Anna’s Prospect Pizza

Pizza is subpar, not good, not great. Everything else on the menu is fabulous, amazing, perfection! Absolutely delicious and properly made every single time, nothing is ever over or undercooked or ever burned. got the pizza twice, never better, just acceptable, probably not for everyone but that’s fine.
Only issues are that if you’re not going in person delivery takes FOREVER. Over a half hour for one meal, but still worth it! Just try to be hungry earlier lol. This place deserves rewards & needs to be open 7 days, losing business on the strange off day. Can’t say enough good things about this place, even the phone staff is nice and courteous, and delivery drivers are friendly too albeit the time it takes. all around good folks here.
check your mail for coupon flyers with the menu, that’s how I found out about this place.

Though we have not tried the pizza Their other food is AWESOME! Especially the salads their Cesar dressing is the best I’ve probably had as well as their mozzarella sticks. Delivery people are always so nice. Never had a bad meal we order at least once a week. Highly recommend!!!

Very poor service and they never want to take their own coupons. I am not talking about expired coupons either. Very very poor customer service!!!

Wouldn’t honor the price on the menu that they DELIVERED TO MY DOOR! Then the pizza arrived and the crust was burned. $ 24 for a large, burned pizza. Overpriced. Poor quality. AVOID

Anna’s has the best pizza around by far. They have great specials, a wide variety of choices. We’ve had them several times cater the meals for several events or parties.

I’m very picky about my pizza, grew up on traditional New Haven pizza, but I love Anna’s pizza! Tried several pizza places in the area and yuck, then we found Anna’s, it’s become Sunday must for two years. The owner takes pride in his food and wants every pie to be great. Another review said food was hit n miss, I can say that in two years we’ve had only a couple pies that were not quite perfect, but still very good compared to other places. Wings are very good too. Try Anna’s you won’t be disappointed. Takeout or delivery only and they deliver to Naugatuck!!!

Hmm, what to say about Anna’s? What I’ve come to learn about Anna’s is that their quality is hit or miss.
When my wife and I first started ordering Anna’s, every time we got the pizza and wings it was amazing. Over time, it’s become more sporadic; some nights the pizza and wings are awesome, sometimes not; sometimes the wings are plump, juicy and tasty, and other times they’re small and dry.
I really hope Anna’s pays attention to their reviews because, as one other reviewer put, I really want to LOVE Anna’s, as I did in the beginning.

We were in town to see my nieces and newborn nephew, and we were hungry. My sister recommended the pizza at Anna’s in Prospect. I ordered two pies — one with pepperoni and bacon and the other with mushroom. The prices for the size of the pizza were fair and the time it took for them to prepare the pizza was right in line with how long they said it would take.
The pizza tasted pretty good. I didn’t really taste the flavor of the toppings though — I would have guessed a quality cheese pizza if I was blind-​folded, as the flavor of the cheese, sauce and crust were very good and overpowered the toppings. You can even smell the Parmesan cheese through the box!
Anyway, if you live nearby, make sure to take advantage of the coupons on the flyers if you happen to receive their flyers in the mail. On the grand scale of pizza places, this was pretty good but no where near the best I’ve ever had. Definitely no where near the worst either, so 3 stars is adequate for me!

Service was excellent and very friendly. Unfortunately, pizza was some of the worst pizza I have ever had. Half bbq half cheese. The crust was thinner than a 8×11 piece of paper and piled with greasy toppings.
I struggled to eat the cheese and only took one bite of bbq.

Fresh ingredients… friendly people… great prices! Enjoy getting my takeout from Anna’s! Let me tell you the calzones are huuuuuge and by far the bourbon wings are out of this world. Very tasty and addicting! Looking for good quality pizza in the Naugatuck/​Prospect area? Please check them out!

Love love love Anna’s. Food is always fantastic. (Have you tried the chicken parm? Soo good!) I normally get delivery and even though they say it will be 45 to an hour, it’s always delivered so much sooner! Portions are huge. Service is always fantastic. My number 1 choice for take out!

Very disappointed. My husband and I liked this place a lot until tonight. We thought they had the best pizza and wings in the area but no longer. We ordered wings and they were small, all bones, no meat, and previously frozen! Total garbage. My husband called to speak with he owe we and he blew him off saying he was too busy to talk!!! Really you sell your food but are too busy to talk about the quality? Shame on you!!!

Seriously, a pretty good pizza. We tried one the other day for the first time and I would definitely return. Be advised its take out only. the pizza heats up remarkably well… We asked not to have the pizza cut so its not so messy to slide it onto a screen and toss in the oven, and it turns out great… once it’s heated we just cut it with our pizza cutter. We ordered the margherita, which was good, even though I found the fresh sliced tomatoes distracting, as they seemed to compete with the sauce… not a big deal, but i would probably ask to have them omitted the next time. The cheese was very good, not rubbery or overly salted. Overall a nice pizza and a great option for when were running late and don’t want to deal with cooking dinner.

A really excellent pie is served here. A little sloppy for takeout, but manageable after the first few bites… fold in half and enjoy. And at $ 2 a pop for a cheese slice, who’s gonna argue about a little slop?
Dare I say the best part is the sauce? I don’t know what they use or where they get it from, but it’s an incredibly sweet variety, which tastes really excellent with the salty and melty cheese.
Just know that Anna’s is strictly takeout; there’s little more than a front door, a counter, and a kitchen here. What with the cold weather, I was forced to enjoy my slice in the car. Nevertheless, I look forward to enjoying more slices from Anna’s. You gotta love the motto written on the wall…
«You don’t have to go to New Haven.»
It’s true, you don’t.

Anna’s or prospect pizza does a great job of trying to make pizza in the New Haven Wooster street style. Thin crust Italian style. Very good. Best in the area. Also fills the box with a semi square shaped pizza. I recommend highly.