Anthony’s Pizza

I visit Anthony’s Pizza 3 – 4 times a month. Simply fantastic service and the food is all made to order. Family owned and frequented by locals. Service is prompt and food is excellent!

After reading both reviews on Google and here on Unilocal,I decided to try this location. I called up Anthony’s for a carry out order and let them know that it was my first time ordering and would like a recommendation on which pizza was their most popular or which pizza they considered their specialty. They didn’t know the answer and had no recommendation and proceeded to read me the full pizza menu. A little concerned for the employees inability to relay helpful information to new customers, I decided on a small basic Margherita pizza… to get a baseline. After showing up exactly when they said it would be ready, I waited almost 5 minutes to even be acknowledged and I was the only customer! It took another 15 to receive my pie. While waiting, I observed one of the employees prepping toppings without wearing gloves or a hair net, frequently stopping to text on his phone. Not exactly the cleanest thing to touch while making food for other people. Without making this review any longer than it already is, I’ll end by saying after one slice I threw out the pizza. The sauce tasted heavily of vinegar, the cheese was sparse and the spices muted. The crust was crisp but bland. Worse pizza restaurant I’ve had tried in a while.

Excellent pizza! Recently moved back to the neighborhood after being away for many years. Decided to give Anthony’s a try since it’s so close, and ended up ordering 2 days in a row, it was that good :)
Flavorful sauce, the consistency of the crust was on point, and good sauce to cheese ratio. I’m excited to try the ‘Grandma pie’ that someone mentioned in another post.

Have been ordering from here for probably around 10 years now, and only recently discovered the secret to getting a good pizza here. Their standard pies that are available on the menu are nothing to write home about since identical pizzas are sold at every other pizza joint.
However, if you order the «Grandma’s pie» you’ll wind up with a pizza that really swings. The drawback to this order is that it is more expensive than their normal pies and they will not always know what you’re referring to when ordering Grandma’s pie. In that instance you’ll have to ask for a square pie with sauce on top.

We’ve only had the pizza and it’s delicious! We order from here about once every other week and love it. Only notched down to 4 stars because of price (it’s about 50% more for here than some of the other local pizza places that compare in quality.

Very good pizza. My husband and I ordered dinner recently — Veal Parm, ravioli, side of sausage. I was a little surprised when the bill was $ 31 but then when I got and opened up our meals, I was totally okay with it. The veal parm dish was packed and not just with the pasta. There were three giant pieces of veal and a ton of cheese. The ravioli dish, while not completely packed in the tin, there were a huge amount of them. The sausage side was two huge pieces of sausage. Each dinner came with a small salad (not a whole lot in it lettuce tomato peppers… and pickles, hmmmm I don’t know about that) and a large piece of bread — very very fresh yummy bread. Everything was good and we had leftovers for the next night. Your order is always ready when they say it will be. Staff is always pleasant and smiling. Really wished they delivered though!

Ate here not too long ago while I went to go visit a friend. I had never been to Anthony’s so decided to give it a shot. The first time we ordered from them we got a simple large cheese pizza. That they managed to do fairly right, and despite people saying «pizza is pizza» they really do a good job on being generous with the cheese and not leaving the top slathered in grease. Nice for a cheese slice fix.
However my downside happened when I came the second time and ordered spaghetti. It was fairly cold out and the pizza slice wasn’t gonna be enough to hold me over. So my buddy and I decided to get a bite from Anthony’s. I chose the spaghetti and the initial presentation of it was standard fair for many pizza/​hoagie places — salad, bread, and the spaghetti. Presentation looked decent so I had good hopes for my meal. Paid $ 11.25 for it. The woman who took my order though was a little snippy, but I took it with a grain of salt. When we got home I opened the lid to discover three very average sized meatballs…
Disappointment. They tasted like they were grocery store freezer brand and just tossed in a pan with some sauce. Bland. No flavor. And the actual pasta didn’t do it any justice at all. I could toss some Prego sauce in a pan at home and make better meatballs then this place. The salad wasn’t at all all that good, and if anything looked wilted. How do you mess up salad?
All in all I’ll probably be sticking with my local pizza place Angelo’s pizza. At least their spaghetti is a large portion, with meatballs covering the entire container, a good sized salad and garlic breadsticks to boot.
If you come here, just stick with their pizza or sandwiches, which looked decent. Don’t go the pasta route unless you really want too. For $ 11.25 of that price you could go to your nearest grocery and make a brimming pot of spaghetti that will taste better than what this place had to offer.

We love Anthony’s Pizza. It is a tradition in our house to pickup dinner there every Friday night to start off the weekend right! We order the thin crust well done pizza and sometimes a cheese steak to go with it. The people there know us name and are always very friendly and professional. If you are looking for a great place to eat in Washington Township, Anthony’s is the place to go.

I like Anthony’s the pizza is really good but what they do that keeps me coming back are the chicken cheesesteak hoagies. Yum! I so wish they would deliver though. :(

This pizza is the best in town… Has never once disappointed. Only drawback is that they don’t deliver :(