Silverman Judy MD

Dr. Silverman is thorough, gracious and very competent. She has helped me in correctly diagnosing back problems and ordering appropriate PT. So glad another doc at St. Mary’s recommended her!

11.23 was my 1^st time meeting Dr. Silverman. I had been suffering w/​Sciatica and getting no help from my regular Doctor, who sent me to P.T. & IB pro-​fen. Maybe I needed to learn to explain my needs better (Lesson)nothing worked & I contacted my Primary Dr & begged for better drugs or someone who specialized in this area. Referred to Dr. Silverman part of the Spinal Dept @ St. Mary’s. NOTE: Lots of paperwork arrive 30 m early. Our 1^st meeting I explained I was soooo over pills, P/​T that was doing right for my ails. Dr. Silverman heard me! She not only listened, she heard what I needed from her. I need to be able without drugs conquer this shit. Conducted a few mobility test, then shared her findings & her thoughts & how to treat. My Rx reads as follows: The Cobra 10 sets/​10 reps and after 3 days I felt the effect! Seriously no more pills, being unable to sit or stand after sitting. I waited until today 12÷2÷15 after my follow-​up to finish this review. I hugged her I was so very, very pleased she was who I was referred to! She is simply the best!!! I knew that today might the last time I would have to see her (because she is that good). I hope I never see her again, BUT if I have Sciatica again I will contact her immediately! Sorry this is long but I wanted to let it be known this is a person you want in your court for Spine Injuries. (10 stars was unavailable). Shout out to the Front Office Folks too!

Well, there’s a difference between lack of bedside manner and being downright rude. After a year of being mostly pain free due to Pilates, my mother died and I ended up back in a ton of pain because I couldn’t quite keep up with exercise.
I’m writing this while lying down unable to move right now.
I was told that (a) my body is telling me i need to not work so much (ok, so I don’t have the luxury of not working, but Dr. Silverman never offered to be my sugar momma) and (b) «I’m not going to dope you up just so you can work.» Not even recommendations about alternatives to opiates. Just an assumption that that was what I was there for, despite my pleas, and I was walked out on. She also advised me not to see my back specialist, which I am doing tomorrow since I now can’t move.
I’m really disappointed in the change in care. I’ll never step foot in there again.

I just lost my whole review when I signed in. Silverman is great. Unilocal sucks. Why?

Dr. Silverman is amazing. She isn’t one to sugar coat her opinions, but I’d rather have honesty from my doctor. She’s thoughtful and caring, and went above and beyond to coordinate my care.

If you have Fibromyalgia and are seeking the help of a doctor for back pain, related or unrelated to your FMS/​CFS, this is NOT the doctor to see. She will start with «I do not believe in Fibromyalgia,» and the rest is too distressing to report. Use your time and money wisely and seek another orthopedist.

I think I understand some of the negative reviews of Dr. Silverman but completely disagree with them. She is a very caring, attentive doctor who spends an amazing amount of time with a patient, listening carefully to every detail and making a thoughtful diagnosis. She is not cold at all but very calm and methodical, taking total charge of the visit. This aspect of being totally in control and no nonsense in her approach might turn some people off but I appreciated the care and thoughtfulness she’s shown me over the years. I highly recommend her as someone who goes to great lengths to find alternatives to surgery but when it’s necessary helps you find the best possible surgeon. St. Mary’s Spine Center is run as a very tight ship but so is every other hospital based practice.

Dr Silverman is patient, thoughtful, passionate about her field, and just a great expert and advocate. I don’t really understand the reviews here that say she’s cold and rude — she’s not an effusive person, but I found her very genuine and a great listener. Highly recommended.

What it’s like to see Dr. Silverman: Imagine talking with someone for an hour with them NEVER smiling or having any warmth whatsoever. So, if you can take that, the question is how good a doctor she is, which is what you’re going for. With me, she quickly came to a conclusion before she’d looked at any MRI & x-​ray records I brought. She came to a conclusion that made no sense to me; I had to ask why she came to that conclusion. She made no attempt to explain her ideas and why she had different ideas than all the other doctors I’ve seen for decades. She only wanted to give me one drug after another; she spent the most time reviewing potential horrific side effects. I don’t like drugs. The drug she prescribed had no vegetarian version (not in gelatin capsule; tablets don’t have that). She didn’t review non-​drug options. I decided that I needed a back adjustment. I called to make an appointment with the osteopath in that office, Jerel Glassman. On a previous call, the receptionist said the doctors there worked independently. When I called to make the appointment, the receptionist said I’d have to talk with another administrative person. That person said that Drs. Silverman and Glassman operate as a team. She said Dr. S was listed as my doctor, even though I told her I don’t want that any more. She said Dr. S. would have to give permission for me to see Dr. G. She transferred me to Dr. Silverman’s message machine. I asked her to call me back, saying I think I need an adjustment and want to see Dr. Glassman. She NEVER called me back. In sum: If you think you want an osteopathic adjustment, see Dr. Glassman FIRST. In sum about Dr. Silverman: she is humorless and her drug-​oriented analysis made no sense to me.

I have nothing but great things to say about Dr. Silverman and feel lucky to have found her on the recommendation of my physical therapist. She is a very capable, knowledgeable and caring doctor who actually takes the time to listen to you. In a dark time where I was in a lot of pain, she quickly got me the best care possible while doing everything to avoid surgery and invasive procedures as a first approach, which I really appreciate.
I was most impressed that she takes her time with you, doesn’t make you feel rushed and genuinely seems to care about her patients. She is also upfront about medical issues and advice, which is something I appreciate.
I ended up getting a cortisone epidural for my herniated disc after we had exhausted all other possibilites and she sent me to an equally wonderful specialist for the procedure. She also recommended a great physical therapist near my home for rehab.
Her staff is very friendly and my interactions with them have been great. They are always nice in person and on the phone. She accepts co-​pays in cash/​check only. Parking in the garage below makes for easy access without exorbitant fees (I’ve seen way worse at medical buildings around the city).

Had a wonderful experience with Dr. Silverman and would recommend her to friends and family. She was very knowledgeable and listened closely to everything I had to say. One of the better experiences i’ve had at a doctors office.

Dr. Silverman is thorough, sensible, and open-​minded. She will propose a variety of treatment options for chronic pain, explain them carefully, and give you time to mull them over before making a decision. She has a wealth of knowledge about alternative treatments, and while encouraging patients to keep non-​Western approaches in mind, she does not force them on you. For most patients, finding the right chronic pain treatment approach is a careful process of trial and error. I think Dr. Silverman does a great job guiding patients through that process.

Dr. Silverman is fantastic! I’ve seen well over a dozen ortho and nerve specialists for chronic lower back and neck pain and this is the first time in 20 years I’ve had any real relief. She listens without judgement and what I love most is that she is open to alternative treatments without recklessly forcing them on patients. For example, my other doctors have poo-​pooed the idea that foods I eat impact my pain levels. Dr. Silverman asked where she can learn more. Also when I asked her about PEMF healing, which no other doctor (except Dr. Oz) knew anything about, she was WAY ahead of me. LOVE HER! Plus I never have to wait more than 5 minutes to see her.

Her beside manner is freakin cold and rude. i complained about pain and refused to x-​ray. i wont be back.

I saw Dr. Silverman earlier this year in my relentless pursuit for the right doctor while healing a fractured vertebra and herniated disc. She was doctor #3, I think.
Very thorough, very professional, very knowledgeable. Not the best bedside manner though. On the verge of (sorry) — cold.
It was nice that she suggested peppermint as a pain reliever. Never heard that before and liked her alternative approach.
Overall though, didn’t work for me — but if you are completely immune to lack of bedside manner and are looking for a smart doctor open to alternative treatments, you should check her out.

I was a patient of hers for a low back injury. She takes a TON of time to take a complete and accurate history and thorough exam, seemingly unpressured to see a million patients every hour, like so many doctors these days. She is very patient oriented, referred me to a specific physical therapist, and my complaints subsided. She is a wonderful doctor and I highly recommend her.