food arrived I was pretty mad, and the delivery driver simply said they are slow. Thanks. Food was mediocre after all of that. I will NEVER order from this place again. There are plenty of great food places in the area — we certainly don’t need ale delivery for not impressive food.

This is not about the food. My coworkers and I used to order from them all the time for lunch. The guy that I spoke to on the phone was so rude when I tried to be nice about them forgetting our drinks. They said it would take a hour, prices for the drinks, and a delivery charge. Seriously??? They are literally 5 minutes from where I work. If I had the time, I would have driven there. I will never order from them again. When I told them that, the guy said «oh well». See ya… you guys lost A LOT of business from my work.

Bad, bad, bad. Ordered wings they were rancid tasting. One bite and we through them away. They tasted was so bad I spit it out and had to brush my teeth. Also got an Italian hoagie, low quality meats, bland dressing. Will never go back., save yourself a major disappointment, much better places to eat in the Burg.

Great pizza! I get it all the time but to be honest their delivery sucks. It has taken over an hour multiple times I ordered from there.

The food was absolutely horrible!!! It took them over an hour to deliver it and when it finally arrived it was cold. I ordered a caprese salad and by the picture on the menu assumed it was a traditional caprese salad. I don’t know what this was… lettuce, large tomatoes, barley any mozzarella, old rotten olives and covered in shredded parm. I asked for no mushroom and my wrap to come cold. It was warm and soggy and filled with mushrooms. Lastly, I asked for cheddar cheese SAUCE on my cheese fries. I got cold shredded cheese that was hard as a rock! HORRIBLE HORRIBLE HORRIBLE

It appears that the miserable Pizza Palazzo has been overpowered and put to rest by the superior Mario’s Pizza.
A concert I had tickets for was canceled (Danzig at Stage AE), so with a night off as a result, Kay and I figured it was high time we tried Mario’s, a place we’ve been passing a bunch during our travels of late.
A special deal got us a whole hoagie, a pizza with one topping, and a dozen chicken wings for one price ($ 23).
The pizza, featuring our chosen topping in bacon, had a crust like a Southside Pretzel; it will strengthen your jaw muscles, let me tell ya. The sauce had the proper amount of sweetness to add some Yum Capital to the pie, and the cheese was generous. The brackishness of the bacon we added played off the honeyed sauce beautifully, reminding this diner that salt and sugar make quite the couple.
The garlic wings made me melancholy for each flat and drumette evoked memories of the recently departed George Aiken’s chicken chain with their fatty, friable quality.
The soft of bun, fresh of vegetable, and slightly light on tuna hoagie was an acceptable filler that barely scores a victory over Subway’s version.
Yeah, I can see us getting delivery from here often, but Beechview’s SLICE on Broadway is a contender as well. I guess we’ll have to flip for it, that is unless I keep finding more pizza parlors to review, and there are many left in the ‘Burgh.
P. S. Our order came to the house within the 45 minute time frame and was correct.