Vince the Pizza Prince

sorry u burnt it again

Where to start?
3 stars is because of a 4.5 star pizza (very good and very unique… coming from someone that has had pizza all over the country and world) combined with a 2 star rating for service. It isn’t that anyone is really rude here (my usual complaint about service), but more that it is extremely difficult to actually get a pizza here and get it on time if it is a weekend.
How to convey my point? Perhaps a short storey of my last visit there. A businessman that knew Vince the Pizza Prince had something going for him offerred to buy another establishment, all they had to provide was the recipe and he would split it 50/50…because well, it is damn near impossible to get a pizza here on-​time on a Friday (Pro Tip: Order before they open!). Of course, the prince himself declined and to this day one must still battle for the right to a slice.
IMPORTANT NOTE: You will not likely find a pepporoni pizza like theirs anywhere… try it!

This has been my favorite round pizza for years – back when Vince’s father ran the place. It still is my favorite pizza – unique and full of flavor with a nice crispy crust.
HOWEVER…on a recent visit I was apalled by how the owner treated a customer. An elderly gentleman came in and asked if he could purchase a pizza for his nephew whose birthday was coming up. He asked the owner if he could just put a note on the wall with the nephews name and mark it: owe one pizza… the owner wigged out. He was very loud and and disrepectful of the elderly man and shouted «oh no buddy, I’m not going to be responsible for anyone’s money». The man then asked him if he could purchase a gift certificate. The owner very rudely said «i don’t have any». Then he got real cocky and said” how about this. did you ever think of this, why not throw $ 10 bucks in a envelope and say there-that’s your pizza money”. the elderly gentleman just put his head down and walked out, totally embarrassed. Then the owner continued to talk about the guy with other patrons and his employees. Shame on this owner !!! This is certainly not the first time I have witnessed a nasty attitude from this place — but I can tell you this much – as much as I love the pizzza– I won’t go back. Anyone who could publicly humiliate another human being in this fashion does not deserve my money. And if my memory serves me correctly the owner certainly has nothing to have his head so high up in the air for.

Kinda unique but kinda really good pizza (get it with pepperoni). Just don’t expect it to be ready when they say it will (add 10 minutes to whatever time they tell you and you should be good).

This pizza is my absolute favorite, and that’s coming from someone who practically grew up in Old Forge. Seriously the best pizza that I know of. The first time I had this pizza was at the old place in the Clarks Summit location, but that has since closed down. My buddy Jim and I stopped to get something to eat, and the name and the castle of a building won us over. When we got our order, I was incredibly hesitant to try the pizza: it looks disgusting! Brown patches of cheese, the sauce is strange, not to mention how hot it was. After trying it, though, we came back for more pizza every time we were in the area.
Anyway, the pizza is so damn good that I drive 45 minutes on 81 during rush hour just to get some pizza every now and then. Highly recommended.

The Prince of goopy weird, delicious orangey white cheese pizza! A little more spiced up that Maroni’s it falls 2^nd place to my all time favorite MARONI’S PIZZA. i also hear the dude delivers large orders of pizzas to NY via AIRPLANE in the summer