Mr Pizza

Gluten-​free and delicious!!!
Last week, my hubby and I picked up two 10″ pizzas to go, one regular and one gluten-​free. I waited to do my review until I was sure the GF pizza truly was GF, as I have wheat intolerance. Mr. Pizza passed the test! Not only that, but the pizzas were scrumptious!
He ordered one of their specials. I ordered a mushroom and black olive. It was loaded with thick, meaty shrooms and savory olives, plus so much gooey cheese, I was it pizza heaven. The crispy crust was fabulous. Neither of us could finish our small pizzas and were happy to have leftovers the next day. Yum and double yum.
The best thing after a day of miserable testing at Mayo is happy eating and knowing I could eat gluten-​free was the best.

Best pizza in town by far! I work in a hotel an recommend Mr. Pizza to all the guests asking who has the best pizza. My husband and I have been patrons for years, we don’t eat it nearly as often as we used to, but it’s still our favorite pizza in Rochester! The crust is fluffy, the sauce is robust, good quality cheese and toppings and an excellent staff.

My family and I went there on a recommendation from the hotel we were staying at. The waitress was very nice and came to the table pretty quick to take our drink order. She gave us a great recommendation for a appetizer, the pizza bread. The waitress is the reason I gave the restaurant 2 stars.
We ordered an extra large thin and crispy ½ cheese ½ sausage. When the pizza came it was extremely greasy. The sausage looked like it was burnt and had no taste. The cheese didn’t taste good at all.
I do not recommend this restaurant at all.

Mr Pizza has really grown on me. The best part about their pies is their toppings. Their prices may seem a little higher than their competition, but they really, really pile the toppings on. Their pizzas are the definition of «Meat Lovers». Three of their specials, that we’ve tried, have tons of ground beef, sausage, pepperoni, and other treats for carnivores. With so many toppings, the slices can sometimes require forks because the crust can’t always handle the weight. My wife thinks that the toppings are a little overboard (especially the ground beef), but I’m a big fan of them. We just make sure to order two pies when we stop by for take-​out (she prefers their white pies with less toppings).
The owner contacted us after our last review to apologize for the burnt pizza and offered to make it up to us. We haven’t taken him up on his offer yet, because we’ve been saving it for a time that we could stop by to eat in. We want to try his recommendation, the thin-​crust bacon cheeseburger, with a few pitchers of beer. We really appreciated his dedication to ensuring their customers’ care and I picked up some the two stores’ history. In a nutshell, the two stores aren’t chains; they are two restaurants operated for more than thirty years by two brothers, who started out together at the south location. Now, each family runs their own place and has added their own touches. Mr. Pizza North expanded their menu because of a larger kitchen, while Mr. Pizza South has focused solely on what founded the original location.
I really like coming for their lunch specials and I’m a huge fan of the pizza joint atmosphere. Nothing is better than sitting down in a place with character, eating a warm pie, and getting a frosty pitcher of beer. Also, their take-​out is extremely fast and convenient; I’ve never waited more than 20 minutes.

Great lunch. Meat combo is the best. I opt for the thin crust but they’ll make make it anyway you want, pan style, cheese stuffed, doughy, I think they do gluten free too. I usually reward myself here after using the car wash in back. They have been here for years and it is just because they do it right. Nobody has a thin crust like them. The pizzas are big, perfect for pays or football games. Forgot to mention the frozen take home ones too, I usually keep a couple in the freezer at home.

Great pizza, fast service. Only one waitress working and she killed it. did a great job. Nice atmosphere! Truly good pizza!

I love love their Taco pizza! I have to say I had a little bump with thier toppings but Ryan took care of the situation and its all good and I can’t wait to get another Taco Pizza from there again. Don’t hesitate to eat at Mr Pizza… classy owners!

Oh man I love you guys. Got the thick crust with extra sauce. It was so zesty amazing. I’m from NY where pizza is disgusting and the sauce is watered down crap. Man pizza like this makes me hate ny stupidity so much. Why can’t I get a simple good pizza like this there. Seriously good, very pasty thick sauce. Me and my sister are so happy we came here. I appreciate you guys!!!

Great service, had a bacon cheeseburger thick crust pizza. The pizza was loaded with toppings, and perfectly cooked. This will be the go-​to pizza when in Rochester.

Had to go to Mayo Clinic twice and this was in walking distance of our hotel. Twice I got pizza from here and it was fabulous. I hope to never have to go to Mayo again but this pizza will be missed.

BEST pizza I have ever had! Every pizza I eat is compared to Mr. Pizza. Moved from Roch in 1975, been in AZ for thirty-​one years. I gave up hope of finding good pizza long ago until recently (in Tucson), but all pizzas are compared to Mr. Pizza. Terrific sauce and pepperoni, and cheese to die for. Whenever I’m back in Roch (maybe once a decade), Mr. Pizza is a must for me.

Can’t be any better than the classic!!! Best lunch special and amazing garlic bread and pizza. Great for the family and I’ll keep going back.

Wow! Pleasantly surprised! Read the reviews on Unilocal and figured we would give it a go as opposed to our favorite delivery joint. Not mad about that decision at all! Pizza was really great with lots of toppings. They don’t skimp out at all. They don’t have a giant menu which is actually a good thing. Pretty basic toppings and a few unusual, it was an easy choice when ordering. I do wish they had a few more options for alcoholic beverages. Four beers from which to choose. Two bottled and two on tap. Overall a really nice experience.

We are visiting the Mayo Clinic and ordered a pizza from Mr. Pizza.
It was one of the better pizzas that we have had. Lots of cheese and toppings. The one concern was the price. $ 28.00 for a 14inch with pepperoni, gr. Beef, onions, and mushrooms seems a little high. Now they did deliver it two blocks away by a taxi but we did not ask for that method of delivery. It’s our fault for not asking for the price ahead of ordering it btu the pizza was great!

Two stars because it was edible, just simply not very good pizza. We ordered the House Special. It was like Shepard’s Pie, not pizza. I ate it. It filled me up. I thought the crust was like the pre-​made from Walmart and lacked sauce. Fair amount of cheese. So if you want bland flavor, mediocre crust, negligible sauce, this is your place — I wouldn’t go back. Too much good pizza in this world to give a second chance. Keep moving.

Probably deserves 3.5 stars.
Hard to describe the style if you are not from around here. It’s kinda the «more is always better» philosophy of pizza making. Lots of sauce, thick bready crust, lots of gooey cheese, lots of food service grade toppings.
Still, it works on a level that I can’t really explain.
I prefer their thin crust with light sauce. The bacon cheeseburger (ask for pickles) is actually pretty fun.
For reference, I love chicago style deep dish and especially love Neapolitan pizza.

I am not from New York or Chicago… and Seattle isn’t really known for their pizza so really, I’m easily pleased by pizza. And this was one of those cases. Oh, and I don’t like deep dish pizza. So by now, most of you have probably stopped reading.
I came here with a college friend and were looking for somewhere different from the 3 places I ate at all week to go to dinner. Pizza sounded good so Mr. Pizza we came. I’ll be honest, the name of this place made me laugh… and a little skeptical… but it was perfect for our purposes.
The service was quick and easy — we sat down and someone came to take our order. We ordered a medium size for the two of us with the the works. It was definitely big enough for two with a good amount left over.
The pizza was thin crust (yay) and had so many toppings on it, it made me happy. There was so much sausage/​pepperoni/​good stuff that I actually took notice before shoveling it in my mouth.
This feast for 2 was only about $ 16 which was a nice treat after having had $ 80+ meals all week.
I can’t promise you gourmet pizza but this place hit the spot.

$ 2.75 for a delicious and big slice plus fountain soda. This single slice filled me up.
Mr Pizza is a home town classic!

We came in from out of town to be seen at the Mayo. We had some pizza delivered to the Kahler Grand. BOTH OF IS GOT FOOD POISONING!!! 15 minutes after eating the Pizza, both of us were on the toilet with stuff coming out of both sides of
our body. I didn’t want to put them on blast on Unilocal but when I tried to call back to warn the manager. No one would answer the phone. Hopefully, they shut down the store so this could not happen to someone else. I tried calling for 2 hours. I stopped trying at 10:00pm. CHOOSE THIS PIZZA JOINT AT YOUR OWN RISK!!!

Call me spoiled, I just moved to Rochester from the land of endless pizza possibilities and home to the famous deep dish… drum roll, please… Chicago, but I did not like Mr. Pizza one bit. I had been forewarned that the pizza options were slim to none in Rochester, so I was excited to read such high reviews for Mr. Pizza on here.
Location is fine, older building, lots of booths and family pizza parties. Staff is young and high-​school, but very pleasant. Not sure what kind of pizza we ordered, took waitress’s recommendation, and hated it. Actually tossed my leftovers (very uncharacteristic of me).
I’m sorry Mr. Pizza and die-​hard Rochester fans, it was not for me.