Buon Amici Delicatessen

This place is great. Small and defiantly better to call and order ahead of time. I love the Stoli Chicken Sandwich. Give it a shot but if you walk in at noon it will be packed. Call ahead.

Best sandwiches in town! 007 is my favorite. I came in really early one morning, and I watched them make the fresh mozzarella. Everything is really fresh, including the bread. Great, friendly staff. All the locals love Buon amici!

Buon Amici is the real deal.
They are known for their panini combinations and rightfully so.
The freshness and quality of the ingredients really come through.
I suggest the bruschetta sandwich, the mozzarella, bruschetta, chicken, and seasoned mayo come together perfectly on the grilled panino.
The staff is very friendly with the owner mostly always present.
A bit expensive but always worth it.

This is by far the best deli in the area. Do not let the size of the place fool you. The food is excellent and the staff is as well. The owner always has a smile and a handshake waiting. I have had a lot of things from here and I never had anything bad. Never. Great Deli !!!

Everyone at Buon Amici is friendly and quick. The food is always fresh and delicious. They are amazing :)

Amazing sandwiches and hot food! These people get it! They know how to prepare
excellent food. I visit here weekly, never a bad lunch. I highly recommend the 007!

Walked in at 2 pm asked for Deli Sandwich. But the slicer was being washed. So I decided to look at the hot buffet. I asked counter person is that chicken Frances. The owner or manager says please look at our menu on the wall behind you. So I decided to simply spend my money somewhere else. It’s looks like a clean and nice deli but here is a tip… wash your slicer after 3pm and answer a simple question.

The reviews speak for themselves ! This place is legitimately good. The place gets incredibly busy around lunchtime which is another sign that this place serves delicious quality sandwiches. I had the Americano and Cutting Edge both were fantastic!

I’ve used Buon Amici for catered events, for delivery, and for pick-​up. The staff is friendly and flexible, the quality of food is unbelievably high, the delivery is quick, and it just tastes great. Thanks, and keep up the great work!
Addendum: I can’t stop thinking about their fresh mozzarella and horseradish sauce, which they add to my roast beef wraps. I’m definitely ordering that again!

I can see why they get rave reviews. We got the Ixtapa panini, lasagna, and penne alla vodka. All were AMAZING. Probaby one of the best lasagnas I ever had (a little salty, but great with a side salad) and my daughter kept asking for more penne. We will be back. Only drawback was that there’s no seating so we had to wait 20 mins to get home and the food was not as hot.

This is a nice family owned place, the food is decent. However I was lost when our waiter came over and gave us the specials. It was like another menue. I think they could renovate the restaurant inside. However I think they could do a little better.
But I would go back.

Great little deli. Food is great. Very friendly staff. Good selection.
They’re good about correcting mistakes in the order (which are rare to begin with)

There is nothing here that isn’t amazing. I have loved everything I have eaten here. The panini sandwiches are great. My favorite is the Ixtapa. The fresh pasta dishes are unbelievable and so are the soups and chicken chili. You can’t go wrong with anything here.

The best wraps and paninis in westchester. The Americana panini is so delicious that I drive an extra 15 minutes out of my way to order here. Tried almost every wrap and they are all good. No complaints here! Perfectly heated with the right amt of dressing. The hot meals are prepared fresh and are so tempting. The chicken cutlets melt in your mouth. Grilled veggies are delish too. One time, I was sick with an annoying cold and the chicken soup was the right remedy for me. It was definitely homemade with a smooth, full flavored broth. John and the crew are really nice and they know their customers well. Order anything and you won’t be disappointed. Would be nice to see some more cold side dishes. Homemade Pasta salads (macaroni, pasta, tortellini etc…) would be a great addition to the selection.

The bread is what makes these sandwiches truly incredible– the paninis come on crusty, chewy Italian ciabatta mini loaves. Every sandwich I’ve tried is great. Favorites include the Crazy, Parma, and Cancun. Fresh, quality ingredients are used. Friendly service, though very fast-​paced. If you don’t order over the phone, walk in knowing what you want if you’re going at a busy time. Not a whole lot of patience extended.

The food is good if you can manage to get your order through the Scarsdale yuppies who like to cut the line. Make sure you take out a second mortgage before you eat here. I don’t own a home, so I guess I’ll get a second job so I can eat here. Everything is overpriced. Get a wrap and treat your taste buds.

Italy in Scarsdale, amazing panini sandwiches made fresh on the spot with great ingredients from Italy. Friendly staff. Prices are modest, plenty of parking outside.

None other than legendary here in Scarsdale. Always packed during the lunch rush hours (when the high school lets out), and for good reason. Their sandwiches are simply divine and of some of the best quality I’ve ever had. Everything they make here is just delicious, from the chicken cutlets to the bread, and the place is well run. The 007 is simply the king of sandwiches– chicken cutlet, mozzarella, bacon, and hot sauce. Every once and a while I’ll treat myself to one of these bad boys. Buon Amici catered my graduation party and all of the food was excellent. Whether stopping for lunch or looking for a caterer for your next event, look no further.

This place is and will always be one of my favorites. John and the gang are always welcoming, and do a great job of making quality food.
I should really do a review on each of the sandwiches as there so many great ones to choose from. Most of the sandwiches are Panini style, they are not the biggest, but a sandwich will fill up most people. The wraps are also good, and I like the salads as well.
To name a few of my favorites in no particular order:
Stoli — Chicken parm with vodka sauce. A nice variation of a classic. Get it with prosciutto and you won’t be disappointed.
Roma — Classic Italian Panini, probably better than what you would find in Italy.
Parma — Even more classic than the Roma, for those who truly appreciate parmigiano reggiano.
Draft — Pepperoni and chicken cutlet with ranch and caramelized onions. I’ve never had a combo like that, but it is great.
Crazy — Even crazier combination — chicken cutlet, bacon, pastrami, mozzarella, pesto, and hot sauce. Got to try it at least once.
Ixtapa — I did save the best for last. This is my hand down favorite. Chicken Cutlet, Bruschetta, Monterey Jack, Avocado, Chipotle Mayo on Jalapeño Popper Roll. This sandwich is unique as the bread is not regular Panini bread. The bread has cheese and jalapenos baked right in. (Tip — you can get that bread with any sandwich if you want to spice things up) This sandwich has so much flavor. It really can’t be beat. Get it with bacon or prosciutto and you have yourself a hit.
Other things to try are the nutella paninis, with or without cheese. Also have a nutella with cheese and bacon which is good.
But if you really want a dessert sandwich get the nutella with walnuts. Its something I made up one day, and eventually John put it on the board.
Which leads me to the last reason I love this place. They are always willing to make whatever you want. John is always looking to try something new. If you are ever in the area, you need to make a stop at Buon Amici. You won’t be disappointed.

This is that one in a million place that gets 5 stars. The sandwiches here are outstanding I’ve tried so many different things on the menu and its all great. The guys behind the counter are awesome! Always greet you with a smile and are so polite.