Sag Harbor Inn

There’s nothing wrong with this hotel it is just old! The front desk was very nice and since it was a mini moon for us they even dropped off wine later on. Nothing is computerized and they even give actual keys. The rooms are clean but so old. Horrible comforters with matching curtains that were so worn out. Our room also had a fruit fly issue. Bathroom was clean but old. We had a nice porch over looking the water but paid for it. It’s a 15 min walk to town but it’s a nice walk. We chose this location because it was the cheapest and the only hotel in town without a 3 day minimum. I would go back but I wish they would update themselves to 2015.

Place was just renovated and is really super clean! Can’t expect the world from an inn in Sag Harbor, but we’ve traveled much and this was pleasant. The rooms smelled surprisingly fresh for a «inn». Great deck to sit on right off the room. Big clean new windows. Really nice! You could do much worse out in Eastern Long Island. I think people are confused because they paid $ 200 for an inn but it’s all about location. I paid $ 100 for two hamburgers and two beers. It comes with the territory.
Pulled up with two sparking clean well cared for road bikes on the rack which together retail $ 7,500, asked nicely if we could store them inside. Was told «no that’s the rule». Asked to speak to manager, couldn’t. She went out back and «called» the manager who apparently said no again. Was told to put a $ 5k bicycle in a wooden shed out by the pool which had a huge sign that said not responsible for lost items. Really… Really?
How can I relax when my expensive stuff is out in a unguarded wooden shed? Even the Huffy that was there had a lock on it.
Front desk staff was cold since that interaction. She barely said hello, barely said anything at checkout. Just seemed nasty, and about a dozen other reviews say the same
Owner was nearsighted, we won’t be coming back to spend $ 225 per night when reasonable and polite requests are turned down without any critical thinking or evaluation. Screw that lady at the front desk for telling me to stick a bicycle that cost more than her car into a wooden shed or go take a hike. In the end, just like another reviewer, we wanted to find another door to come and go through.
Breakfast included has muffin, bagels, cereal, yogurt and coffee. Meh. It’s no press button pancake machine at the holiday inn!

The view and the neighborhood are to die for. Great views and peace and quiet. Very quant city. The front staff was very helpful and friendly in all our requests.
The Inn itself is dated, even though we were told that it had been renovated. Cheap, plastic, dated flowers are near every room. The doors are very inexpensive and you could just push on it to open. I did not feel safe with the door closed. There was none or little sound proofing and you could hear people walking on above you and next door. It gave a very 1980s feel and in this area it should be a lot more.
It is a shame that the quality of the place was soo low for what you are paying for. If they gave this place an update to the 2000’s, it would be a great place to stay.

Fantastic little hotel off the main drag.
The neighborhood is absolutely dead silent. Nothing at night but the sounds of crickets.
I actually like the décor. If you want to complain about it being antiquated, you probably don’t understand the Hamptons.
Staff was friendly. We didn’t encounter anyone mean or surly. Fantastic, reasonable hotel I highly recommend.
Their (absolutely free and password-​free) Wifi tested at 30Mbps for me and was perfectly stable throughout my stay.

I stayed here two times, in spring 14 and over the 4^th July weekend. Sag Harbor is very dreamy and the hotel (it should be ranged motel…) location is perfect. The first time I stayed in a pink room, shockingly 1980’s with rattan furniture, powder pink and blue walls. This time I was on the ground floor, across the elevator in a blue room and the wind howled all night through the room (if you open the window…) Bathroom sink leaked, maid walked in on me three mornings… — You will find all the details of lacking service in previous comments; front desk unfriendly, no «charm» throughout the place. Yes, it’s clean, furnished with basic amenities but for the charge and location provided their Continental breakfast should not be reduced to a few packages of cereal, milk, cheap OJ and weak coffee… In face of a new hotel construction next door, I am astonished there is no effort to compete — I was informed I had to change rooms; I checked out. This place surely could use someone (like me) flipping the place back on track; foremost team-​building, «real» breakfast and «modernization»… It’s an okay place, pricy for a few nights rest — not my recommendation yet. They are still banking on the lack of choices available, but that is changing soon!

I stayed at the Sag Harbor Inn recently and will definitely be going back. The hotel is very clean, comfortable and relaxing, with an efficient and friendly staff, an outdoor pool, free daily breakfast, great flat-​screen TV’s and internet in every room, and vintage hamptons artwork and decorating on every floor. I believe it to be the best value in town and you won’t find a better bang-​for-​your-​buck given the short walk to main street and best water views of any hotel in the area. While peak season is always the busiest time in the hamptons, the rates are still very affordable compared to the other options, and you’ll be happy if you decide to stay here instead of the Baron Cove Inn located next door (have stayed at both). And when looking for a place to visit during the off-​season, the rates (in addition to everything else mentioned above), makes the Sag Harbor Inn a no-​brainer in my opinion.

Being from Southern California, I’m not a regular visitor to the area; over the last 10 years, I’ve only been here a handful of times. However, in the future, I will surely choose the Sag Harbor Inn as my destination of choice.
It’s a perfect lodging option for this quaint little town. It, by no means, is fancy and for those with a snooty attitude, this may not be the place for you. I however, loved it.
It’s perfectly located to town and possesses spectacular views. The rooms are comfortable, spacious and incredibly clean with nice little amenities. While the décor may be a bit dated (see previous reviewers comment about the floral bedspread) it really doesn’t detract from anything. They even have regular keys for the door; none of those card types here!
The continental breakfast was ample in quantity and quality and was a welcome site the next morning.
Each room is equipped with a nice little sitting area where you are able to take in the gorgeous views.
The price point was extremely low considering the area but a welcomed relief considering my dining options preceding my stay.
I would highly recommend this as a lodging option and will surely return on my next visit to town.

Stayed on a Thursday night. Wasn’t exactly what I had expected for a «Hamptons» hotel. Wasn’t dirty but wasn’t amazing either. Has a pool but nothing exciting to look at or go in. I have a 1 year old so I did need to spend time in the room, I guess if I just needed a place to sleep I would stay here again. But if I came back with the baby I wouldn’t. Furniture was very old and looks like it has been used a lot! I putty own sheets on the bed and over the couch :)

Quaint little old fashioned hotel. The flowery bed spread and matching curtains are just what one would expect for quaint new England town. The chairs lining the hallways are a bit odd. but it’s clean and affordable and would come back again

Very nice room to pass out in. Located close enough to Sag Harbor to walk from, I enjoyed my stay. Fairly pricey, but inexpensive for the area.

For our first time in Sag Harbor, we had a great trip including our stay at the Sag Harbor Inn. This quaint Inn with breath taking views and a very homey feel was the perfect spot for us. We went during off season and it was very quiet and peaceful. The Inn was located in walking distance to the downtown and overlooked the water. Our room had a patio which was great to enjoy some sunshine and the beds were incredibly comfortable. Definitely a nice place to stay during our trip to the East Coast.

After the car rental’s GPS decided to route us through two ferries via Shelter Island, we finally ended up at the Sag Harbor Inn one rainy Friday evening in early October. Easy check in at the front desk where we were given an excellent map of the Hamptons and a great recommendation to try out the Beacon for dinner. I don’t know about the hotel’s claim to be «the most luxurious hotel in the Hamptons,» but it was certainly an acceptable place to rest our heads. Yes, the inn and the rooms are decorated like your grandmother’s house circa 1985, but it was perfectly clean and well maintained. Our room had a nice balcony overlooking the harbor. Free continental breakfast. Just about every tv station available, including Bravo which never happens at hotels! Overall, a great water location in a very down to earth, relaxed part of the Hamptons. If you are a city girl who doesn’t really look at maps and relies on GPS, I would highly recommend making sure you avoid the ferry detours and are on route to take the Montauk Highway instead. $ 23 later, I finally understood why the GPS showed we were 8 miles yet 45 minutes away from the hotel. Oops.

After two visits to this Inn, I will certainly not stay there ever again. The price is ridiculous for what is offered. To pay in excess of $ 250 a night on a long weekend for this older hotel is just not worth it.
The woman at the front was surly to the point of being rude, making our arrival seem like a hassle from which she had to take a break from smoking her cigarette on the front door. An attempt to be polite was quickly rebuffed, and suddenly we felt we were the bain of her existence just to check in. The attitude from said staff did not slacken the entire weekend, and in fact we chose to enter from another door to avoid her surly attitude.
I corroborated this with friend who lives locally, who said that once when my friend had tried to book and pay for a room for her visiting mother, the same woman refused to allow her to pay for the room (even though she had booked it) because it was her mother who was staying there. What had meant to be a nice gesture quickly devolved into an awkward situation at check in when the woman refused to take any other form of payment. The kind gesture soon became an awkward transaction between mother and daughter, as my friend had to send her mother a check to cover the cost when the woman refused to accept any other form of payment.
Being made to feel as though your arrival is an inconvenience is bad enough, but to pay $ 750 over three nights of it is absurd. This place only thinks they have the right to charge that because there are few hotels in the area, but do yourselves a favor and spend the money elsewhere, because this place tainted our entire trip to the Hamptons.

With the reviews that I read, I had low expectations but was pleasantly surprised with my stay. Just like Colleen M., I went during the winter so it wasn’t terribly busy but it was peaceful and very clean. Nice and helpful staff. They are very accommodating and can help you over email rather than on the phone so you have a record of all the deals they have going on.
There is free wi-​fi but it seemed like only one person could get it at a time. We had to take turns with checking email but at the same time, the point of going on vacation was to get away from it all so we didn’t mind.
Thin walls. Definitely noticeable during the Valentine’s weekend.

This place is not the Four Seasons, but for the budget traveler this fits the bill. We stayed here for a night and there were only a few other rooms filled since it is winter. They upgraded our room to a harbor view for free since they had so much extra room.
There is free wi-​fi but it didn’t work for most of our stay. The continental breakfast is just cereal and coffee, so don’t count on it if you want a bigger breakfast. I read other reviews of this place that said they have bagels and muffins, so maybe they have a bigger spread in the summer.
Despite any complaints I may have, it certainly was good for a night and it only cost $ 99. We were right on the harbor with a pretty view. It’s an old building and it has character. I would stay here again if in the area. The staff was friendly.