Carriage House Pizzeria

Was searching for a new pizza place because all of the ones in the Canton/​Stoughton area were not as good as they used to be. Decided to try this place and I’m glad I did. The red pepper and spinach pizza is amazing. My new favorite pizza place!

Solidly three stars. I’ve been working my way through their menu, and the best bets here are the really excellent sandwiches, better than anywhere else in Sharon. The hot roast beef is a must. Tried a Greek salad wrap and didn’t care for it. Too much onion. Didn’t like a slice of cheese… some weird spicing issues there. A meatball calzone was really tasty, albeit a bit overly garlicked.
The girl at the register is sweet and helpful… she is an asset to this business.
Wait time can be a bit much at lunch peak. Prices are pretty good. Parking in the lot or on the street can be dicey.

4 stars for the food and friendliness of the cashier. 1 star for the wait and that they didn’t sell cheese pizza by the slice on a Friday night. I had to buy a small pie instead for my 6 year old which I waited 30 minutes for. My CBLT came out after we finished the pie.

I enjoy Carriage House quite a bit. A lovely small place in Sharon with pleasant employees and very good food. Their pizzas are very good, their delivery is reliable, and the sandwiches I’ve had there have been yummy. My favorite thing there is the mozzarella sticks. Delicious. Anyway, if you’re hungry and in Sharon, stop by. It’s a chill place and the food’s good.

I’ve now tried their pizza and their sandwiches a handful of times. Very good food, fairly priced and good service. Very good for a pizza and sandwich shop.

This is definitely the best pizza in the area. Italian style (wouldn’t be ashamed to serve it in Italy). This is the place for pizza in Sharon. Price is reasonable too.

Outstanding Pizza! By far the Best Pizza around. We love the sandwiches, salads and calzones as well. The ingredients are always fresh and perfectly prepared. Very clean establishment and professional staff! Can’t wait to go back!

Great Italian pizza! I ordered a large with extra cheese. It certainly had extra! Next time I will probably just order it as is. The dough was thin the way I like it. We also got a small wings order, teriyaki flavor and they were great! It’s about time Sharon had a good slice of Italian pizza. Update: I had the chicken parm dinner and it was huge and delicious!

Great place for food. Pizza is always delicious! I would recommend the meatball parm sub and all the calzones are great too!!! Everyone who works there is extremely pleasant and the services is excellent. Great place!!!

Their NYC style thin crust pizza is addicting. Find myself craving their special dough with savory sweet sauce and exceptional crust. They have by far the BEST Chicken Parmesan sandwiches — you can tell they take pride in making it and use fresh crisscross buns… they slice up the chicken and the cheese is gooey! The owners have worked hard to change this non-​traditional pizza place up, they are pleasant, and make it a place to visit frequently!

yum, this is a great new spot to try but no just the pizza. They make a delicious, spinach salad with fresh goat cheese and the new soups and chili they’ve added really round things out. Excellent service, nice family owned place, a new hang out for us

Nice fresh NYC style pies. The lunch special is a fabulous deal. 2 slices of your choice and a bottle of soda or a small Richies slush.
If you ask them they will likely make a slice pie with your choice of toppings.

This place is great. The pizza is always delicious. Always fresh ingredients. The meatball sub is a great option.

My boyfriend and I ordered chicken broccoli Alfredo and Bolognese pasta. They were both not good at all. Very little runny sauce, the chicken was chewy and really just bland. My boyfriend also didn’t like his dish. Anyone can do better at home with canned sauce. They foccacia bread was horrible. I only give it a 2 stars because they deliver.

hub brought home takeout: a GF pizza, a salad, and an app of wings. first thing he said coming home was: never going back to this place. why? that «meal for one» cost $ 30. yeah, i am hungry again now that i ate and just finished my review.
wings were fried, with a side of dipping sauce (BBQ and honey mustard, not bad). margherita pizza was slathered with canned tomato and not enough cheese; strangely, basil came through in some bites. GF crust was really thin, almost like cracker (slightly burned but it’s crispy alright). strawberry walnut spinach goat cheese salad was quite yummy, actually.
aside from the pizza toppings that were a little disappointing, and the value of the meal not really there, the rest of the elements were accounted for, in the 2.5-star overall rating. and i’m glad we caught them open this time. LOL