Anthony’s Pizza

Tried this place for the first time and the pizza was soggy and super greasy! Seven of us ate this pizza and none of us liked it. Even the kids complained that it was ridiculously soggy. Never again!

Horrible people. I previously worked there between March 2015 to May 2015.
so first lets address the unregulated things they do on a daily basis–
* They hire woman under the age of 18 to serve alcohol to the customers
* They hold back pay
* They issue you a food severing license that isn’t even in your name.
* They Don’t use the proper sanitation processes when cleaning Dishes/​equipment
* The kitchen ceiling is covered in mold.
*They drop food on the floor and REUSE IT
Now lets Address how the owners treat people–
They are horribly rude and disrespectful to everyone employee or not– the exceptions are some of the regulars and friends that come in. other than that you better pray your order isn’t messed up or you’ll end up getting kicked out without your money back, or in some cases in a physical altercation.
Now if you’re one of the lucky ones that means you didn’t end up with a pizza that has hit the floor or some previously used utensils.

I was told this was the best place for a cheesesteak sub! I placed an order to go… got home & it was a meatball sub. They messed up my order and only said «sorry» did you eat it… Well half of it I live 25 minutes away… she said oh sorry! SMH I will not be back!

Pizza is good but the service is terrible. They want to charge you extra for cheese or red peppers on take outs. The manager will not even bother to return your calls if your unhappy with their service. I don’t need this place there a lot better pizza places in PSL. They’ll never see me again.

Aweful service. When I went into the restaurant service was not bad. However, ordering for delivery, I had a similar experience as others have discussed. I was told my sub and motz sticks would be ready in 35 minutes. 40 minutes later the delivery driver calls and says he will not deliver to my house, which is only a few minutes from their store. I explained that after waiting the 40 minutes for the food this was unfair and dissapointing. I drive to the plaza they are located in frequently and doesn’t ever take more than a few minutes from my house. I had a rather large tip prepared so his loss. Also, the driver had a bad attitude over the phone. Ended up ordering from Goodfellas which is same distance as Anthony’s and delivers for free as well. food is better from Goodfellas I realized so it worked out. Anthony’s lost a lot of local customers today (coworkers that order with myself, family members living in the area and business orders I make suggestions for) and Goodfellas gained them.

Awesome pizza! Lots and lots of hot cheese just makes me swoon! Love it!
This is truly a pizza joint. Divey, dark; honestly not very inviting. No ambiance. But the pizza! Oh! The pizza. DE-​YUMMY!
And the server who seems always there, Karlee, is AWESOME! Friendly, polite and knowledgeable about their fares. If you must have pizza, suggest Anthony’s! It’s darned good!

Stopped here on the way to Disney, looking for a pizza and salad. Vey friendly service, willing to help in any way. We almost ordered the 24 inch monster pizza, but she explained it was a beast and too much for our small family. We started with the mozzarella sticks, which were fairly standard but full of cheese and came out nice and hot. Next, we had the tossed salad, which is chock-​full of crisp lettuce, tomatoes, and a small amount of other items, as well as mozzarella cheese shredded on top. I am a big fan of crisp lettuce, so this won points with me. The pizza, while extremely tasty, was a bit oily for my taste. We finished the entire regular 16 inch large, and enjoyed it, however. Kids loved it, and it’s a fairly standard pizza joint. Still, don’t hesitate to grab a bite if in the area!

I must say as someone who knows all about the local food joints around PSL Anthony’s has the BEST sub hands down no question! Me and my family have been going here for years mainly for their subs since they’re the only place around that makes their bread homemade and let me tell you that’s the difference big time. I always order a chicken philly and the ingredients are fresh and they load up all of their subs no matter what kind you get. The homemade bread is indescribable since that makes the sub and no other place can come close. Also the service is always spot on and they take care of their customers. Only place to order subs from in PSL.

This is the second time I have tried to order a pizza within an hour of closing time for delivery and was told, «I’m sorry, we’re closed.» I have excused poor customer service for the last time. In the past, I’ve ignored the fact that my pizza was an hour and a half late because they delivered it to the wrong address and all I got was «oops, sorry» from the delivery driver. Anthonys WAS convenient for delivery but I’d rather order Dominos which doesn’t compare if I’m looking to stay home or drive to Tavola on PSL Blvd. SO DONE WITH ANTHONYS! I will not give them another dime of my money, they don’t deserve it!

Pizza is ok, but service is horrible. I’ve ordered from here 3 times and every time they had an attitude and the last time they forgot my order and when I called to speak to the manager he said he has enough business to care about my dissatisfaction. I will not eat here if they paid me

I’ve lived in the area for over 20 years. Port saint lucie sure has its fair share of pizza places. A lot have come and gone but anthony’s has been there for quite a while and I must say out of all the places I’ve tried, this is absolute best pizza in the area. It’s authentic and the service is friendly and quick. Very cheap draft beers as well.