Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta

I love this place, the pizza is okay but the real action are the desserts and the Alfredos

My fiancée and I have been really sick and wanted some good food but in riverdale the delivery options are pizza and chinese food which can get tired quick. We checked Unilocal and noticed Anthony’s which we have seen numerous times passing on Highway 85. So I decided to give it a try. The young lady I spoke with on the phone was very polite and understanding with me having to call like 3 times. One to confirm they delivered. Two confirming they delivered to my area and 3 to finally take my order.
So we ordered the chicken fingers with fries and my fiancée ordered the spaghetti w/​meat sauce and the tossed salad. I must say I was pleasantly surprised. I tasted my fiancée’s spaghetting with meat sauce and the sauce was pretty darn good. It had a kick to it which you hardly fine in spaghetti sauce’s without adding something extra yourself. The salad was fresh. AND THE GARLIC KNOTS OMG!!! THEY WERE AWESOME!!! I could have eaten those all by themselves. They said the delivery would be about 45 minutes to an hour and they were actually early which was great because the food was hot and this was right in the middle of the lunch rush.
Now what made the rating a 4 star instead of a 5. I ordered the chicken fingers. Now this is an italian restaurant so I was leery of getting chicken fingers because I mean i didnt expect them to be home made or fresh but they didnt have that deep fried crisp to them and the fries were kinda soggy but ya know it was still edible and didnt taste bad.
Overall, I have found a spot when we dont feel like fixing spaghetti or lasagna ourselves that delivers which is alright with me. DEFINITELY TRY THEM GARLIC KNOTS… OMG THEY GOOD!!!

I LOVE the Philly Cheesteaks And Pizza. Fast and Friendly Customer Service and Comftorable Laid Back Eating Enviorment. Enjoyable to Watch The Games on they’re Flat screen and Play A Fun Game Of Pool

Amazing pizza, great service. Very chill and laid back environment. Ordered a couple slices of their pepperoni pizza. Yummy!!! I love how the pepperoni slices are hidden under the cheese!

When I’m in the mood for good italian, but quick, Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta is my go to place
The service is quick, the food is tasty, and the price is right.

Great value, good size portions and tasty food. I enjoy the meatball sub and also the spaghetti. Atmosphere is okay, but the food makes up for it. Very reasonable prices.

I would have given this place 4 stars a couple of months ago but now they barely deserve 2. The pizza is inconsistent. One day my crust was so thin I could barely pick up the pizza because it started sticking to the box. The employees need better customer service skills and they need to hire a cook who can make the pizza the same every time. It seems like someone different makes my pizza every time. Their restaurant score is in the 80s now and was in the 90s months before. Something went wrong.

I came here for lunch. Prices are very expensive for the amount of food you get. The pizza was mediocre. Felina’s pizza is way better and cheaper. I will not come back again.

BUT on another note, I did go back and I’m glad I did. Their pizza is by far the best in the area… nothing else comes close, not remotely.
Their large triple topping is a great value and their sauce is incredible. In complete honesty, it’s even better the next day.
Skip the chain and stay with Anthonys.

Good Panzeroti at a fair price, not much else to say about this dark little place with 80’s video games and pool tables.

The food tasted like trash I had to throw it away

Decent pizza, okay salad.
We got a to-​go order on a Hawaiian pizza & small house salad. All of which was pretty standard. The pizza didn’t have as much pineapple as I had hoped though, and the salad came covered in sliced cheese slices. Sliced by hand to help you jiggle it down your throat. Easy to pick off at least. A good portion of it was half large chicken chunks and cheese, to olives, and lettuce. Not the best salad, but sufficient at the time.
The pizza here would work as a good alternative to chain stores. I have no complaints about it besides there not being a lot of pineapple, but I can get over that.
As for the venue, it seemed pretty quiet but a nice family eatery, arcade machines and what not plus lots of room. Staff was prompt and friendly too. If ever a late night pizza run hits again while in Riverdale… we might be back.

Worst pizza I’ve ever had, being from NYC/​nj area I know pizza… It was worse then chucky cheese pizza… Cheap dough consistancy… Barely any sauce and the cheese was somewhat boring and flavorless. 20 $ got me a plain cheese pizza and a side of meatballs that had to have been frozen. Dominos will now be my only choice of pizza in this town.

Tried this place for the first time today and loved it! Me and my husband both got the shrimp fettuccine Alfredo for 10.99 &we both added side salads for 1.00. The prices are great and you get a ton of food. The pastas also come with these delicious little garlic buttered crescent rolls. Yum! Certainly gonna come back plus the service was good

I’ve rode passed this restaurant thousands of time. Today, I had a taste for lasagna, so I chose Anthony’s. I ordered lasagna and a 3 cheese ravioli kids meal. After I paid, I looked around for their health inspection score. I found it neatly placed behind the cash register. As soon as I saw it, I no longer wondered if it (you don’t hide good scores) was low. It was just a matter of how low it was. 76 is the answer. It was done in March of this year which means there has been plenty of time to correct the items and get reinspected.
The food was not close to what expected after reading all the favorable reviews. I didn’t like the lasagna, the ravioli, the tomato sauce or all that darn cheese they put on those items. My instincts said, IT’S A 76 GET YOUR MONEY BACK! I guess I should’ve listened.

Nice little spot been staying in riverdale area for a long time, use to order pizas years back but never went to the the joint. Had the chicken salad all good, very clean place nice menu to choose from it was a good stop something different for lunch, good service will be back. PS be four stars I like a cold one with my lunch on off days but all and all good stop.

Oh my! This food is awesome. I got the lasagna and a Caesar salad. I’m in heaven! Plus… free Wi — Fi!

So came in for lunch one afternoon and it has a nice little feeling to it. Server came in a reasonable amount of time — I ordered a sweet tea to drink. Another server came back and brought me a water, so I let her know that I ordered a sweet tea and she quickly got an attitude.
After taking about 5 minutes to get my drink correct, she finally came to take our order. I ordered the pizza sub and that food came out rather quickly. The sub was mediocre, the bread was insanely dry and had pepperoni stacked; not spread out which just sort of didn’t tickle my fancy.
I might give it another try and order the pizza, but only maybe.

I thought that the pizza here was okay. I like the crust and the sauce is okay. The staff was friendly and attentive.
IA date brought me here because I wanted to learn how to play pool… enjoyed the pool tables most of all. I would come here just to play pool. I had a GREAT time and the restaurant seems like it was meant to have a pool table or two in it. Come out and enjoy this place for some good wholesome fun.
Great place for a 2^nd or 3^rd date fellows. You can get close to your Sweetie without her realizing that you are copping a feel. :) And NO. I still can’t play pool! LOL!

I’m somewhat astounded by how long it took for me to review this place. Maybe I was subconsciously avoiding a review since Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta has been associated with a couple of unfortunate events as of late; Anthony’s is the first place that my closest friend and I went to after his father passed away, and another friend locked his keys in his car the last time I was there. Notwithstanding, such occurrences really shouldn’t put a damper on Anthony’s because this restaurant is home to outstanding pizza. For me, one of the true tests of pizza is whether it’s delicious fresh out of the oven, cold, and also after being reheated a day later. Anthony’s aces that test! I’ve also tried their shrimp fettuccini alfredo, but the main attraction is undoubtedly their pizza.
I’m a fan of the red brick and wood interior that gives this family-​oriented pizzeria a classic look and feel. As a family-​oriented restaurant, Anthony’s features several pool tables, a few arcade machines, and an air hockey table. Moreover, it’s also a family-​operated business; seeing the underage kid working the register reminds me of my own formative years of «indentured servitude» working at my parents’ restaurant. Now that I mention it, I should tip that kid the next time I visit.
Ideally, discovering and supporting local businesses is what Unilocal is all about, and so I encourage others in the area to patronize Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta. It’s exceptional given that it’s one of the few praiseworthy places in Riverdale!