Bay Burger

Welcome to the top burger joint in the East End. Here you will find reasonably priced, delicious burgers served up in a super friendly, laid back atmosphere. Their fresh brioche buns are heavenly. Tons of vegetarian options are available as well. The Thursday night jazz jam is top notch, but make sure and get there early if you want a table.

Love it. they make there own buns for christ sake

I have enjoyed every item that I’ve tried on this menu. They do great burgers and fries and for something different, try the Fish Burger (which I give 5 stars).
You can’t beat $ 2 beer and live Jazz on Thursday nights. Plus they make their own ice cream.

First time here & I cannot wait to go back. Burger was amazing, cooked perfectly & the staff was so sweet & welcoming. Cannot wait for a reason to go back to Sag Harbor, besides a good burger

Best burgers in the Hamptons this place is the best from there fresh homemade buns to there homemade ice cream for dessert. You wouldn’t fine specially made burgers here just nice old fashion burgers sumtimes simplicity is best

Decent burger spot… this was my first trip to the Hamptons and came here with a good friend. Food was decently priced and beers were nice and cold. My friend’s order was botched but that was remedied right away. My burger had gorgeous, thick dill pickles and was well seasoned. You can always tell how freshly ground meat is and the beef patties are hand formed and very fresh… which I think makes a tremendous difference. Also, they serve tater tots which is so much fun. I’ll definitely be back to try their ice cream.

Paul McCartney sighting here! (He was very nice, but he said no pictures please, totally understandable.) The food is great. Get the $ 2 beer — Narragansett draft. Kid’s play space in the back. Nice outdoor seating.

My husband and I have been looking for a place just like this.
Good old fashioned American summer burger joint. When I say old fashioned I mean food preparation.
We liked how you could chose how you wanted your burgers cooked. You could taste the freshness in every bite. The toppings, the buns, the fries, the Lemonade, it was all perfect. My only complaint was that when my fries were gone… I wanted more and we’d already left. Lol. We will be going back next weekend for sure!!!

After a long day at the beach, my friends & I took our very hungry, empty stomachs to Bay Burger. I ordered a grass-​fed medium burger with cheddar cheese, tomato, lettuce, onion, and pickles. The BF & I also shared a side of French fries and coleslaw. Being the sauce whore that I am, everything was generously loaded with ketchup and mayo! The food was great and I will definitely be back next time I’m in the area and in need of a good burger!

Oh bay burger. I wanted you to redeem yourself so badly.
If only to prove me wrong!
Returned here this past Saturday and ordered a burger. Medium well with cheese and lettuce tomato and fries.
Got my order and as I unfolded the parchment paper to reveal the burger I was happy with the way it looked the burger bun ratio appears to have been rectified!
I picked it up and as I brought it close, I smelled the yeasty sweetness of a bread about to go bad.
Against my own better judgement I opted to ignore it and bit into the burger. There was a big hit of salt and the burger was under cooked.
I set it down and decided to cut it in quarters to see what I was dealing with.
Surprise, surprise the burger was not cooked properly at all! There were sections that were well done and under proper temperature. There was salt only on the side that was over cooked.
I tell ya. That was it.
I’m officially done!

Came here for dinner with family visiting. I tried the lobster roll, and others ordered the fish burger and buffalo chicken (spicy!). There are nice options here, it’s an order at the counter and they bring your food out to you place. There is no table service.
I’ve been trying lobster rolls in the area, and this is the most generous portion I’ve had, it’s a ³⁄₅. I lost the lobster among the mixture of mayonnaise, celery, etc. It was not very tasty, but generous. The texture of the lobster was decent.
I tasted a side someone ordered of snap peas. It’s exciting to see they’ve added something green (besides a salad) to the menu!

So the guy pounds two raw burgers with his hands and then puts them on the grill,
and then gets a handful of blue cheese for the other burger that is ready. Raw beef?
Not requested. No appreciated. Dumb.

Over priced, Asked for medium rare got medium well on two burgers, patty was to small for the bun, shake was pretty good.

Definitely the best BLT I’ve ever had!
Onion rings and tater tots were tasty too. Staff was friendly. Menu is a little pricey compared to other casual burger joints, but I assume it’s because of the location.

Bay burger is a cool joint. They serve up some decent burgers but they’re not super impressive by any means. I’ve eaten here four times and the product has been fairly consistent. Fries are okay, burgers are juicy. It’s not super expensive but I always feel like I’m overpaying. After my meal.
I’ll go again — it’s an easy place to grab a burger and beer so that’s good enough most days!

Bay Burger is a great spot to stop in for a good, filling meal that won’t break the bank. The tater tots are amazing, as are the onion rings (which aren’t listed on the menu but a must-​try). The chicken sandwich and turkey burger were cooked well and yummy.
$ 2 «cheap» pints of beer and live jazz music on Thursday nights are what keep me coming back though.

Was feeling a burger snd decided to revisit Bay Burger…
Pros: friendly service by the owner

Cons: no toilet paper in either bathroom, and nothing else to use. Bathrooms needed a facelift.
Food– smallish burger. Cooked ok. Not juicy. Pale pink unripe tomatoes despite it’s high tomato season– there’s a veggie stand next door. Cmon. Fries and tots were old. It wasn’t busy in there, yet they’re serving old, dried out potatoes. Not good. My news paper stuck to the table from some sort of clear sugary substance.
I think it’s the summation of all these small details that added up to a very unforgettable experience. There are a ton of great burger places out there. Step it up!

My fiancée and I had heard good things and were excited to check this place out!
Negatives:
1) upon telling the employee that it was our first visit, she nodded unenthused.
2) we ordered our burgers and fries together, waited 20 minutes for the burgers and an additional 15 for the fries. (We finished our burgers by the time the fries arrived
3) burgers were small for the price
4) employee scooping ice cream was rude
5) mediocre burgers at best, definitely by worth the price
6) «loaded fries» were made up of two slices of overlooked cheese and 4 bacon tidbits. Cheese was not layered, bacon was lacking, fries unseasoned
Positives:
1) Wednesdays you get a free scoop of ice cream
2) cute décor
3) they support a local charity
We won’t be back.

Bay Burger serves some tasty burgers in a casual spot. They have provided reliably good, juicy burgers for several years now and we always try to visit when visiting our friends in Sag. Ordering is easy, just follow the steps at the cash register. The staff gives you a number placard you place on your table so the staff knows where to deliver food. Bay Burger can become over run with screaming, unruly kids but that’s just something you have to deal with I suppose. Instead of sitting inside, try to grab some outdoor seating located to the left of the building.
The burgers here can come loaded with fixings if you desire. I always add bacon and caramelized onions. They also have a really tasty fried cod sandwich as well as a good turkey burger if you’re being a weirdo and don’t feel like beef. I know this because maybe I’ve ordered both a burger and another sandwich item on previous visits. Lay off me, I’M STARVING! They will occasionally have a lobster roll, which is good but not spectacular. However, for the price of one lobster roll, you can get two delicious burgers and that’s what I would suggest doing. Bay burger is also one of the few places that still serves tater tots, harkening back to your high school lunch days. Try them smothered with bacon and cheese. The burgers can get a little messy while eating, but that’s because of all the sweet, sweet burger juice gushing out with each bite.
Bay Burger also has a few beers on tap, but they also have a rotating $ 2 beer. Usually it’s something like Narragansett or PBR, but this time it was Bud light. Where else are you going to find a $ 2 beer in this area? Not a bad deal and great to drink while outside enjoying a great burger. Perfect for a pre or post beach meal.

Went here the other day with my mom, son, son and daughter around lunchtime. The place was almost empty when we walked in but started filling up and getting busy shortly after we walked in. My son ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich. My daughter ordered a grilled cheese sandwich and a side of fries.
My mom ordered a side of onion rings. I ordered a burger (medium), topped with american cheese, pickles, onion mustard lettuce and tomato a burger with a side of fries. The bill came to about $ 35. The food was good as I had expected; however, the prices are certainly not dirt cheap.
The burger was good. The bun was freshly made but perhaps a little too doughy. I don’t like when the bun overshadows the burger. My son enjoyed his buffalo chicken burger, which comes dressed with lettuce and tomato and comes with a side of blue cheese dressing. My son said he enjoyed it but left part of it uneaten.
My daughter enjoyed her grilled cheese sandwich fries. She finished most of her sandwich which is unusual for her. My mom tasted her grilled cheese sandwich and said it was uncommonly good and the way a grilled cheese sandwich should be made. My mom enjoyed her onion rings which were cooked just right; crispy and firm yet not overcooked.
The building is clean and orderly but dated/​old looking. The lighting in the dining area on our visit was perhaps too dimly lit. Perhaps deserves 3.5 but I will round down 3. For a good, cheap meal in this area, this place is not a bad choice; however, I prefer a couple of other places.