Damgoode Pies

Really hate to see this place fail. Pizza was the best in Rogers and beer was always reasonably priced and cold! I have no idea why they closed the doors…

The food is still good but now the owner made the decision to make it self serve. I even have to go get my beer from bar and pay each time. I don’t plan on coming back.

It was okay. Had a variety of things. Spaghetti and meatballs, meatball sandwich, pizza and cheesy bread. I liked the meatballs but everything was just okay. Probably won’t go back. Sauce was on the spicier side, which I liked but was a bit too spicy for my daughter’s kid meal. Nothing to write home about.

I have ordered twice from here. The first time was the best pizza I have had in years. Plenty of red sauce and a great crust. Delivery service was very fast. Almost surprised how fast it was. It was so good that I ordered again 2 days later. I had the damngood a trois appetizer which was unbelievable. I also had the pizza with the pink sauce. It was highly reviewed but I was not a huge fan. I will stick to the red. I am getting ready to order again. 3 times in 8 days.

Great service and food! We got our food quickly and the waitress was very helpful. The manager came by and checked on us too! Food came out fast and was delicious!

This was an excellent pizzeria. The staff were kind and helpful, our waitress was very good. The food is incredible, the crust and sauce and toppings are all delicious. If you want a good pie in Bentonville stop here.

Pretty damn goode! The pizza sauce tastes really fresh and the cheese is SO GOOD. Crust is the chewy kind like I like.
The small salad is like 6 dollars and the size of a side salad. Yummy… but it is expensive.
Also the two times I’ve had it (once delivery and once carryout) I don’t think fast is a word they use.

Earned it’s name. The salad was mediocre buy a good portion. I love all the choices in sauce and cheese and crust.
I had the stuffy crust, spicy 5 pie, and was not dissatisfied. The service was a tad slow but nothing horrendous. Server was very friendly and accommodated our ridiculous request to split all the checks without hesitation.
We were almost the only ones in there, and that’s the 2^nd time that happened to me… A little weird since the food is so good?
I’d definitely go back and recommend it too!

The pizza was really good. Probably the best tasting pizza I’ve had in quite a while.
The salad my daughter got looked good as well.
Cheese bread was pretty good too.
Service was so-​so. Would have expected better since there were only 3 tables of customers.

This place is worth it for good pie that is a cut above places like Pizza Hut, Dominos, and a about on par with Papa Johns (for me). I’ve been here a couple of times, and one of them was for an office get together. It was fun and the server was awesome. I’m defintely a fan of this place, and plan to do more business here to satisfy my pizza tooth.

The servers were great and informative and the food came out quickly and hot, however, we were the only diners in the restaurant. The food itself, however, was good but pricey. We ordered a 10-​inch Supreme pizza ($ 12.49) and a 6-​inch The Hog pizza ($ 7.99). The reason for the odd order is because of the significant increase in price between a 10-​inch pizza and a 14-​inch pizza, which is $ 9. The 14-​inch Supreme pizza costs $ 21.49; that’s a big difference for a couple more slices. Our bill of $ 22.43 covered the two smaller pizzas. We ate the Supreme pizza there and took The Hog pizza home as a take-​out. However, we were still hungry and ended up eating that pizza when we got home. Both pizzas desperately needed more sauce. The crust was wafer-​thin like a cracker as advertised. The veggies were fresh. However, the toppings, especially the cheese, were pooled in the middle which made serving and eating it by the slice difficult. We had to cut it up and eat with a fork.
We were really looking forward to something extraordinary, especially with acclaimed awards and the top-​dollar prices. However, we were disappointed and won’t be returning. The pizzas were good, just not so good that we would drive to eat it and pay the high prices as well. There are some better pizza places much closer to us that aren’t so outrageously expensive.

Excellent place to eat! Delicious meatballs and red sauce as an app or for a meal. Service is great !
Pizza is dam good!
Ally is a great server.
Salad is fresh and huge!

Very few customers. Kitchen is very slow. Then they burnt our pizzas… So it’s even slower now. The waitress was very nice, though, and competed our beers because of the wait.
Also, forgot the pickles on the kids’ meals. I think the big drawback of this place is all the potheads in the kitchen.
Pizza still not here after sitting here an hour. Giving it two stars.

I had a late lunch. Ordered the salad & half sub lunch deal. Did not notice any issue at the time. I was the ONLY patron there. Approximately 2.5−3 hours later I was beset with emergent diarrhea. I am writing this review ~24 hours AFTER consuming their food. I am still queasy and have had intermittent episodes of diarrhea since yesterday. I did notify the manager. He offered a discount on my next trip. I replied that will not be necessary; there won’t be a next trip.

Worst service ever!!!
Wish I could give no stars.
The server Anna was rude and inconsiderate
1. Bought us wrong appetizer with meat whereas we orderd vegetarian. On the top of it she argued saiying it was right one, when another server bought the right one she picked up the wrong one and gave it to the people initially orderd. One of my friend aleady touched it picked up bacon and tasted it. DID NOT APOLOGIZE
2. Orderd beer pitcher, she never bought it and when we canceled it saying we don’t want as it took so long she did not say sorry or anything and bitched instead saying I don’t know what took so long.
3. I orderd my pie with onions, guess what NO ONIONS
4. When she bought our pies she never said which one was which aa we had vegetarian and non vegetarian orders
5. OUR GLASSES WERE EMPTY, she never bothered to fill it up
6.I asked for extra sauce, she never bought it
7. She snuck up on us from over the booth and heard us 3 times bitching about service and STILL NEVER APOLOGIZED
8. MESSED UP SPLITTING OUR BILLS AS WELL.
I guess this place and management here does not give a f*** about customer service.

Guys, I am so torn about this place.
Pros: AMAZING pizza! Their pies absolutely are damn good. We have eaten here about six times in the last three or four months. The location is very close to us, in fact, I believe it is the closest restaurant of all. The last time we ate here was two weeks ago. We dine-​in because we love our pizza to be right out of the oven.
We love that you can customize your pizza down to the variety of sauces. Every time we have ordered the supreme pizza with the pink sauce because we love toppings and the pink sauce has just the right amount of spiciness. The pizza always tastes so delicious with its gooey cheese and great toppings. The crust is fantastic with the perfect crispiness.
We have tried a couple of their appetizers. The wings are good, your standard pizza place wing. The real showstopper here, though, is their STUFFED MUSHROOMS. I would honestly just come in and order them with a salad because they are so good. The mushrooms are stuffed with ricotta, parmesan, basil, garlic, red and yellow peppers and topped with tons of mozzarella. Mmm.
On the food alone (and the fact that they are less than a 5 minute drive away) I want to give Dam Goode Pies five stars, but…
Cons: The service stinks! Every. Single. Time.
Normally service makes it or breaks it for a restaurant for me. However, I am such a sucker for a good pizza. I believe I have vowed at least twice that I will never return… but you know how that goes with good food.
On most occasions we have visited when it is not busy at all. Even when it has been busy the situation is always like this: you walk in, no one greets you. There is a sign on the counter that says something like «See the bartender to be seated.» Sometimes the bar-​tender is there, sometimes not. You get seated and sometimes a waiter comes to you quickly, sometimes not. We order quickly… we always know what we want right away. There is a long wait for the food, which we understand because it is all made fresh. We are hardly offered refills. If the place starts getting remotely busy, good luck seeing your waiter again.
One of the last times I went, our server was a young blonde girl, perhaps in her late teens or early twenties. While our glasses were sitting there empty and we finally decided to just pay and leave, friends of hers walked in. Instead of offering us more drinks or getting us our check, she was riding her friend’s back for a piggy back ride. Priorities, I guess.
I want this location to make it, because it is in a place in Rogers that needs a good restaurant and the food is so good. If it keeps up the terrible service, I don’t think it will make it. I am on the verge of moving, so I may visit it once more. When I stop and think about the service, though… perhaps I won’t.

I had their Stuffed PIe. It was delicious and a great alternative to the usual suspects in Benton co. I had the red sauce, I’ve been told the pink sauce is better, but I really liked the red sauce. I hope this place makes it.
Sausage is bland but not bad

First time in, had an ok experience. Nice attentive service and a knowledgable server — she knew what was on tap (several local beers), what type of beer it was (this is more rare than what you would imagine), and could tell us which pizzas were most popular, which sauces, etc.
We settled an a 10″ hand-​tossed Hog (pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, bacon) with pink sauce (mixture of traditional red with spicy white) and took the server’s suggestion to add pineapple. Also ordered a 6″ thin crust Artie (artichoke hearts, mushrooms, and tomatoes) with tomato basil sauce (mixture of traditional red and basil pesto). I really enjoyed both sauces — the white sauce gave the red nice richness and spice and the pesto have it a little garlic basil kick. Toppings were fine, nothing outstanding, and both crusts were ok. Just ok. The thin seemed pretty bland.
So all in all, it was ok, and $ 20 for the 2 pizzas. Better beer, probably more attentive service, and more creative sauces than Gusano’s, but I wasn’t knocked out. I’ll probably give it another try — maybe during happy hour!

It’s pizza. Got a 14″ hand tossed pep and sausage with normal red sauce. When we showed up the parking lot was full, but inside there was no one. All employes. Took a little over 30 min to get the food being the only ones there. Some of the employes were talking about how they don’t like Mexicans and Blacks with a old guy, who turned out to be the manager. He then started talking about people he knew that had kids in drug rehab.
Hand tossed pizza here is thin crust, but chewy. So it got soggy right away. The pizza was not bad but not good. Nothing to remember it by besides the bad service and lack of customers.

Went last night for the first time. Service was fabulous, friendly and fast! Pizza is pizza. Not bad, nothing extraordinary. Lots of sauce options, 3 crust options and plenty of toppings to choose from. And… they use «fresh mozzarella, so no cellulose powder… ew»! Score!
My beer was ice cold and my husband had a glass or two of red wine.