Stefano’s

Very good pizza and prompt delivery. On a fishing trip and it hit the spot after being waders all day. Gave four stars cause I am a pizza snob living in area with 300 pizza places in a 5 mile radius :)))

Pizza good with fresh vegetables and just the right amount of cheese. The Antipasta was a bit too heavy on meat and not enough lettuce. Lisa provided excellent service. $ 8 for a small glass of cheap wine was far too expensive for this type of place.

Solid NY Style Italian food. Larger selection of menu items including a lot of different pasta dishes. We had the buffalo wing pizza as well as the white pizza. Both were pretty good. Jalapeño poppers were good as well. Friendly staff, quick service.

Excellent pizza. Delicious. stop ever year. friendly service. Only problem is garlic knots are small like knot in shoelace and way undercooked. Also toppings r ni t put on pizza till after it comes out of oven. WTF

Great pizza and wings. What else could you ask for? They do a great job. I got delivery and it was fast and hot. Great for football Sundays. Definitely worth a try. By far the best pizza and wings in the area! What are you waiting for?!

Really terrible food. Got food delivered: calzone with mushrooms, sausage, and hot peppers, spaghetti marina with meatballs, garlic knots, and cinna knots.
Every single thing ordered was pretty disgusting. The calzone was limp with grease leaking out. The spaghetti was bland and the knots were just balls of oil and butter.
Never getting anything here again.

Food is great. Hometown vibe is strong. Be prepared to wait during tourist and fishing seasons. Service can be somewhat uneven. Conserve your beverage. If they offer you a table for two in the corner, decline. You need a tea set to accommodate.

I remember their location in Carthage from my days in NNY, always good food and service. This Pulaski location, well can you say unprofessional and rude? While visiting in NY i placed an order here & picked it up. They forgot part of my order, band i had to make the trip back to get the rest of the food and I asked to speak with a manager. The owner’s wife was there that night, but too concerned with socializing with the «regulars» to be bothered to come to the counter. For being such a small town she acted very stuck up and snooty. When she did come up then promptly ran out back to take a supposed phone call. She obviously does not care about her husband’s business or the Stefano family name. I left, and ended up eating cold pizza. Next time I’m in the area I’ll try Paulanjo’s.

Simply said, I just love this place!
It is certainly a local, family run establishment which I tend to like over chain locations.
The pizza and wings here are outstanding! It is that simple. The the large pizzas are good sized (we only get large… that is how good they are) and always come with plenty of toppings! No, refrozen stuff here!
Now, if you’re a health nut, you may not like this aspect, but in my book, «one» of the characteristics of a great pizza is that a small pool of grease will form in the center of the pizza… if you’ve never seen this, then you’ve not had great pizza and you can do so by coming right here.
The wings here are also outstanding. They don’t fool around with undersized chicken parts where the wing is about the size of your pinkey or thumb… no way… here they are much larger. These wings have a ton of meat on them. They also offer several degrees of heat, so most likely they’ll accommodate the various desires of any group or family coming here wanting to share some wings.
This place can get packed, so you need to time it right. We’ve found getting here on the tad early size works well!
Oh yea… and I can’t forget about the staff. They are friendly and get the job done and most important, they make sure your glasses don’t go empty!

The pizza crust was too thick and doughy for my taste and overall it was mediocre.
The garlic knots were good.
The Cesar salad had dry not-​so-​fresh chicken in it as if it were not cooked to order and held in a cold tray.
The owner may be from Sicily but apparently didn’t learn to cook there.

We came here after a whitewater rafting trip on the Salmon River. In this instance, Stefano’s was fine. We were tired from all the paddling and wanted something warm to eat. This would be a two star pizza joint if it wasn’t for the fact that they have some of the more unique toppings, like eggplant and artichokes, that I didn’t expect to find. The pizza (sauce especially) was unspectacular, but after a river rafting trip, it’ll do.

Our pizza was great. I especially liked the crust. Price was ok. Service was good. We will certainly go back again.

My idea of a good «family run» Pizzeria & Restaurant! The ambiance is great «Italian Soccer Teams Theme», Plenty of seating, My family and I have ordered just about everything that is on the menu over the years and have been happy with just about all the dishes (I’m picky, so there are some things that sound good that I end up not eating a second bite of).I am a HUGE fan of their thin crust pizza, stuffed shells, calzone, and calamari. I didn’t give it 5 because I think the prices are a little too high for the amount of food you get in each order. The wait staff also becomes «forgetful» sometimes.