Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery

Tyler, Chuck, and the entire staff are extremely friendly, courteous, and truly makes you feel «at home». The pizza and homemade bread is beyond amazing. It’s all homemade in a brick oven and some ingredients are home grown right on site. Truly a place you won’t regret going to dine!

The best pizza and bakery place in Columbus: always fresh and tasting great! That’s the only place where my husband and I are getting bread and bakery stuff from. We like to experiment with different types of pizza (which they are always willing to make for us) and still deciding on our favorite one :) The guys working there are awesome people who is always friendly and nice! Great place, I recommend you try it!

Wonderful hometown pizza shop. Friendly staff and quality pizzas and desserts! Yum-​Mo!

Sometimes I really hate that you have to be honest with these reviews. This is one of those times. The lady at the counter was so warm and friendly. The baker, an industrious hard worker who you can’t help but admire for the way he tackles life. I WANTED to give these guys five stars. But… honesty. Ugh.
I had the candy corn pie and chili calzone. The first is essentially a cheese pizza made to look like candy corn. I don’t know how you can mess up a cheese pizza, but it was not good. Wrong spices or something? Normally, I’ll finish off an entire pizza in 24 hours. This one, I had two slices and that’s all I could stomach. The calzone was only marginally better. Originally I wanted the noted chili roll, but was told they didn’t have any today. So, calzone. And it wasn’t that good. Mainly, too much bread not enough chili.
I will give Tyler’s another try. I feel like they deserve that much. But, for now, I just can’t recommend them. I will be rooting for them to stay in business, though. Because, sometimes, people matter more than food.

Awesome local place. Pizza was made fresh with fresh ingredients. Watched them make the sauce using the brick oven to roast the tomatoes, onions and garlic. The place smells amazing and the pizza tastes great!

Don’t plan on going there for lunch, we went out our way to try it only to be told they don’t start making pizza until 12:30– 1:00.

Stopped in last night and was so glad that I did! The whole staff is super friendly and even let my kids check out the pizza oven. It was seriously the best pizza ever. We eat a whole lot of pizza and this may just be the best we have ever had. Grabbed some chocolate chip cookies and they were also superb. The price was more than fair and even though we live 25 min away, we will definitely be making the trek back often. Highly recommend.

My boyfriend and I tried Tyler’s pizza for the first time On Saturday night. We ordered the cheeseburger pizza due to the harmonious suggestions from the gentlemen making the pies when I asked what we should order. We were not disappointed!
We also took home a bag full of pastries because we loved every item we taste tested. Oh did I mention they let you try ANY pastry before ordering? Amazing!
Everyone working there was friendly, helpful and took pride in their culinary creations. It’s really nice to know there is a good local eatery right around the corner.
These guys are getting things right!

It’s the greatest pizza I’ve ever had. The only thing better is the smell of this place when you are waiting for the staff to pull the pizza out of their wood burning oven right in front of you! This is the epitome of freshness and I’m proud to support a local business.
I have not had the pleasure of trying any of their baked good but they look and smell delicious and it’s only a matter of time. I’m a customer of this place for good! Service is phenomenal as well. Thank you!

Our first visit and it was awesome. We ordered the margarite pizza, bbq blast, a calzone, a regular pep pizza and a cherry chocolate chip pizza. All of them were delicious. Will certainly go back.

I think I saw Frodo and Bilbo here, ordering from the head breadmaster, who was concocting middle earth delicacies on a massive wooden prep table, all the while making googoo eyes at his insanely great pizza in Mordor’s hellfires, well contained within his hobbit-​sized brick oven.
Oh yes, this is very, very good bread, pastries, and I’m told, his pizzas are otherworldly. It was such beautiful pizza coming out of that back room (clearly visible, unfortunately), that I had to avert my eyes. This journeyman pizza-​wizard knows his bread science and has perfected the art of baking. This is craftsmanship quality.
There was quite a backup of orders for the delicious pizzas being finished out in his Mordor oven, and I just didn’t have the time to wait (6PM on a Friday, who can I blame). I’m coming back to try that outrageous pizza– soon.
PS Try his scones; best I’ve ever eaten.

I just picked up at Tyler’s pizza pepperoni and mushroom. As I walked in the smell of fresh bread was very inviting. I really enjoyed eating this pizza with my family.
I called at 4:51 and I’m full at 5:41. It helps to live near by. I like keeping my money in my town and supporting small business. Thanks Tyler’s pizza for a good dinner.

I had my first experience at Tyler’s last night for a To Go order. They were slammed busy and the pizza took about and hour and a half, but it was totally worth it!
They make everything fresh and they are super friendly. You can also get fresh bread or pastries with your order. The pizzas are well priced for being all fresh too ($ 10-​$ 16/​each)!
I made a 25min trip out of my way to try this, but I don’t regret my decision. I’ll make it a routine to get pizza from them every couple months.
P. s. Down the Main strip, there is a lot of construction. Take that into account when traveling during peak hours!

We found this place through Unilocal on our way from the Columbus airport. They definitely earn all 5 stars! I really appreciate the pastry samples. It’s so hard to choose just a few to take home. The pizza was phenomenal. Not stingy on the toppings at all.
Friendly, delicious, and affordable! We’re hoping to stop back on our return trip.

This was my first visit to this pizza shop and it far exceeds any pizza I’ve ever had! We ordered the California chicken pizza and it is superb-​I can’t begin to describe the flavors — just a delight to take that first crispy/​chewy bite!
The pizza crust is crisp but with just enough chewiness and the flavor was lovely — it was heavenly! I will most definitely refer anyone I know to this place and come back again
I might even venture here early in the morning for some fresh baked pastries too

I have a Groupon for a specialty pizza (dine-​in) that expires in two weeks, so I thought I’d take my niece for lunch. Unfortunately, this joint doesn’t start making and serving their pizza till 3 pm everyday. Bummer :(
But now, I’m totally stoked to head back! The young lady who greeted me from the back kitchen was very polite. Great personality. All the prep and baking is done out in the open — it was neat to watch. I got a good vibe walking in.
She was happy to let us sample any of their muffins/​pastries. I tried the Cheese Danish. Holy cow! Super soft. Moist. They make everything from scratch every day. You could tell this sucker was made with love. I couldn’t resist, so I bought two for our breakfast.
I’m excited to stop in for an evening of pizza, next week!

I have been told about this place for a few months now, and since I have moved to this side of town I had to try it. I bought a Groupon for their pizza, it expired.
They honoured it, they made a wonderful Taco pizza, and now I’m a believer.
I expressed that I have heard so much about them and thier bread and pizza… I was given a taste of a wonderful tasting of a pork pulled sandwich… That was amazing. thank you.
I also stated that I have heard that thier bread was amazing but I was just one in a household, so an entire loaf would be overkill, so he gave me a partial loaf. To me, the entire experience has made me a long time customer.
Thank You.

I followed the Unilocal reviews to Tyler’s…then after I ate the pizza, I considered going home to get a tent. SO I could camp out in front of the Pizzeria/​Bakery and be the first to see what delicious mischief Tyler’s came up with for tomorrow! Seriously, I had the SMALL Mushroom Onion Pizza, and it was like everybody else’s MEDIUM.
I bought 2 Snickerdoodle cookies, and they were the size of every other pizza places’ PERSONAL size pizza. Oh, and did I mention IT WAS A COOKIE!!! And what a cookie! As a home baker, I immediately recognized at the first bite as being made with an excellent quality butter. Sublime!
You must go here! You will not go away hungry!!! The quality is excellent, and the wood smoke oven fragrance hits you as soon as you enter! It is a WONDERFUL experience on every level of the senses!
Go! Hurry! They’re only open till 9!!!
You still have time!!! Get in the car!!!

After stumbling upon Tyler’s on Groupon, we found this gem of a bakery!!! We have only ever ordered pizza from them, but I look forward to every time my husband goes «want it get pizza tonight?»!! The first time we had pizza we got the cheeseburger pizza. I was skeptical, b/​c come on! Why would I not just have ordered a hamburger from Thurman’s to go instead?!? But Oh my golly… If was amazing!
The only pizza I have had that I didn’t like was one of their pizzas without their red sauce (I think it may have been the margarita pizza??) I am obsessed with their pizza crust and sauce. The sauce has a perfect hint of sweet while being so incredible creamy and delicious. And their crust, straight out of the stone stove… Perfect combination of crispy and soft!!! We will def be back again and again. You can consider your groupon deal a success! You have new regular customers:-)

Fantastic family owned pizzeria and bakery. Located in a small strip on the north side of Main Street. Upon walking in you are hit with the aroma of the wood fired oven and a friendly greeting.
I had the Summer Garden pizza: sweet pepper blend, onions, tomatoes, and sweet corn straight off the cob. Sauce is homemade daily and not overly sweet. Everything is made in-​house. Perfect pizza. Not to thin; not too thick. Baked to perfection.
Prices are extremely reasonable. They offered up free samples of their pepperoni rolls which were amazing as well. I’m looking forward to trying some of their breakfast croissants and pastries which come in many flavors and are also made daily. I’ll be back (soon!)
Note: No indoor seating. A few tables out front, but mainly a carry out place.