Cheese House

I liked the Cheese House, but I think Yutzy’s better, EXCEPT for the yummy looking ice cream selection, and the antique shop next door, both of which I’ll have to check out NEXT time! Pretty similar stuff (compared to Yutzy’s) at slightly higher prices. All sorts of jams, jellies, baking supplies, and other «old school/​country style stuff, along with a great variety of cheese and meats. Wishing they had samples, but probably better off that they didn’t!!!
Friendly service, lots of variety, definitely worth a visit!

The cheese shop has fresh vegetables with no GMO’s. I asked Yulty’s 3 times if their vegetables were from GMO seeds and they said yes.

This is a nice little place but I think Yutzy’s beats them. I didn’t really do any shopping because I just came from Yutzy’s but I wanted to check out what they had to offer. I got some ice cream and it was pretty good but I would love to see them offer some homemade ice cream instead of Ruggles. Prices seemed to be a little higher than their competition, but their prices still aren’t too bad.
One thing that is cool is that there is an antique store attached which is something my wife seemed to enjoy.

If it wasn’t for their competition down the street, they may have 5 stars. The Cheese House has some good weekly deals but their everyday meat and cheese prices are a bit higher than their neighbours.
In the past I have enjoyed coming here for a delicious deli sandwich, Ruggles ice cream cones, fudge, cheese, meat, and other bulk goodies. They also carry one of the best dressings/​dips in Hartville Kitchen Dressing especially their Honey Mustard. I stopped in the other day for their deal on Muenster Cheese ($ 2.59 a lb). Most of their cheese comes from Amish country and they also carry some meat and cheese that is chemical free– nitrate free and so on.
They have decent service but I can be a bit confused after I order my meat and cheese because they sometimes just lay it on the counter and you are not sure whose meat or cheese it is. It would be nice if they called it out but this is only an issue when more then 4 people are waiting. They have a better location so they can keep their prices up. I come here second to Yutzy’s.

Definitely more touristy than Yutzy’s around the corner, but still a decent place. Good selection of dry goods, meats, and cheeses. No curds, though, which surprised me. Prices are pretty good, and it’s probably a better place to take the kids for ice cream (though I’d just go to the Eskimo Queen for that…)

Single greatest milkshake ever! Incredible!

The Amish like to keep things simple which I guess explains the name. They have cheese galore and you can get trail bologna, too. I recommend the Vidalia onion cheese.