Pizza Nostra

The Combination pizza is fantastic. The sausage is my favorite in town. The crust is just the way I like it– not too thick, not too thin, and a perfect balance between chewy and crunchy.

two of five orders have now been wrong. fake-​ass vegetarian «bacon» is offensive, creamy garlic sauce does not tend to be red and tomato flavored, and how hard is it to NOT CUT the pizza? we’re done with you

I love Pizza Nostra! The pizza is great, and the cinnamon bites are amazing (if you haven’t tried them, you need to!). My current favorite local pizza spot.

I am a pizza critic.
I always seem to find something wrong with it, or I have just had delicious pizza and its hard to compare.
I decided to try Pizza Nostra because it was Monday, and what makes people happier then some good pizza?
Nothing.
I ordered the La CARNIVORE and substituted the standard marinara to their special pesto sauce which literally blew my mind away. YUM. YUM. YUM!!!
It is NY style pizza; perfectly thin, not overcooked, not over anything, its just delicious. I highly highly suggest, regardless of what pizza you get, to add the sausage to it. It is the best sausage i’ve had on pizza, probably ever.
I would also like to mention that the crust, is the type of crust you don’t leave hanging, its as good as the entire pizza. Not chewy, not burnt, not hard, its like slightly fluffy and compliments the rest.
I’m not sure what the people below are complaining about, I thought I was picky lol. Whatever issues they might have had in the past, it’s in the past. They started early on their whole «new year new me» thing. Place was clean, service was great, detailed and friendlly, and most importantly, food was delicious.
Go try it :)!

Ordered at 8:16pm when they close at 9pm. I felt bad but their delivery window closed at 8:45 so figured a half hour before the window closed was fine. The pizza and wings got here before 9pm, which was great, but when we opened the boxes, they did not cut the pizza and our very bare wings had no dipping sauce. The pizza was okay, I didn’t enjoy the crust and had to add my own bbq sauce to the bbq pizza, but the experience really rubbed me the wrong way. I understand mistakes can be made but it really felt out of spite. I have worked back of house for years and I remember lazily making the last order of the night when I was a shitty kid, angry that customers were still ordering food. I guess karma is coming back to me.

I like the Veggie Nostra. Its not the greatest pizza I have ever had, but it is still really good and always fresh.

The «crispy bacon» isn’t bacon at all, it’s chewy no flavor turkey bacon. And an «hour» is really two hours. Beware.

I dig this place for a few reasons:
1. They are one of the few places that will deliver to my house, for whatever reason
2. Their basic pizzas are pretty dang good.
I try to always give some of the more artisan pizzas a try on their menu, but it’s usually hit or miss for me personally, but what gets them the higher rating is their ability to make a basic cheese, pepperoni, or sausage/​olive pizza really, really well.
I’m definitely not knocking their other pizzas, I just prefer their take on the classics :)
I’d definitely recommend Pizza Nostra for a tasty pie.

I ordered delivery first and then read reviews second. I was pretty scared after I read about food poisoning, dirty kitchens, and incompetent staff. But the food arrived on time, was made as ordered, and most importantly was good. *wipes sweat from forehead* phew! Glad I survived that one.

Visiting from northern CA with my wife, 2 kids and another family of 5 and decided to order in. Looked at some tell reviews and gave this place a try for delivery. I ordered 4 large pies and sidelined a salad and was quite disappointed when the delivery driver showed up one hour and forty five minutes later when our kids were ready for bed. I paid $ 105 plus tip for an average of $ 26 per pie. My combo was good but had soggy crust, the veggie was good, but had soggy crust, the pepperoni was the best and the cheese was so burnt that my kids wouldn’t even eat it. Not happy

This review is for the pizza I ordered. and its subsequent delivery.
They were both lacking — no joke.
I get it that if you call on Friday at 645 it’s going to take 90 minutes but this took even longer. One kid and my husband had both passed out by the time it showed up.
(hell yeah we live large on Friday nights!)
I contacted them after 15 minutes past the delivery on the EAT24 app and it took another 10 minutes for that person to locate the pizza which she said was 15 minutes (or so) away.
I get that businesses get slammed, and all the shit that happens on a busy Friday but hey how about a phone call? Or maybe an apology when the barely just barely cooked through pizza arrived? Nope. Not a word.
The pizza itself was under sauced and the crust was indeed the opposite of crusty, more in the realm of mushy. I just don’t want to waste my pizza nights on this lackluster place so from now on I won’t.
Guys — get yer shit together or drop the delivery, and a little Customer service couldn’t hurt which is why ya’ll are getting TWO freaking stars.
Bollocks…

Ordered a medium half combination/​half Hawaiian pizza for pick up — $ 15
Pizza and was so good my best friend & I finished the entire thing lol.
Great service as well.

My fiancé and I just moved into the neighborhood and found our pizza place. First time we ordered they showed up when they said if not earlier, and the pizza was amazing. I just ordered again tonight and once again here right when they said and great pizza.
Thanks pizza nostra! You guys are great!

Awesome NY style pizza! Generous toppings, chewy crust, delivered still hot. The garlic cheese sticks are delicious. This will be out go to delivery spot for sure. It’s also well priced and I absolutely feel you get your money’s worth. Check it out if you like NY pizza!

I wish I could stop ordering from here. Alas, the cheese breadsticks are too damn good. Then I get to the pizza… My standby is pepperoni, bacon, and fresh mozzarella. The bacon is real, the pepperoni is crisp, and the sauce is simply outstanding. The garlic aftertaste is awkward, but the food isn’t overpoweringly garlicky. On top of it, delivery is always reasonably fast, and perpetually friendly.
I’m sure there are better pizza places in town, but none of them let me order through Eat24 and then show up at my house like magic 45 minutes later. … Be right back, I have a pizza to order.

I order pizzas here for work events and I’ve had pretty much all the pizzas here. The Chicken Garlic pizza is the way to go with a side of marinara sauce on the side for dipping. Everyone at work loves this pizza so much that’s all we order now.

Had pizza delivered from here on a Sunday night around 8pm. They arrived in less time than estimated (around 40 minutes) and ordering was a breeze using the Unilocal/​Eat24 mashup.
The DIY pizza (starts at $ 13.99) was made just the way I like it (obviously, because I designed it!) with pepperoni and olives. The key to this perfect pie was the spicy sauce. Usually when a pizza place offers a spicy version of their marinara, I roll my eyes because it won’t have any flavor and ends up just tasting like marinara. This one, however, had a nice kick to it! The crust was doughy and sweet on the outside while being crisp enough to hold the toppings just right in the middle without being a flop fest.
The cinnamon bites were ordered to meet the $ 15 delivery minimum. I would have preferred them a bit ooey gooey-​er, but I think the delivery time messed with that a bit. However, they were a nice sweet treat to kick off the meal! And, I think they have the potential to make some really great French toast bites!
I highly recommend the pizza for a night of couching it up!

Every couple months I stop in for the $ 20 Giant 26″ Cheese pizza.
Never a disappointment, the service friendly, the price is right, the pizza is good.

Yes. Yes.
If you’re a fan of Gladstone Street Pizza, you will like Pizza Nostra (probably more).
The margherita is solid. A lot of pizza places in the Portland metro use basil chiffonade on their pizzas (like Gladstone), and it’s usually because they want to use less basil. Pizza Nostra uses whole basil leaves, optimizing the basil factor on your pizza. Bonus points.
Also, their crust is superb. Not too chewy, a bit fluffy, perfectly pliable. Their pizza is affordable, and their options are nearly endless. Win.

So I’ve gotten to visit many establishments in my adopted Beaumont Wilshire neighborhood. This was one I hadn’t been to and being that I am a pizza snob, I was hesitant. I was out walking my neighbors dog. A large nine year old puppy of a Golden Retriever. He needed snacks, I need food. He got his fill at Green Dog and I chose to stop here, basically because it had some covered outdoor seating and it was raining. Shocker.
They had a combo of a slice, salad and drink so i went for a pepperoni slice and Greek dressing. The salad was standard iceberg with a few extra veggies, nothing impressive. The pizza is exactly what you’d expect. Nothing memorable with pepperoni on it. It was what it was. There is more pizza to try in this town, and that is what I will do.