Uncle Tony’s Pizza

Uncle Tony’s is… fine.
There’s nothing particularly memorable about the pizza either way. We order from them when Nick’s is closed (they’re closed on Sundays. Boo.) The bread sticks are good. Delivery was fast – about 30 minutes, so that was nice.
They messed up our order, which is oddly not surprising because the exact same thing, with the same toppings, had happened to me at another pizza joint. Pineapple on one half, bacon on whole was our order, but we got half and half. Eh. Maybe those two things are not meant to mix.

Great food, great prices. French fries are crispy and delicious, wraps are great, hoagies are huge and you have to try tiramisu it is amazing!

Uncle Tony’s offers fast delivery and typically above average food. There’s not much more I could ask for from a pizza joint.
I’ve had their Regular Pizza, Garlic Parm Wings, and Fries — all above par. I think the Italian hoagie left a little more to be desired but it was still average.

LOVE!
I was first introduced to Uncle Tony’s pizza at a work training in nearby Mt. Lebanon.
After the first bite, I was so glad we ordered from there!
The pizza has a sweeter sauce and just the right amount of cheese.
To me, everything about this pizza is perfect.
WARNING: You will want more than 2 slices!
I’ve also had their grilled chicken hoagie and it was great! The chicken is very fresh and grilled. You can tell that the chicken is not pre-​packaged like the stuff some other pizza places use.
Overall, I am a firm believer that you will love this pizza! Delivery was super fast and it is free! If you’re in the south hills area and looking for a new pizza joint, go here!

I like this place. Their delivery is SUPERFAST and the salads are HUGE

Still not meatball’s. Service is friendly and did not take very long to get our meal.
The pizza is OK. The crust was a little thicker than last time. Just a reminder, the cheese is cooked on top of the toppings.
Had the chicken wings and they are OK.

Eh, I miss Meatball’s, the pizza joint that previously held this spot.
We opted for delivery from Uncle Tony’s last night and made one mistake; we ordered fish sandwiches from a pizza parlor. Never do that.
I know, I hate making generalizations, but these were just nondescript, mushy, and tasteless, just like pretty much every fish sandwich from a pizza restaurant. Dad wanted his fish, though, so…
The wings were overcooked and overseasoned.
The pizza? Call it the bastard child of Mineo’s and Fiori’s. Look up my reviews for those pies before you get excited. I’ll wait…
Ready? Do you see what I’m getting at?
Hey, the crust and sauce were both solidly appetizing, but that cheese, which covers the toppings (something novel that I welcome, actually) just slid off the pie and had that tough texture no melted cheese should ever have. Nonetheless, the pizza was the highlight, and that’s unfortunate.
Why did Meatball’s disappear? I want them back. There needs to be a petition circulating about this.
Cagney and Lacey.
Arrested Development.
Meatball’s?

Ordered delivery on a whim to try something different. Was extremely impressed with the friendly service, great value and size for the pizza, and freshness of the toppings. The pineapple must have literally been sliced fresh; it was unreal.
If there’s any small complaint, the pizza had a ton of sauce, so it was hard to eat by hand.
But overall, a great new place in Dormont!