John’s Pizzaria

Excellent pizza plenty of toppings and always delivered hot we’ve had their chicken and plenty of other items on their menu and never had a bad meal I would suggest you give it a try

The biggest drawback was my we tried to order 3 different beers and they were out of all three. They did make up for it by giving us our first beer free.
The pizza was really good, and the Garlic Cheesy bread was best thing we ate. My picky 6 year old loved the bacon, chicken, Alfredo pizza and my Pepperoni & mushroom was good but I thought the crust was a little underdone, but still really good.
Our server was very friendly and was great with the 2 kids in our group. The dinning room was clean and comfortable.
Overall we had a really nice time and would love to come back next time we’re in town to try some of the other things on the menu. I would recommend this place if your looking for a good pizza. It is locally owned and you definitely won’t get a better pizza at one of the chain joints!

Very nice family run business. Great service and nice atmosphere. The ingredients used for the pizza were outstanding. Fresh! We had the pizza with everything on it. The only reason for the 3 stars was the pizza sauce. It was honestly lacking any flavor or character. In my humble opinion the sauce is key along with the crust. Crust was good and on the crispy side. Just wish the pizza sauce was flavorful.

So my boyfriend and I went here before Christmas. Its a small little place and very welcoming. They had a nice selection of beer and pizza of course. It was delicious!!! Crust was just right crispy and tasty. And the toppings were fresh. We got the sausage and pepperoni and onion. It was great!!! The price was very fare. You could call and reserve a spot. There were two large groups when we were there but if you don’t come early it gets packed as there’s 4 booths and two tables. But I would recommend this place to anyone!

Here is my experience from 11÷14÷15
Before we dinned in, I called the restaurant;
Me: «Do you offer a gluten free pizza?»
Employee: «Yes, We do.»
Me: «I will see you guys soon.»
My wife has special dietary concerns and I was excited that we can have a date night here. Being new to the Port Washington neighborhood, we were excited and hopeful this would be our go to pizza place.
When we get to the restaurant, they were at capacity. The server said it would be about 45 min for the next open table. Not a problem, she took down our phone number and told us she would call us when our table is ready. The wife and I go next door for a drink. 45 min or so passes and we still haven’t heard anything. We figure, what the heck, let’s go check it out to get an updated.
*****Here is where it goes bad*****
Upon our return, there are multiple tables open. The hostess/​waitress see us and says «oh, you guys can sit there.» As she points to the back booth. My wife and I got the feeling if we didn’t stop back in we would have never received a call telling us the table is ready, but there is no way to prove that so moving on.
We sit down and we wait and wait and wait… In the meantime a group of 10 come in off the street and are promptly given menus, and they place their order. Finally the waitress comes to us and gives us our menus. We were greeted by a «Sorry, I keep forgetting about you guys.»
In our time waiting we pulled up the menu on our phones and try to place an order when she delivered our menus.
Me: ” …and we will try that pizza with the gluten free crust.“
Waitress: «Um, that one doesn’t come in gluten free.»
Me: «Ok, which pizzas come gluten free?»
Waitress: «actually none of them do.»
Me: «Are you sure? I called before we came in and was told you guys offer gluten free.»
Waitress: «Oh, that was probably our dishwasher. He doesn’t know anything.»
So glad I called ahead and waited 45 min for this. We asked if they had any gluten free options and it was clear that there wasn’t.
After the mix up the waitress didn’t say «I’m sorry» or «is there anything I can do to make up for the mix up» or anything like that. I was obviously upset and disappointed. I felt like the waitress couldn’t care less about our situation that her company put us through. As a potential customer I felt disrespected and like I wasn’t valued.
The waitress was young, straight light brown hair with glasses. I include this so the owner can address the issue and give the proper training that is needed.

I’m up in Port Washington from Chicago, as you know, we can be a bit smug about our pizza. I had the pizza delivered to my hotel room and was surprised at how great this pizza is. Great cheese, loaded with toppings and a crispy crust. The Right up there with the best pizza you can get in Chicago.

Ran in quick fior a Pepperoni Pizza to go; crust was thin and amazing, pepp was not greasy, tons of fresh cheese and I didn’t order extra. Nice surprise at the end, waitress told me about their cheesecake made from scratch– OMG!!! Got two slices to go as well, made points with my wife. GREAT wait-​staff as well, great!

Great service and Good food. The toppings and sauce were really good. The crust needed a hotter oven or stove it was a little greasy and chewy but over a good experience.

My wife and I stayed at the Holiday Inn in Port Washington, Wisconsin.
Ordered John’s pizza due to Unilocal reviews. I was NOT disappointed!
Delivered promptly, VERY fresh, and TONS of toppings! I was eating it for the next four days, and I got the next to the biggest one.
And the garlic cheese bread is to die for! Gimmie some more! :-)
Wish we had this establishment in our Missouri area! Mucho Kudo’s to John’s!!!

If you are looking for a pizza in Port Washington, John’s is the place to go. Their pizza is always amazing! My wife and I often order carry out, and have never had a bad pizza from John’s. They also have a heart stopping garlic cheese bread that is top notch. I highly recommend a John’s pizza to everyone!

The pizza here is outstanding! The best you’ll find in Port.
They are very generous with the toppings, especially the cheese, and everything has a true homemade taste to it. The crust is delicious, personally I prefer the double dough but everyone else in my house is a thin crust fan and they cannot get enough.
My favorite thing on the menu though, even above the pizza, is the cheesy garlic bread. It is a delicious loaf of fresh Italian bread, covered in cheese and bursting with garlicky goodness. It is a must order in my house.
Do not expect to pay the prices that Pizza Hut and Domino’s offer, you have to pay more to get better quality as with everything. Worth the money and the trip and will make you look forward to pizza night even more than you already do.

This is my absolute favorite pizza place in Port Washington! And, one of my favorite pizza places, in general.
Hands down, I recommend their chismo — cheese, sausage, mushroom and onion. It is so so so good! And, there is no need for extra anything (cheese, toppings, sauce). They put just the right amount of everything on it. It’s a thin crust. Not super thin, but definitely not a thick crust.
Whether you are eating in or carrying out, be prepared to wait. I’ve carried out several times, and more often than not, it takes longer than they say. I’m not talking a couple minutes. I’m talking 15+ minutes. I have only eaten in once. However, there was a fairly long wait for the pizza. Much longer than other typical pizza place, from my past experience. Don’t let the wait deter you from trying out this place. Just be prepared to wait for some awesomeness that is John’s pizza.

Best Pizza in town! Locally owned. One of my personal favorites. I’m trying to think of my favorite but I’ve never had a bad one. The garlic bread is also outstanding. Give it a try, you won’t be disappointed.

We ordered carry out pizza. It was way underdone. We walked 2 blocks home and half the toppings slid off the pizza. Barely even cut, had to recut every slice. Sausage lacked any flavor. Considering they have only 3 pasta dishes on the menu we thought pizza would be the star. We thought wrong.

This Pizza is always the best by far, and let me also add, the best garlic bread. Love It!

This is the type of place that we love to support! It’s family run and they take excellence seriously. We ordered a double-​dough Hawaiian pizza. Ingredients were fresh and plentiful. Pizza came out a little under-​done, but they quickly cooked it more to our preference. And it was great. We then enjoyed homemade cheesecake of the day, which happened to be a turtle cheesecake and quite delicious. While we just had the pizza, the menu was extensive with a number of sandwiches, homemade soups, pastas, and other family-​friendly options – and the prices were surprisingly low. I wish we had a place like this closer to home; we would be visiting often. Well done!

I loved this place! Growing up in Chicago I would travel and stay in port Washington at least once a year. I never had food from johns pizza but it is amazing! I had the bbq chicken pizza yummy! Make sure to get their double dough! My fiancé had their ravioli with meatballs. He kept telling me with every bite how wonderful it was! If it staying in the area this place is defiantly a must have!

I almost always go to John’s for carry out. I’ve sat down for dinner there twice, the service was fine.
The food is quite good, for the most part. The mozzarella sticks are in eggroll wrappers and are presented nicely. I love deep fried, breaded cauliflower so I’m a fan of that. The beef sandwich is good. I just plain don’t go nuts for pizza, so when I do eat it it’s usually just fine with me however it’s done. I’m not a connoisseur, but my friends who love pizza say this is great pizza. You can see them rolling out the dough in the kitchen, so it’s fresh and handmade.
On the down side, it’s a small place so if it’s busy, you’ll be waiting for your food. Like I said, I order carry out so it’s not a problem. But I’ve been in there where people are complaining about the wait, and you can clearly see they’re overwhelmed.
If you’re in town, it’s good, solid, reasonably priced food in a nice atmosphere. If you’re in a hurry, check to see how many tables are full and make a decision on that.

Yikes this was truly horrible. My husband and I sat in the dining room and did not order any pizza. That may be good, but I won’t be trying any soon. We had a quesadilla appetizer which was so tiny! Not the typical large shell used by every other restaurant. My husband had the shrimp. He said it was awful (and he is not picky when it comes to shrimp). I had the chicken alfredo. Where was the sauce? There was a large amount of mozzarella cheese melted over the top of plain noodles. Geez, if you’re out of sauce let me know and I’ll order something else – you’re not pulling one over on me with that mess! The dish had a plastic taste to it so it was obviously stored in plastic and reheated in plastic. Finally, the waitress only paid any attention to my husband. Hahaha, this was humourous and gave us a good laugh all night because she so blatantly ignored me but really, how unprofessional!

The best pizza around! They have a great selection of appetizers and drinks, too. I think the prices are a little steep, but it’s worth it. They deliver, but they’re not open until 4 or 5pm, so don’t plan on getting lunch.