Anchor

We may have visited on a bad night, but this place was awful. The pizza was dry and cold, and the wings were fatty. We ordered a calzone that was burnt and awful. I’d never go back. Go to Good fellows instead.

I love this place. I can attest to the deliciousness of the wings and the pizza as well as the friendliness of the staff. My husband and I always have a great time at Anchor and the fellow customers are always friendly and easy to talk to.
The staff always accommodates me when I order my food. I am dairy-​free and the cheese-​free pizza they serve me leaves nothing to be desired when it comes to comfort food. My only wish is that they would add another door before the entrance to eliminate the miserably cold draft that comes in whenever someone enters. But that’s a small qualm and will not keep me from returning.

Stopped by here when I was in town and had a basket of wings. I can tell they were freshly cooked. Delicious and juicy. I sat at the bar and watched the Yankee game. It was a friendly & comfortable atmosphere. I will stop in again next time I’m in town.

Nice place with a good selection and borderline kid friendly. They have food kids like but no kids menu. The adult portions are big enough to share with small children without going hungry. Prices are decent. I was surprised with how yummy my Philly cheesesteak was and my husband had a equally yummy pulled pork sandwich. We ordered pizza on a previous visit and were just as happy with our choice. The major downside to this place is feeling highly unwelcome. No one greets you at the door and you will stand there looking foolish until someone happens to venture from whatever hole they hide in. Also, stay on top of your waiter he/​she not be back for a while. That being said I still go back and have been pleased both times with the food.

I refer to this place in my head as the ‘secret bar’. It’s right next to Sacket’s Harbor Brew Co, which has a nice small bar that can get very very crowded on Friday and Saturday nights. We’ve ended up coming in here a couple times when it was too crazy next door and we were always happy we did. The patron-​to-​bartender ratio is much better and there is plenty of seating. This bar is good to hang out with a few friends with enough room to move around, but enough atmosphere to have a good time, plus bartenders that are actually available to refill your drinks.

Pizza was great! Lots of yummy choices. Easy going atmosphere and fun to bring a larger group of people to have a dinner. Will be going back soon!

I’m surprised Anchor didn’t even have a listing here on Unilocal,and I think it deserves one. Located next to all the other eateries in Sackets but somehow I’ve walked past it many times without realizing that it was even there. Maybe I was relying on Unilocal too much and since it didn’t exist on Unilocal yet, I didn’t go. (Thanks Unilocal for making me addicted to you.) But I have had food from here several times (to-​go) before finally venturing inside one day.
Nice bar area right inside the door with several bar stools as well as a few high top tables. Decent selection on tap. There is also a seating area behind the bar, which I didn’t even realize was there at first. A pool table, vintage style posters peppered one wall, exposed ceiling, scarred tables all add to a warm comforting relaxed atmosphere. Or it could be because I just walked in from the freezing cold outside! Prices are pretty decent considering the area and the other places nearby. But portions are big enough that there will be leftover to take home. I’ve had a couple different types of pizzas from here, as well as calzones, and even a salad (gotta eat vegs sometimes… lol) and I would say it’s solid. Maybe not the best I’ve ever had but it’s good. Besides pizzas, calzones, salads, they also have subs, premium sandwiches, wings, and typical bar food/​appetizers. Bonus for having milkshakes!
I would definitely recommend.