Sieb’s Pub

We have been coming here for years and have tried almost everything on the menu. Always good food and service. The draft beer selection is small, but we come here for the Harp and Smithwicks. Tonight I had a Reuben and my husband had the shepherd’s pie. Excellent as always.

Came here last night with a group of 15 people to celebrate my daughter’s engagement — a happy occasion! The Wait staff told us we need to calm down, that we were too noisy and bothering the other customers. REALLY? A Pub? They got grumpier and meaner as the night went on, and then downright aggressive! I’ve never experienced anything like it. BAD juju and food! We won’t return!

Recently ate here for the first time and will definitely be back. We stopped in around 8 for dinner and the pub side had a few people but want crowded. Our waitress wad extremely friendly and answered all of our questions. The atmosphere is all things Irish which I love. Everything we had was good — small fish sandwich, shepherds pie, and Southern Style BBQ soup. That soup was fantastic. There was good music and everyone seemed friendly. We will definitely be back!

Sieb’s no longer serves all you can eat crab legs on Wednesday. There is no reason to come here anymore unless you want to drink Irish whiskey or Scotch, in which there is a very solid selection.

I have been to Sieb’s a few times now when over in the north hills. Each time I am always impressed. A very hometown friendly atmosphere. There is a bar area and a dinning area. The menu is very diverse with everything to Irish specialties, bar favorites like burgers and Pittsburgh style salads.
I have ordered a grilled chicken salad which had a mixture of iceberg lettuce and mixed greens with grilled chicken fries and cheese on top. I chose the ranch dressing which was great and I think homemade. The chicken was fresh (not frozen) and the fries were hand cut.
Most recently I ordered my favorite thing on the menu a chicken pot pie! The presentation was great and the taste was even better. With a flaky crust and a flavorful filling. The chicken was lean and fresh and again it was obvious this was no frozen entrée. This is the reason I will be going back to Sieb’s pub anytime I’m in the North Hills! I have been to Sieb’s a few times now when over in the north hills. Each time I am always impressed. A very hometown friendly atmosphere. There is a bar area and a dinning area. The menu is very diverse with everything to Irish specialties, bar favorites like burgers and Pittsburgh style salads.
I have ordered a grilled chicken salad which had a mixture of iceberg lettuce and mixed greens with grilled chicken fries and cheese on top. I chose the ranch dressing which was great and I think homemade. The chicken was fresh (not frozen) and the fries were hand cut.
Most recently I ordered my favorite thing on the menu a chicken pot pie! The presentation was great and the taste was even better. With a flaky crust and a flavorful filling. The chicken was lean and fresh and again it was obvious this was no frozen entrée. This is the reason I will be going back to Sieb’s pub anytime I’m in the North Hills!
Another perk was a good beer selection. I love Rivertowne brews and they had my favorite Pineapple Beer!

Brought my family here for Father’s Day. Was expecting more based on the reviews. We had the Kennedy Irish Stew, Shepherd’s Pie, Chicken Pot Pie, Fish Sandwich and Steak Hoagie. The stew and both pies had a sour taste to the base stock. The Irish Stew was particularly sour. I thought it was supposed to be based on Guinness beer but I’ve had other Irish stew’s based on Guinness and they were rich, flavorful and a little sweet. This was very sour as stated. Service was good and the staff were very friendly. This being Father’s Day I expected the place to be packed but there were only about a 15 people there including our party of 6. Wish the food was better because I liked the place and the staff but I’m sure I won’t be returning. Sorry!

Siebs has been a regular dinner spot for our family for a few years now. My parents were regulars, sharing in many celebrations there as well as just a normal Friday night. When my Dad recently passed suddenly and unexpectedly, we knew there was no better place to celebrate his life. Not only did the owners and staff cry with us, they helped us plan the most beautiful wake in his memory. They were truly phenomenal! The food, drinks, service, and facility was above and beyond. So many people have told us that they were impressed too. It’s rare to find places like this that you feel so at home and not like just another customer. We will continue to celebrate life and my Dad’s memory at our favorite restaurant as well.

They have the best bar tenders in the North Hills but they do not have a great selection of draft beers. High quality food and affordable prices. An awesome family owned and operated establishment.

Came here on a Friday night with my parents. Had about a 20 minute wait which we were informed of and then were seated promptly in the dining area next to the pub. Our server was the owners son. He was extremely attentive, honest about the menu and funny!
I had the guiness salmon and sweet potato fries and the irish stew. The stew was good, but even the server said he liked it better with the original lamb meat instead of the current beef. I could probably agree with him. The sweet potato fries were to die for!!! seriously AMAZING. Mom ordered the Reuben and normal fries — both very very good. Dad ordered the ham and cabbage soup with a side salad — both of which he really enjoyed.
It is a really adorable atmosphere and I cant wait to go back with my friends to have some drinks at the bar and eat their great food. The live music was fantastic too… A really great place — i’ll be back soon!

Our family has eaten here several times over the last few months. Each time we tried a different item on the menu and have enjoyed everything. One of our favorites is the shepherds pie, and the hamburgers. Would eat there more often if we didn’t look like we are trying to move in. Love it.

This place has awesome food but the service at the bar sucks. Sat without a drink for 15 minutes. The bartender finally came over and it took him another 10 minutes to bring it to me.

This place is simply excellent. It’s a pub, and measured against others it is clearly superior for food. The chef is creative, and seems to take the extra time and effort to prepare his food with very high quality. I had some food that would be common in New Orleans, but not here in Pittsburgh. Was authentic, and excellent. Would be a hit in the middle of Jackson Square in NOLA. I have also had traditional pub type food. The menu offers what you would expect on any Irish Pub menu, but also things that would be considered unusual. The soups I have had are outstanding. The beer selections looked limited, but had both Guiness and Smithwicks on tap — and Harps. At an Irish Pub, the basics are absolutely covered!
This is the type of place to try with an open mind. Very good food. Seems like a nice place, and would highly recommend it.

Good, depending on what you get. Stew in a bread bowl, amazing, but not available on Tuesday. Bangers and mash could use some work. Pierogies, good, but pricy. Funnel cake fries are fricken crazy awesome!

Always on the lookout to try somewhere new, Sieb’s Pub fit the bill. We stopped by on a Saturday afternoon during off hours. Lucky for us, we got one of the pub tables in the bar area. The place was over done on fall decorations. Totally over the top. They have a really cute little patio area, unfortunately with fall weather, the time for that is over.
The menu has lots of choices including steaks and seafood and BBQ ribs and pasta dishes. They also have Irish choices that include Bangers & Mash and Shepard’s pie. We were eating light, so I got the Fish & Chips and BJ got a steak sandwich with onion rings. While, I was not a big fan of the fish, I loved their fries, onion rings and BJ sandwich. He ordered it medium rare and it was served that way. Service was fairly attentive and friendly. I think next time we will be trying the burgers.

Horrible place. We waited 2 hours after putting or names down. The owner who is a blond over weight woman sat her personal friends down before us twice. She claims they take reservations but they don’t. They keep people waiting while they continously seat their friends. Place is a complete joke. Bad service and the sons mom told me to f off. Very unprofessional place and I will never come back here

The chicken pot pie is soooooo good! It comes with a flaky, buttery crust on top. The broth is creamy but not too rich. Everything was excellent, great service and the people are friendly. This is my new place to eat. Want to check out the music on Wednesday nights.

This place has good food, good service, good atmosphere. Mondays and Wednesdays are All You Can Eat crab legs. They recently raised the price though, but it’s not too bad. Especially if you can devour plate after plate of crab! The soup is really great here too, and even comes with the All You Can Eat crab. It can get pretty packed around dinner time, but so far I’ve never had a wait.

This place is great. We like to stop for a few pints and dinner after a long day at work. The food is exceptional. All of it. You have to try the Irish stew in the bread bowl. Excellent!
It’s a family owned and operated pub. The service is top notch. We’re always greeted with a warm welcoming smile when we walk in.
It’s a nonsmoking environment, which is great. The bar area does get crowded, especially when they have live entertainment. I’d suggest getting there a little earlier in order to get seats. You have to check out Bucky, on Wednesday nights. He’s awesome!
They also have an upstairs banquet facility, and offer event catering.
Can’t recommend this place enough!