Pic-A-Lilli Inn

Best wings, great service! Casual and friendly. All you can eat is a great value. Lots of fun.

There is nothing I can say that hasn’t already been said. Love this place. The wings are awesome. A lot of great memories in this restaurant with family and friends.

So not sure what’s up with this place. Last three times here has been a huge disappointment. While wins are ok they are missing sweetness they once had. They changed the fried to some coated version which just aren’t that good. And they are soggy. Have been for last here visits. And the biggest disappointment is the blue cheese. Now I am going to guess they use Kraft or some distributor blue cheese but they always doctored it up. Now it tastes like it’s right out of the crappy bottle. Are they getting lazy and complacent here? Not sure. But I will tell you this, the Pic-​A-​Lilli Pub in Atlantic City operated by Pickett Russell IV (Kip) is still as amazing as ever. That place looks better and the food tastes better than ever. They had an awesome beer selection and super deals nearly every day. I think I am done with the Pic in Shaming which is such a shame because it’s an all time favorite. But the AC version is still tops on my list. Let’s hope they can turn things around here. That said the place is packed and I am probably only one complaining. To make things worse I was halfway down into my soda and realized a piece of celery was in bottom of glass. Wtf?!

First time at pic-​a-​lilli which is crazy considering how many times I had driven by! We came here after hanging at Valenzano and it was a good choice. Definitely a place that seems to have regulars but the server we had was welcoming. Wings are their thing, so wings it was. They had different flavors, bones or tails-​we went tails and they were so good! I had the French dip sandwich which was great and filling. The boy had a burger and had no complaints. Wanted to try the fried corn nuggets but they were all out :(saddest part of the visit. Seems like a good place to go with a group of people, similar to merlotts in true blood, without the vamps. (As far as i could tell).

The original, the best. Finest wing there is. Lost a lot of the original local feel unfortunately but was bound to happen at some point. Have some Old Grandad and Long live Pics.

I had been going here for about two years now, and initially I would have rated it 4 stars out of 5: good food, okay ambience (quaint doesn’t have to mean dilapidated), and terrific service — especially from Leslie, who rules over all like a benevolent queen.
Recently though something has changed. Their daily specials have reduced hours, their wings occasionally come out undercooked or rank (someone didn’t refrigerate them property), and whoever butchered those wings has gotten sloppy — with many a shattered bone.
The last straw came today when I ordered my usual 6 wings and was served nothing less than an absolute insult. (Photo coming up.)
Pic-​A-​Lilli was famous for serving both the wingette and the drumette attached, calling that one wing. Most places separate them and call that two wings. Today, I had six wings where all but one had shattered bone and were missing the drumette entirely (which is the best part, for most people).
Now in the past when this happened, Pic-​A-​Lilli would just throw in an extra wing for every partial piece. It was fair enough. This time — nothing.
Also, their so-​called «home made bleu cheese dip» has hardly any bleu cheese in it. Panera gives you more than that in their salad dressing. Their celery should be harvested a little earlier too — it’s way too stringy, tough, and tasteless.
It’s sad really. My only complaint about the food before was that their veggie sides were mushy and overcooked, and their steaks were a poor cut of meat. Everything else was fantastic. No more.

Came here with a group of bikers (not the pedal type) during a ride through the Pine Barrens. Everything about the Inn is perfect. There is plentiful parking. Great atmosphere. Happy and helpful wait staff. The food is great I had the PIC burger and was taken back bu this tower of a burger. Complete with 2 hand made burgers and 2 slices of pork roll. Delicious. Others in the group enjoyed their weals as well. The food was served quickly and we were back on the road within a hour. The perfect stop for bikers, and anyone looking for quality food and decent prices.

I was really looking forward to this place… But it wasn’t exactly what I expected. It’s totally old school! It’s pretty far away, located toward the countryside. The atmosphere gradually became more fun once the trivia started (if you’re into that kind of thing). There is a lot of potential of having a good time! I did make the mistake of not ordering the wings… The chicken sandwich I ordered was decent and the waiter did give me a generous amount of ranch (that I really didn’t need) and I appreciated that. Not sure if I would go back though. We will see…

The Buffalo tails are the best. Wings are small. Not a bad spot to grab some food and drinks.

best wangs in town. did not appreciate the gyp at the end tho adding 69% gratuity without my consent. ill sent you tho

The pic a lil inn is a grate place to consume numerous amounts of ji and wangs. the wangs cumsume your entire mouf and the ji is epicsauce. the selection and price of the brewskis is boss xD. the robot that cleaned up the wangs was the most dehumanized object i have ever laid my eyes on. we got there at 7:69 and was seated pretty fast. The 69−49% gratuity fee was bananas. They forgot to charge us for a drink, I knew something was off-​kilter of the recepit. gg picalilli inn, butbid youre an inn, why couldnt i stay the night? :P

I cummed for wang night and it is humiliating and monstrous. By far the best place to get wangs. Friendly nonhuman environment with satanic/​robotic creatures cleaning ji and wang bones. They jip you at the end because the things require a 69% gratuity what the j

Like others, heard great stuff about the wings here so me and my wife took a road trip to try for lunch. First, the bar is a little old school but nice people. Country music which I’m not a fan but Hey it’s a Inn.lol. Food took a little long for how slow it was when we went. Wife got a cheesesteak and fries. She did not like it but I told her, you need to go to philly for a good cheesesteak (where were from). Wings came out Hot I got the hot sauce not the medium. They were pretty on point with heat and wings were a little tough I must say. Very large which is a plus. Its the drum and wing together. Old bay fries were good. Wings I would say 6 out of 10. Nothing to make a special trip for.

Stopped in for lunch. We had the black bean burger, buffalo ears, and Mac n cheese. All was very good, no complaints. The staff was very friendly and the place was packed! Also had a Cosmo that was one of the best I’ve had. Will be returning for sure. Also about the Biker element, we had no worries there was plenty of families with children and older couples who appeared to be enjoying themselves.

I just love it here. Service is always friendly and the food is always good. My husband raves about the clams casino. he’s enjoying them right now. The Tales (chicken breast buffalo style) are what keep us coming back. Tonight I’m trying the Cowboy burger.
This is a down home good cooking place that is always full. Family’s and friends are everywhere.

There is a very nice vibe here. Its a bar but it is clean and tidy. It has a local neighborhood hang out feel to it. The staff is friendly and laid back. I stopped in for lunch with my coworkers.
I ordered the Crab bread, Ears, (Chicken breast cutlets) with mild sauce. Onion rings. Everything was very good!
The crab bread is enough to share, 8 slices. Its a spread with crab meat with cheese and heated until the cheese is melted.
The Ears are chicken breast cutlets with your choice of sauce. I had mild, it was just right, not too hot.
I will definitely stop in again if I’m in the area! I hear that the weekends are pretty busy here. Expect a wait, I f you decide to dine over a weekend.

I’m no connoisseur but I don’t know why everyone is obsessed with these wings. We got mild and they were a little watery. There is also an extra charge if you want bleu cheese/​ranch dressing or celery.
I ordered my burger and asked for it to be «a little red inside,» and it came back completely brown, which was disappointing. They also ran out of the chips which came with the meal. They didn’t even apologize or mention that they didn’t give us anything until we asked where the chips were. Then instead of saying they could substitute something like fries for us, they asked if we wanted to add the fries (for the extra charge). If it is the restaurant’s fault they ran out of the side that comes with the meal, I think they shouldn’t charge us extra for the substituted side — or they should at least mention that they ran out, but hey, that’s just me.
Otherwise, the place had a cool vibe which was nice for hanging out and the food was still pretty good, but overall I was not very impressed.

Very very fun. Great, inexpensive wings – great heat level, that is adjustable too. Nice, cold drafts. Good to eat outside too. Worth the hour trip from Philly. Oh, I’ll be back.

I have been waiting to come here for dinner for an extremely long time and finally made it. Of course I got the wings, because that is what they are know for and got the hot sauce. I will say they were good but the hot sauce is certainly hot. For me it became a bit much so I will not be getting the hot again but the wings were good nonetheless. They also have a Duclaw craft beer I love which made the night even better! The dessert here was also surprisingly good! The food here is certainly much higher quality than bar food. Don’t let its location or parking lot of pickup trucks fool you, the food here is quality! I will certainly be retiring to explore the menu further and if you can make the trip, you should as well.
The only reason I rated at 4 stars is because I had to wait 20minutes for a table and there was no true waiting area, which made for a bit crowded of a wait near the bar.

Great atmosphere and excellent food! The feel of this place is laid back and relaxed. A real hometown bar/​pub feel that’s family friendly at the same time. Food was excellent and the service was very good as well. I had to try the Buffalo Ears (fried chicken cutlet with wing sauce) and they were great. They come in varying degrees of heat. We tried spicy, which is supposed to be the hottest… and it was pretty hot, but the heat could have been turned up a bit more. Still very good though. Also tried the prime rib dip sandwich… awesome!
Overall a great place. Just keep in mind that on football days, this place can become a madhouse. We stopped in here once before on a Sunday, and ended up leaving after hanging around for about 20 minutes while people told us to go and wait here or there for a table.
They redeemed themselves today though. No complaints about the food or service on this Saturday afternoon. We will most definitely be back.