Andy’s Frozen Custard

Love this place! Great custard, super service and employees who seem to actually love what they do! Try the Jitterbug if you like coffee!

Andy,
I know you don’t know me well, yet. But something tells me we’re about to form a very unhealthy relationship. This isn’t to say that what you’re dishing up isn’t made from fine ingredients. No this says nothing about the composition of your delectable custard. This has everything to do with the impossible addiction that your sweet, smooth, robust flavored custard induces. If someone told me I would be jumping off the TD’s train just a couple of weeks after declaring it the best ever I would have slapped them silly. Could anyone really improve on perfection? Could anyone make the stars at night even more beautiful? Prior to this weekend I would have said no. But now I know, there is a magical realm where the impossible is possible. Your magic could have solved world hunger or made a cure for cancer. Instead you used your powers to create other worldly custard that demands attention and is available year round. *slow clap* Bravo Andy. You are a good drug dealer!

What can I say, I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!
The custard is so good! I usually get a concrete with peanut butter cups, but last time I got a concrete with Heath in it and I wish I has ordered a medium it was that good.
I know what you are thinking, it’s cold out!
It’s that good you will want it even if there is snow in the ground and 15 below!
Come try it, I think you will love it!

The James Brown Brownie concrete was outstanding!!! Grand kids each got a cheesecake concrete plus a regular cup of vanilla. All got great reviews!

Really good. I would give it 5 stars but I gave TD’s 5 stars and there can really only be one that’s as good as it gets, right? Ted Drewe’s is just a little bit better in my book, but really, some of that may have to do with nostalgia and what not than the actual custard. You can’t go wrong with either.
I’ve only ever had the Snowmonster because I like it and why get something else that I may not like as much? I’m weird like that, yeah.

I finally got to try Andy’s after driving past the place so many times. Thanks go out to Steven B. for putting together the UYE that finally brought me here on a beautiful early-​November afternoon.
Things I liked:
They made their turtle sundae into a concrete for me.
Pecans, pecans and more pecans!!! Slightly salty and nicely sweet. Each bite that contained one was a treat… and there were plenty!
Hot fudge — very creamy and not at all grainy. Plenty of it too.
Custard — also very creamy and smooth. It was sweet enough without being over the top and very enjoyable.
Kid 1 called her’s one of the best malts she’s ever had. I was offered a sip and thought it was very good but a little light on the malt for my taste.
Kid 2 told me the same about her brownie sundae. I didn’t get a shot as her’s as I was unwilling to risk the bodily injury that may have ensued had I asked.
Things that concerned me:
You may have to dodge a car or two in order to park and walk to the window as their parking lot doubles as a drive-​thru. Just watch for cars and keep an eye on the kids if they’re little.
Love that they are open year-​round but concerned about whether they can do enough winter business to make that viable from a cost of operations standpoint.

Andy’s Custard is yum! I think it’s better than Ted Drewes. Yes, I’m a native St. Louisan and I’m saying that. My favorite is the cherry bash concrete. Anyone want to drive to Kirkwood?

Andy’s custard is so creamy and rich and delicious. But what sets them apart is that they have the ability to do the Jackhammer, which totally ups the ante. If you love different flavor combinations, like I do, then you will love the Jackhammer. Can’t decide between chocolate and strawberry? Fudge and peanut butter? YOU DON’T HAVE TO! The Jackhammer drills awesomeness down inside the already-​mixed concrete. Flavor explosion! Case in point: GET THE JAMES BROWNIE FUNKY JACKHAMMER. If you love chocolate and peanut butter, you can die a happy person after eating this.

I had snowmonster concrete, i like it but it melts very fast even though it wasnt too hot today.

I have been to Andy’s 3 or 4 times now and it’s been very good each time. I still like Ted Drewes a little better but Andy’s is also deserving of the 5 star rating in my opinion.
Excessive use of chocolate warning! If you really love chocolate like I do, you will love Andy’s chocolate custard, concretes and shakes!
I don’t know what’s wrong with you non-​chocolate lovers out there, but if you are one of the poor souls who fall into this joyless group, there are plenty of options for you as well :)

Andy’s almost killed me.
I would have died with a smile on my face.
The popularity of Ted Drewes apparently means they don’t have to keep the Chippewa location open during winter anymore. So when we went for our annual fix, it was a no go. After watching a line of disappointed fans drive in & out of the lot for 10 minutes… we had to improvise.
Andy’s can have my business! We found them on Unilocal.I loved my Turtle style concrete. It was huge, rich and delicious. I rarely meet a treat that can best me. I almost couldn’t finish. My husband, who grew up on frozen custard, said their Triple Chocolate custard was some of the best choco flavoured custard he’s had.
Cool, modern building with a drive through… and, Wow! They were open! Bonus points for that.

My first spotting of Andy’s, so I had to give them a try after the conclusion of our girlfriend Kirkwood Romp yesterday.
For some reason, the menu board for the drive-​through was a little confusing. I’ll get used to it.
I got a small concrete with hot fudge. He asked if I wanted the hot fudge on the top or mixed into the concrete. That confused me, too. If I only wanted hot fudge on the top, I’d order a sundae.
Well, it all got mixed in. OK by me. I sat in the parking lot with the car running and the air conditioner blowing, and ate ¼ of it. Took the rest home and put it in the freezer. It’s still there.
And it’s darned good.
Great service. Associate cleaned my plastic glass off three or four times to get the sludge out of the way.
I’ll finish it later this week.

The Triple Choclate Concrete is Great! But the lines are INSANE! I was in the drive up on a Sat evening for 15 mins, Everyone behind me left!!!
The parking is horrible
They really need to figure something out!!!
I won’t be going back anytime soon unfortunatly

The turtle split was good. It would have been better there I’m sure. We got it to go. I would advise you to eat there.

The first time that I tried this place, I really wasn’t a fan. I didn’t feel like they had very much candy in their concrete and they also use a knock off peanut butter cup instead of Reese’s.
So why five stars now?
Well there are a few reasons. It’s nice that they have a drive through, they are close to my house, and they have good hours.
I also discovered their jackhammer, which is a concrete with a hole in the middle that is filled with candy, hot fudge, etc. This allows you to have more stuff in your concrete and tastes really good.
But the main reason for the fifth star is three words: cookie Casanova Sundae!!! I think my pregnancy hormones remain and are giving me cravings for this thing. A fresh, warm cookie with custard, Caramel, almonds, and a cherry on top. It is so delicious that it is sinful!
Overall, the menu has unique offerings that other custard places don’t have. They even have root beer on tap from a local brewery which is a great compliment for your custard.

ITS ALMOST SUMMER! and ANDYs is here!
this place is great, depending on the person some would prefer Andy’s over the fabled Ted Drews.
Came here with a big group and got to try a lot of their things, such as the thin mints frozen custard, the chocolate jackhammer, rootbeer float, etc.
I honestly think they mix their custard better than ted drews; it is firmer.
But honestly they are both really good so if you live close to Andy’s and far from Ted Drews, give this place a shot and avoid the long drive! This place is awesome, I’d try all their stuff if I lived closer.
They have BOGO coupons that seem to be pretty easy to find so make sure you bring those too for a cheap pair of desserts!

Andy’s has some pretty great frozen custard and not many people are going to argue with that. I’ve had Andy’s before when I was in CoMo for college and was happy to see one pop up in STL. For a chain, Andy’s has some pretty amazing custard.
I pretty much always get the same thing… the Turtle Sundae. It comes with custard topped off with a lot of hot fudge, cherries, and pecans. What really completes their sundae is that fact they don’t skimp on the hot fudge. Seriously. That pretty much is what makes the sundae… that and the pecans. I always get the smallest size (½ size) and am more than happy with it. I’m no wimp either… they just have large portions.
One last thing, the drive thru is a major bonus. So convenient!

Oh, man. I have to update my review just to tell you about the banana split I just ate.
Believe it or not, I had never had a banana split in my 30+ years of existence on this planet. It never was something that appealed to me. However, after catching a glimpse of someone’s picture-​perfect Turtle Split a few weeks ago, I had to have one.
Tonight was the night. Andy’s Turtle Split is described as «a whole banana and fresh Andy’s Frozen Custard® covered with hot fudge, crème caramel, roasted pecans, and cherries.» I, of course, added peanut butter to mine for an additional $ 0.70.
For me, the roasted pecans are where the magic happens. Maybe I’ve led a sheltered life, but they are the best pecans I’ve ever had. They are crunchy and delicious. I’m not even a huge fan of pecans, but I really was looking forward to them after previously having them on the Stolen Brownie Sundae. I was quite pleased to see that they had not been skimpy with the pecans on my Turtle Split.
The dessert itself was as beautiful as the one I saw a few weeks ago. The banana was flawless and did not have any dark spots on it, as bananas often have. I could have used a little more peanut butter, but whatever. This dish was the ish.
I am fairly certain the Turtle Split also counts as health food and that it would make a good late breakfast or early lunch. You’ve got fruit, pecans, and calcium-​rich custard. If you don’t count the hot fudge and crème caramel, it can’t have too many calories, right? ;) FYI: Andy’s opens at 11!

Once upon a time, my husband and I drove by Andy’s after eating dinner nearby and decided to stop and check it out. We’ve been back time and time again, so I’m glad we made that smart decision!
There’s both a convenient drive-​thru and walk up windows with several outdoor benches. If the weather is nice, we like to order at the window and claim a bench. The drive-​thru is super convenient if we just want to place a quick order or not worry about braving the outdoor elements.
Andy’s has a decent selection of mix-​ins and offers both vanilla and chocolate custard. My favorite is the James Brownie Jackhammer… vanilla custard (I always sub chocolate), peanut butter, and brownie pieces with a hole drilled through the center and filled with hot fudge. It’s absolutely amazing down to the last bite! I’ve also tried the very tasty triple chocolate concrete (chocolate custard with cookie dough and chocolate chips) and my hubby really enjoys a vanilla concrete mixed with brownie and peanut butter. Ordering a small is plenty… I always have a hard time finishing my last few bites, but was taught not to waste my food. ;)
Andy’s always hits the spot. I’ll be back to enjoy another thick, rich, and creamy concrete soon!

Hello, Andy! You’re a chain, but you may be my new BCF (Best Custard Friend).
I really try to shop/​eat local and am a big supporter of Missouri Made, but your custard made my taste buds do a very energetic happy dance. It was nice to see that you offer your rich and creamy custard in both vanilla and chocolate, unlike our hometown favorite which only offers vanilla.
Your small is smaller then the regular at TD’s, but it is the perfect portion for a sweet treat. On our recent visit, we enjoyed two concretes. My choice of blended treat was Reese’s Pieces. However, my friend had the best of our two. He went with, Key Lime Pie. I enjoyed my favorite candy blended in my vanilla custard, but his vanilla custard blended with a sweet-​tart pie with graham cracker crust, definitely won the blue ribbon.
As we stood at the window to place our order, we could smell the aroma of brownies being baked fresh on site. The staff was personable and the service was fast. With the large windows you can see a pristine kitchen and two large machines churning out the fresh custard.
I can walk to Ted, but when the custard craving hits, I’ll be driving to Andy.