Which Wich? Superior Sandwiches

Lots of options. Veggie sandwich options also tasty and plentiful. Black bean patty w hummus and tons of added veggies was flavorful and fresh. Would repeat that order.
First visit: Slow, disorganized service, not very friendly. But clean premises & not at all busy (weeknight after 7pm).
Second visit: also weeknight after 7pm, slow sandwich making but clean, not crowded and friendly.
Not happy with kids’ menu on this first & second visit at all. Kids meal success was a flop with all three kids.
Kids’ crustless grilled cheese a joke of a sandwich — hardly a serving of food, –a pair of 3“x1″ tiny weightless bread slims with a sprinkle of cheese. I literally thought the bag was empty by mistake when we got it & was shocked to see the grilled cheese size/​weight in comparison to the other kids’ meat sandwiches (both of those served smushed & thrown together on regular bread, dripping and oozing way too much mayo and mustard, so unappealing & so messy, they gave up, so did I). Suggestion: revise/​double the grilled cheese portion if that is what is considered comparable to the other sandwiches. Would love to see the kids’ sandwiches served on the same bread as adults, even if cut into shorter kid size portion. It would be more substantial & neater for eating as well, plus kids dig a sammy different than what they would have on the plate at home. Additionally the kids’ meal treats were unhealthy, chemical filled choices… would prefer a healthier choice such as a half banana or a handful apple slices, both of which cost cents & take two seconds to prepare. Or offer chips/​cookie instead of the artificial candy/​junk only offered. Kids’ milk only filled ¾ cup. Felt like staff skimping/​lazy on every aspect of kids’ meals, and I don’t spend $ on kids meals that end up in the garbage instead of their tummies. These are my companion diners 99% of the time & I frequent places where they get decent food for a decent price & will eat it up. Fail in that department on all ³⁄₃ counts.

Finally found a wholesome, delicious pulled pork sandwich (with the slaw ON it)! Not sure if it’s «smoked» on a grill first but it tasted so good it didn’t even matter. Usually I’m skeptical of pulled pork from non-​barbecue places because they tend to have more fat than meat, but I swear every chunk of pork I picked up to eat was absolutely meaty, flavorful, and contained zero visible (or tangible) fat! IMPRESSIVE! Plus the fact that you can customize your sandwich to create your own masterpiece. I will most definitely be back to try other sandwiches, but I’m already hooked on one! OH… And the BROWNIES!
OH MY GOODNESS! Awwww JUST GO MAAAN!

Been to this chain before but, in another state. I like to think of this as a step up in sandwiches. My personal viewpoint is: Regarding fast food sandwich chains
starting at the bottom & ascending in terms of food quality, selections, service & enjoyment are: Subway, Jimmy Johns, Quiznos, Cousins, Jersey Mikes –going higher are Firehouse & Which which. (My opinion only)
I like this place cause of they way its set up. You walk in and on the wall they have listed by number, your different proteins, chkn, pork, beef, specialty, etc. also veggie.
They have a number assigned to each main food. Below are a row on bags (numbered). You remove the bag of your main food of choice which has various types of entrees prepared in the category of your choice. A bucket in the counter will have markers. You mark on the bag how you want your sandwich: hot or cold, type, (ie: how do you want that chicken? Buffalo, grilled, etc) size of sandwich, add ingredients, cheese, etc, & continue down the list checking boxes till you have the sandwich you want.
You hand the bag to the cashier & pay and it then becomes an order form for the sandwich maker. Very easy for them to see. Your sandwich is made, wrapped & placed in the bag and handed back to you. If the item you want isnt on your sandwich, perhaps you didnt check the box. Good concept, huh?
Service is good, ingredients are fresh and prices arent too out of line. You ger what you pay for! Good place!

I went with my mom and sister to try this sandwich place for the first time. Let me tell you my first time there will definitely not be my last!
I love how you can choose all the options for your sandwich right on the wrapping your sandwich will be on.
They have several different options to choose from in terms of sandwich variations. I had the chicken pesto with bacon and avocado and other toppings. It was spectacular and both my mom and sister enjoyed their sandwiches a ton!
I signed up for their new Vibe Club membership because I will definitely be coming back to this location for lunch!

Love it! Much better then any other sub place in Plainfield! Much more choices! The customer service is good and place is clean. Priced are reasonable.

I’ve been back many times since my negative review. Each time was good. As I said in the previous review. The sandwiches are phenomenal. It can be slow at time, but it’s usually worth the wait.

Wonderful little sandwich shop. Love the options and the made to order concept. Lots of choices. Our family of 4 all had different options and each we enjoyed. Very flavorful. Would recommend two things — a size small is the perfect size. Medium was huge, which my husband couldn’t even finish. Can’t imagine what the large looks like. Also watch how much stuff you place into your sandwich — more is not always the best. Only negative felt like the price of the ice cream sandwich was too high and I have tasted better cookies before. And the house chips although tasty were just a small amount. Would come back and wish we had one of these on our area.

Staff is friendly and helpful! It was quick to order and to receive my sandwich and shake. I recommend getting the house chips.

Great food, I ordered a pesto chicken with hot peppers and dingleberries my boyfriend ordered a pizza sandwhixh, both were good, the customer service sucked, we came in, no one said hi, I told the cashier I’d be paying with both cash and card and he ignored me, then when I told him again he said «sorry I’m not here today», he was very quiet, I have a feeling they have some greens not on the menu .lol anyways decent place, customer service needs help.

Awesome staff awesome food. Love this place and haven’t had a bad experience in over 50 times going. Use the free app for extra convenience.

Delicious! So quick and easy, even with a toddler. Staff is so incredibly friendly and helpful. The shakes are a bonus.
Try their Black Friday (turkey with stuffing and cranberry) sandwich with Dijon. Seriously good food.

Excellent unique sandwiches, very tasty and healthy. Love the setup, watch out subway and make way for which wich

Loved this concept! Very efficient and no waiting in lines. Kinda tricky for the indecisive because the choices are endless! My sandwich was amazing: black bean patty, avocado, lettuce, tomato, onion, jalapeño, Siracha and honey mustard on wheat. It was a party in my mouth! They need to build one closer to Lemont. My husband said his ham/​bacon was just okay. We both liked the bread and would choose this place over subway any day.

We went there with some coupons and I don’t think I would go out of my way to go back. Their unique sub sandwich thing is to build your own sandwich on a paper bag to order. Think of it as trying to make your own soda flavor. There is so much room for error in not being able to build a good tasting which. If you are trying to build something new it can take a lot of time but I guess they have already put together sandwiches that you can order too?
Sandwich I had was good overall but their own handmade chips don’t live up to the hype. It is your basic sub with a $ 6 – 12 price tag depending on the size and meats you choose.
I am going to stick with the Jersey Mikes concept (fresh meat and cheese cut in front of you when you order) over having 1000 choices to build what you want. If you are a picky eater you will certainly be able to customize your heart out here. For me I just want to quickly order.

Today is my first time being here, was highly recommended by my hubs’ work. So basically you walk in and choose the # bag corresponding to the sandwich you chose. Then specify on the bag what you’d like on it. They do have online ordering FYI. I got the sausage and egg sandwich with tomatoes and spicy mayo. Really good! It’s a bit pricey but worth it.

I think the owner of the place came out from behind the counter to explain the process of ordering a sandwich! I know it maybe a bit daunting to order a wich as the other reviews suggest but as long as you have a helpful staff it’s definitely worth the sandwich! Like i said in my tip the ingredients are so fresh and even the medium sandwich is really filling! Highly recommend coming here!

I was so excited to see a Which Wich being built near my home. I visit this location usually once a week with my husband and every experience we have there is wonderful. We have gotten to know the staff and the manager even recognizes us and remembers the last conversation we had with him. It’s great to have a better sandwich shop in town that gives a variety of healthy choices and great portion sizes. =]

If Which Wich were a little bit closer to Joliet, and a little bit cheaper, it would be my go-​to sandwich shop. The bread is beyond amazing, and they’re pretty quick about making the sandwiches. I suggest you spend the extra buck and get the milkshake, specifically the Oreo one.

Ordering at Which Wich is a bit novel and can be fun. You go into the restaurant and grab a bag and make your selection. You then had the bag off to the cashier and then it operates just like a traditional sandwich shop.
From a selection perceptive, they seem to have an endless list which is nice.
Now on to the food. They charge you a premium price, but give you almost no meat. I ordered a sandwich and I counted 6 pieces of meat on my 10.5″ sandwich. Oh Yeah. That’ll be $ 9 sir.
Rip-​Off. Much better value in the area, and to think I was excited about visiting here.

We went there this evening for dinner and felt that the concept and the food were below average. When we walked in we had to fill out a brown bag to let them know what bread, meat, cheese, topping and how we would like our sandwich (hot or cold).
Ok fine, it’s crafty but truly a waste of paper and time. We also wanted 2 pineapple shakes and a peanut butter cookie. As we approached the register we were informed that we also needed to fill out a separate card for our cookie and milk shakes. Come on, I just want to order my food! When we finally got our food (20 mins after walking inside) I noticed my «turkey and bacon» club sandwich has very little turkey and bacon bites instead of slices of bacon! Really? I just paid almost $ 7.00 for my sandwich and there isn’t anything to it! My husband had the chicken salad on wheat and there was not enough chicken to fill the inside of the bread. (another $ 7.00). The guy that made our milk shakes also wasn’t wearing gloves and he puts the straws in your shake for you! No thanks! We won’t be back! Which wich is over priced for the quality of food you receive. Plan on spending some time there waiting on your below average sandwiches and don’t expect an apology for the wait!