Sweet Tooth Cottage

Took a trip to Sweet Tooth for the first time yesterday. The bakery is cute, the employees are friendly and attentive, and the sweets are fantastic! We bought PB cookies drizzled in chocolate, Buckeyes, salty caramel cookies, and no bakes… all of which were well worth the visit.

The cookies are to die for!
I have used them for a few events and the cookies are a show stopper and are fabulous as well!
And I am sad to admit there is a pick up window!
Great addition to Powell!

Sweet Tooth Cottage is a nice and sweet addition to the Powell area!
Although the nicely decorated interior, and rented strip mall storefront doesn’t necessarily mean they are a new contender in the realm of Northern Columbus sweets.
In fact, I was informed by the owner that Sweet Tooth had been operating in her home for a while doing special orders, and decorated sugar cut outs for parties and other occasions.
Experience shows here. The cookies are decorated perfectly! They’re EXCELLENT for celebrations, or the office potluck. They have some skilled ladies (maybe gents) working here.
I smell a second coming Cheryl’s Cookies here, folks. The sugar cookie cut outs take the cake!
Sweet tooth also focuses wholly on cookies. No other gimics, or unfocused travesties here. Cupcakers look elsewhere. (At least for now)
Sweet Tooth also offers other types of sweet treats like salty caramel cookies (one of my faves), Chocolate no bakes, banana chocolate chip cookies, and just your regular chocolate chip cookie. Although they were good, but the last time I was in the chocolate chips were running a bit on the soggy side from too much butter on the bottom. Not going to ding them for that, though, because the other selections were great.
It’s a shame they’re kinda tucked on the unseen side of the strip mall off of Sawmill PKWY, because they may not get as much foot traffic as they deserve.
«Sweet-​tastical», professional and YUMMY!