Beekman Square Diner

I always come here it’s close to my house etc. but the quality of the food is like flipping a coin. Even if everytime you go there you order the same thing it’ll be different each time. I like the atmosphere and the waitresses for the most part. My favorite is Alison, my least favorite is a [spanish?] guy not sure of his name always gets something wrong. over all I think it’s a decent place just wish it was more consistent with the quality

Had a horrible experience today 12÷31÷15 at 10:50, went for breakfast with my son and food was not cooked the way I requested, cheese looked like it was flopped on to bacon and egg and the roll was not toasted. After witnessing the waitress cleaning her nose with her bare hands. I asked to take back my sandwich and have them cook it the way I requested, she came back much later and my appetite was lost. Approached the scrunchy dirty looking gentleman behind the register and tld him that I wanted to speak with the owner to let him know how unsanitary it is for someone to mess with there nose and handle food and he had no concern and was very nonchalant abt the situation, His response was today is New Years eve, there is only one cook. I don’t recommend this Diner to anyone, guess the Daily Planet wld be getting my service from now on. Horrible Service and Food. Unprofessional. Really sad cause I loved this place before.

Went for an early dinner with the fam and although it looked busy, there were still plenty of seats inside. I get an Italian restaurant vibe from the décor in this place, not a diner, but I’m not complaining; I liked that more ‘upscale’ look. Waters were brought immediately to the table, and we settled in with the menus.
Our waitress overall, was just not friendly. She tried to be, but seemed anxious to be done with us and made a few jokes with a straight face so. maybe they weren’t jokes afterall? She made the entire dinner experience loose a star.
Most of us started with the French onion; a usual diner staple and it was excellent and how I expected, comfort soup. Ladies had plain burgers, eggplant parm and I had the mussels app. I forgot it wasn’t a legit Italian joint, otherwise I don’t think I would have ordered seafood. Burgers were big, but the plain version just looked SAD! I would have loaded mine up with goodies like cheese, shrooms and sauce but oh well, they wanted them bland. The size for the price was a deal either way. Mom’s eggplant parm over angel hair looked ok, I wasn’t convinced she LOVED it. still ate it though. My mussels were ok, but for $ 11, I was hoping they would have been legit PEI and a decent size. There were a little over a dozen of them, but dude, they were baby mussels. They fit on one prong of my fork. Out of the bunch there were 2 decent mouth hole sized bites. The rest should have been thrown back and gone through puberts first.
I was content but I knew I was going to be hungry again within a few hours (and I was by 10pm. Oh well)
I would return to try something else for sure. The place was clean and service fast– I would just hope on a next trip that same waitress would have the day off bc she was a scowly-​face. Their burger and brew deal for $ 11 sounds dope and I want to try that fo sho.

LOVE this place! I moved into the area not too long ago and was really upset of the lack of eatery around, but this place makes up for it. I go pretty
often and have never been let down. Service is very friendly and fast, and the food is delicious and well priced. I bring all my friends there and they all say the same thing… «damn this is a good diner»

I went to the Beekman Square Diner tonight for the first time, and I have to say that my experience was fantastic! We ordered the Potato Chip Fondue as an appetizer and it was heavenly. I had the cheese ravioli with meatballs and my boyfriend had the chicken chipotle panini, and both dishes were amazing!
The portions were big, the food was fresh, and the service was friendly and fast. The owner even stopped by to see how our meal was. I really enjoyed my dining experience and I will certainly go back for more!

Love this place, always have, always will. Been going here for 20 years… ever since it was the Five Star Diner. Best gyros, yummy breakfast and delicious french fries. Their salads are enormous and the service has always been spot on. Was never really crazy about the desserts in the case up front.

I recently moved to the area and was looking for my new breakfast spot for when friends are in town. I have to say I was incredibly impressed with the Beekman Square Diner. It was clean and newly renovated and the owner spent some time talking to me and welcoming me to my new home.
Our server was very pleasant and efficient. I ordered a Greek Omelet and my friend ordered banana nut pancakes. We both enjoyed our meals and will be back to enjoy another breakfast another day.

Food has really gone down hill. I don’t know if the chef left or they just don’t care. We are finding other places to eat even if we have to drive further away. Too bad because the male owner is a very nice man.

Good food! A tad pricey for a «diner» type place, but most of the food is worth it. As of the last year I have a noticed a bump in the quality of food and preparation, I assume they got a new chef and it’s paying off. Breakfast food, soups, wraps, and burgers are almost good. They also have 6 different types of french fries you can get which is nice when you need your grease and cheese fix. Nicely furnished and service is decent. Have had great waiter/​tress and have had horrible ones. But it’s like that most places you go. Overall a 7.8÷10. I go about once every two months.

For a diner they be got great consistent food. I wouldn’t bring a date but definitely friends. The staff is typically friendly and fast. My girlfriend and I have a running joke that soon they’ll have our order ready before we even sit down. Also the place recently had a remodeling and looks good.

I love this restaurant. The potato chip dip appetizer is delicious. I’ve had a variety of meals here, all have been wonderful. The service is excellent too.

I don’t even consider this your average diner!!! Great food! Great service!!! Everything is so tasty!!! Have not been disappointed yet… :)

This place is close to my house, so I’ve been here several times in search of a near (–ish) bite. It’s much bigger than it seems from the outside and I’ve never had to wait for a table no matter when I go. The service has always been great as well. The food is good, a little more updated and varied than typical diner fare but still pretty basic. I loooove the sweet potato fries. I think the prices are a little high for what you get (9.50 for a sandwich? really?) and I wouldn’t necessarily go out of my way, but it’s a nice place to eat.