Casa Rosaria’s

I’m considering this a hidden gem because I didn’t find it till 8 months of living in the area. But hands down the best hot sandwich around! Will be ordering much more!

The most horrible food I’ve ever eaten. Very oily chicken sandwich smelled very bad. The cesar salad was also not fresh. Don’t waste your money here.

really almost 1 hr and 45 min and called they still did not send out our food, not happy

Love this place. They have the best Brooklyn pie in the area. I get pick up at least once a week after work when I get out late. I haven’t had their pasta dishes but their pizza is out of this world. Calamari dish is a little small compared to other places but it’s better than other local places.

This place was close and I had a buy one get one half off coupon so I thought I’d give this it try. Ordered delivery and the food arrived fast and it was plentiful but lacked any real flavor. The chicken franchese was bland, no lemony taste. I couldn’t even finish a piece of chicken. Such a waste! My husband’s chicken parm was rubbery and his soup salty. Unfortunately, we won’t be going back.

Ordered delivery. Food arrived in good account of time, delivery guy was an older friendly gentleman (i love seeing older people active)…any who rating of food is from 1−5…Ordered the chicken Florentine (4), it tasted like it should but it wasn’t my style. that one was on me for not knowing what I was ordering. I also got the side. sausage (3) it’s a side so it’s small only like 5 bucks. I also ordered desert canollis… too sweet, tasted good but too sweet don’t count that against the restaurant. I also got a 2 liter soda. the total was $ 26 bucks, that’s not bad at all… I have ordered pizza from this place and I agree with most reviewers, this place is great for pizza and be aware of you go into the other food, you have to know what you are getting. Overall I’ll be ordering from here again specially the pizzas.

I order from this place at least once a week from work in Princeton. I try to get something new every time, and I haven’t been disappointed yet. No delivery fee, great staff, and when I was doing Keto, they were very accomodating. I wish I could give them 6 stars, haha.

Ordered the veal Marsala and stuffed mushrooms. The veal was as thin as paper and only half breaded. Tasted like jerky. The noodles were horribly undercooked. Everything was flavorless and depressing. The mushrooms were swimming in so much grease and oil I filled a dixie cup with it. They were a soggy messy and nothing about them was distinguishable or enjoyable. Never ordering again.

I get the pizza here because it’s cheap… $ 10 for large, or $ 15 for 2 large pizzas. It’s not the best, but it’s good for the wallet and I like to help local businesses.
That being said, I’ve eaten here for sit-​down meals at lunch and dinner. My husband and I like to bring our own bottles, and though we appreciate good service, we also want to enjoy our food and wine without being rushed– which is what we get here. The bread is served hot and fresh, and always starts our meal right. We’ve tried different items on their pasta menu, and everything has been great. My only suggestion on the food is to avoid ordering salad separately… I always felt they didn’t give enough for the price charged (specifically on the caprese and antipasto). So if you want salad, just get the one that comes with your entrée.
We really liked the chicken florentini, and the francese is a safe bet, plus the ravioli aurora is fun. Pasta is served in big portions, so when we go with our kids, we just get 2 – 3 pasta dishes instead of getting one for each person. Check out their website for coupons, too.
As for location, it is kind of a hidden gem because it’s on a residential block with its own parking lot. When you walk in, it’s an old-​school pizzeria with pies displayed, but to the left up a few steps, there are two dining areas with cute and kitschy murals, and fake ivy climbing the walls.

Horrible! It might be good for pizza but nothing else. Every time I’ve gone there I’ve been disappointed. I ordered some garlic bread with my meal and it was so spicy i couldn’t even eat it. Since when is garlic bread even spicy? Not even that but it took forever and we had to keep repeating our order because he just couldn’t get it the first 3 times!

I’ve been enjoying the pizza here for several years and for me it is the best in the area. I always call up and order to eat some there and take home the rest. Crust perfectly cooked, great amount of toppings. Best of all is the friendly greeting from the boss (who makes the pizzas) who has come to know me as a big fan. I’ve never had anything «off the menu» so can’t speak to it, but I know this: you’ll get good food sincerely prepared.
P. S. Sometimes I opt for Papa’s in Chambersburg, but I always come back here for what I consider «real» pizza.

I wouldn’t disagree with reviewers saying this place might have the best pizza in the town of Plainsboro, which is a really small town by the way.
We usually had a late dinner take out of medium or large pizza with chicken wings (around 20 bucks total). I think they are pretty good. The guys working there are pretty nice too.

Service is absolutely horrendous, as are the meatballs. We had the fried ravioli, which came out with our entrees after I specifically asked for it to be brought out before the entrees, it was sub-​par. My boyfriend ordered the tortellini with vodka sauce, the tortellini was way under cooked, not al dente, but crunchy, the sauce was fine. My sister had the chicken parmigiana, which was your standard chicken parm. I had stuffed shells which were good and the horrendous meatballs which were more like mushballs.
Our server as mentioned was awful, not present at all, and when given a coupon took $ 2 off our bill for what was supposed to be half off an entrée. I pointed it out and she fixed it, we did not leave her a tip however, service was THAT bad. Also, beware, they charge for refills for soda. We will go back, but only for take out.

The pizza there is the best in town.

My boyfriend and I discovered this little gem the other night. We received lots of coupons for various eateries around Plainsboro since we moved to the area a few months ago, and I’ve stashed them on the fridge with intent to try different places. Well, I’m glad we picked this one out of the stack.
When we sat down, my boyfriend said, «Everything here is probably good.» I, being a skeptic, replied, «We’ll see.»
The order:
Fried Calamari appetizer — light and crispy, and a pretty good portion although we could have used some more marinara
Soup (pasta figioli and lentil) — both were good, but the lentil was a little bit better. The pasta in my pasta figioli was a little too over-​cooked for my liking.
Ravioli alla Pancini — boyfriend’s dish, which looked amazing when it came out, and tasted delicious. We planned on bringing home left overs for lunch the next day, but my boyfriend didn’t quite hold up his end of the deal. Yea, he said it was so good he just couldn’t stop eating.
Fettuchine with Vodka Sauce — it was the first time I’ve order vodka sauce at a restaurant, but I am hooked! I LOVE this sauce even more when it’s made fresh to order. I think I would have liked it more with Italian sausage or meatballs, but I still really liked the dish. I am definitely going to order this again sometime.
It’s a small restaurant that seems to get more people coming in for take-​out. But for a Wednesday night, I’d say they were doing pretty good. We only live like half a mile from this place, so we’ll probably be coming by a lot more often.
The price was reasonable, especially for the amount of food that is served. The service was very good as well. For a small neighborhood Italian joint, it’s a definite win!

This place is really convenient to where my parents live, so we typically go here to get pizza instead Papa John’s, etc. My parents also love the fact that this place always has coupons, so you can count on getting a good deal.
I haven’t actually eaten in the restaurant or had any of their entrees — we always pick up pizza. They always have the food ready in a reasonable amount of time, and the pizza is pretty good (much better than those chains!).