Greece E Spoon

My wife and I went here the other day. The interior is very nice, for the small space. There is a lot of history on the walls, pictures and other artifacts.
Problem is when you get to the menu. First they were out of spanakopita, so we ordered gyros, greek fries and dolmades. The dolmades were ecellent, that was the highlight of the meal. The greek fries were tasteless, there were green flecks on them, but no seasoning or even feta to be noticed by our taste buds. My gyro had so much tzatziki sauce on it I used a spoon to scoop off 3 – 4 spoonfuls. This pretty much rendered the gyro into a «soup» on bread, making it hard to really taste the meat. I did pick out a piece of meat with no tzatziki and it was just ok. More of something I would expect off a food truck at the county fair, not restaurant quality.
My wife said she will never eat here again. I will admit I do judge greek food in the area off of the Green Bay restaurant Greek Boys. If it does not nearly meet Greek Boys quality, then there is no reason to go back. (I will say the interior design and decoration of Greece E Spoon is better than Greek Boys, but I visit restaurants for taste, not décor.) (For those of you who will say Green Bay is an hour drive north, I live in Manitowoc, so it is a 30 – 40 min drive in either direction)

We ordered take-​away from here over the weekend and I really hoped for better.
We had the Greek fries with tatziki, and while the seasoning on the fries was decent, they were mushy and the tatziki was not very good. I’d like to note that I am super picky when it comes to Greek dips, and had tons of great options when I lived in NYC… then I wound up marrying a Greek guy whose family does a great job at these dips, so yes, I am biased.
Another thing I really disliked: the pita bread was fried. How awful! Pita bread should be baked just enough to be firm but slightly pliant for the dips.
The only thing I liked OK was the «Greek-​a-​mole» even though the next day my husband tried it and said it had too much garlic.
The delux gyro was a disappointment. Just boring to me. I only had one bite though. My husband ate it and said it was OK. (His family doesn’t make gyros though;)
We also had the spanakopita which was OK. Again, I only took one bite but wasn’t offended by it.
They also mixed up part of our order: We ordered dolmades and they accidentally gave us hummus instead. I also didn’t care for the hummus: taste or texture. When I called they offered to refund us the difference or for us to come by and pick up the dolmades, which was nice.
The girl at the register was very sweet, and there is a long wait time, but it’s a small kitchen, so that’s easy to forgive. The décor is very cute and it’s nice to have this option in town, especially for anyone who hasn’t had the Greek food opportunities I’ve had.
Props for using apple pay and having outdoor seating.
For me, though, I’ll stay away.

I love both the food and the story behind this restaurant. A young couple owns Greece E Spoon, and it all started with a food truck. The owner’s family has a long history in the city of Sheboygan, and the entire establishment is decorated with heirlooms. It’s clear that the owner is proud of where he’s from and cares about the community. Very cool!
Just go eat there. The tzatziki sauce is creamy and flavorful, there’s plenty of feta, and the pita is warm. I recommend the deluxe gyro, especially is you like your gyro a little spicy. Add some greek fries and baklava and you’re set. I heard they will be bringing Gyros2Go to food truck night on Mondays in Sheboygan.

was really not impressed in fact I was really disappointed in the gyros. First time at this restaurant we have been to many Greek restaurant before. We were excited to try it. We had ordered the deluxe gyros. We’re really lite on meat very thin cuts. The feta cheese was crumbs (like cottage cheese) not the cube wedge cut. The peperchinnis were not fresh peppers. It was a relish with other stuff in it. The cucumber sauce was poured on top just drenched. They forgotten the tomatoes. Also was disappointing that for the price you don’t even get fries, And soda is very expensive. Side of fries was 4.25. Next time when we want greek We will stay with Judy’s they are good or head to milwaukee Oakland gyros or gyro palace.

Not sure what it is about this place that every time I pass by it, I get the craving to come in and try one of the other items on the menu. In my opinion, they have the best gyro in town. Prices are a bit high, but reasonable once you get a taste of their food. Only knock on this place is the lack of seating. It can probably sit 20 max and that number is probably on the high side. It’s a local place, so I definitely feel the uniqueness it brings. The inside décor is actually pretty cool. From spartans to medusa, the place screams 14 year old action movies! Every time I walk in here, I have the urge to scream «This is Sparta!» Be prepared to tip even tho there isn’t a waiting service (they have one of those Square machines that make you feel guilty if you don’t tip). Cashiers are always friendly and welcoming. Looking forward to come here again if Gyro is what the taste buds require.

THE best Greek in Sheboygan, no doubt. Their gyros are fantastic and have made a name for the place, but there are two other gems on the menu I’ve discovered recently.
1. The «Village Salad» is my new favorite. It’s basically tomatoes and cucumbers cubed up with a light dressing. Add a meat (chicken is my pick) and BAM — my go to meal.
2. Desserts — ALL of them! Only a few are available each day, but every one I have had is the best I’ve had. My two favorites: carrot cake and butterscotch caramel salted cookie. Seriously, I’ve stopped by Greece e Spoon for dessert after eating at other restaurants.
Explore the menu, there are other gems to discover.

So this may be a biased review since there is no other good Gyro place in Sheboygan. But none the less Greece e is my fave place to get a gyro! I’ve gotten the classic, deluxe and the Zeus and they’re all amazing! The classic can fill you up and if you are craving a big load for the Zeus it’ll maybe have you having leftovers which is a plus. Also had the cheese curds not one complaint there, maybe a couple more would be good, but very tasty. Great brick and mortar shop, and I hope it’s going to be around for a very long time. Staff is very easy to work with, tell them the order they write it down then you pay and they take care of the rest. Try this place and you won’t be disappointed!

Deluxe Gyro: Good but way too much feta and sauce… felt like I couldn’t taste the meat.
Wife tried the Chicken Gyro: she was pleased.
Fries: just frozen fries (?) with seasoning and dipping sauce. meh.
Malts: Vanilla malt was good. Lemon lavender malt: threw it out… I want my 5 $ back! PS. Bigger straws would make life easier :)
Would def stop back for the delicious gyros! (but would ask for sauce on the side).

My Husband and I tried this place while we were in town for the evening. We chose it because it was a fast-​casual place and we were in a hurry.
It’s small, with relatively few tables for people to stay and eat at. You order at the register and pick up your food when they call your name.
I ordered the spanakopita and Greece E Burger, my husband ordered one of their gyros. The spanakopita was delicious; I would definitely recommend it. My burger was also pretty good, though it was well done (to be fair, this is probably my fault as I didn’t specify the temperature I wanted when I ordered). My husband loved his gyro.
If we were in Sheboygan, we’d return here again to try some of their other items.

The staff is very friendly and the food is superb. I love the fries.

OMG this place is a hidden gem. A co-​worker recommended this place and I am glad we took her up on it. This is a small mom and pop place that serves greek food. My co-​worker had the burger here and said it was one of the best burgers he had ever tasted. I had a spicy gyro which was really good. The onions and tomatoes needed to be chopped down a little smaller for me (the pieces were a bit large), but the gyro meat was on point. The peppers in the gyro gave it just the kick I was looking for and filled me up. Unless you are really hungry do not order the side of fries, we could not finish the order we had to share. The only downside is the service is a bit slow because the cashier is constantly answering the phone to take phone orders. Definitely going back!

I had lunch here today. Very busy at lunch. It’s small, but cool décor. I had the gyro and shared Greek fries. Gyro was good, sauce tasted hand made. The Greek fries were fantastic. No clue what the seasoning was, but delish. Highly recommend.

Try the veggie gyro!!! Greek salad is great also

I’ve been here a couple of times now, and every time it has been absolutely fantastic. My girlfriend and I were (and still are) obsessed with the Gyros2Go food truck, and we’re so happy that they have a brick and mortar location now.
First, I love the décor. There’s really cool murals on the walls. The menu is written on chalkboards in bright, different color chalks. There’s a Zeus clock on the wall. There’s even personal Greek touches from the family, including dishes and wooden spoons up on the wall. It’s extremely small inside, so be prepared to get it to-​go if the 6 or so tables inside are filled up. There’s also a few two-​tops outside.
The service is fast, but there’s no waiter service. They call your name from the counter, and you go and get it. When you’re done, you drop your own plates off in the tub and call it a day. I really like that I’m not constantly waiting for servers and that it’s in my own hands. The girls behind the counter are always polite, and it’s always a pleasure when the owner, Greg, is working. He actually recognizes my girlfriend by name from how often we go to the food truck, which I really appreciate, that he takes the time to learn his customers and talk with them.
I have yet to have a bad thing here. My girlfriend and I share our two favorite things to order here– a Zeus Gyro and Saganaki cheese curds. The cheese curds ($ 4.95) come 4 or 5 to an order, but they are huge pieces. They’re battered pieces of Greek saganaki and come with a brandy honey mustard for dipping. The Zeus Gyro ($ 10.95) is the biggest, baddest, and best gyro that Greece E Spoon has to offer. It’s double meat in a pita, and topped with onions, tomatoes, feta, hot peppers, tzatziki, and baklava bits. I know that last bit sounds weird, but it’s an AMAZING touch. I love getting a little cinnamon nut burst in my gyros. It adds something to the gyro. The meat is always well cut into thin pieces, a nice mix of tender strips and the more crispy pieces (which are the ones I prefer, to be honest with you).
This is our usual order, but their other foods are great too! The Santorini Salad ($ 8) is so refreshing. It consists of arugula, watermelon, feta, grapefruit, pomegranate seeds, pistachios, pickled red onion, and a white balsamic dressing. It sounds like a lot going on, but it somehow just works. It’s sweet and salty, crunchy and juicy, and just delicious. My girlfriend has also tried the Pastitsio ($ 4.95) and really enjoyed it. Another side/​app to try is the Greekamole, which is some heavenly mash up of Greek food and guacamole. It has lemon and garlic in it, and is served with pita triangles.
To go with our meals, we always get malts, which are all $ 4. My favorite is Lemon Lavender, but my girlfriend prefers the Chocolate. Most recently, we tried Creamy Peach, and that was lovely too. They’re smooth, creamy, and thick, but not too thick– you can still suck it up through the straw.
Their baklava is on point, and I recommend that for dessert. They also have a feta cheesecake ($ 4.25)… Which isn’t bad, but is definitely interesting. It tastes exactly how it sounds. It was supposed to come with rose jam, but when I ordered it they were out, so they topped it with pomegranate molasses instead. It didn’t look as pretty, but it tasted okay. I don’t think I’d order it again, however.
All in all, this is possibly my favorite spot in Sheboygan to have a good meal. I wish it were open on Sunday and Monday too, but with how crazy busy they are I definitely understand the rest time– plus it just makes me crave it more come Tuesday.

Yum! So glad there is a brick and mortar store in town. I never was near the food truck! The gyros are great, loaded with meat and delicious. The fries are also good, love dipping them in the taziki sauce!

Have had the Deluxe twice now and have to say that I’m disappointed. On both occasions the meat was burnt and dry. One more time and will check the quality prior to leaving with my order. I realize there will be growing pains but please check the quality before boxing and bagging.

I don’t know what the deal is here, the last couple of times the gyro meat has been exceptionally dry, the meat carved is quite thick instead of the nice and thin like my first trip, the meat is not nearly warm enough for me, and the bark they are putting on is way to much. Quite disappointing. One more minor gripe, I do not understand the tipping situation. They don’t bring you your food, soda, or pick up any of your stuff, you put it all in the garbage yourself, yet there is a tip jar for taking my order? I do not mind the system of ordering and getting your food, I just don’t think they should be pushing for tips when you are doing all the work.

Classic gyro was delicious! Service was great. The place looked great, loved the décor! I wish the place was bigger, but at least you can get food to go if it’s busy. Can’t wait to go back again!

Your Gyro and Santorini Salad were terrific for lunch this week.
Nice Vibe for a brand new brick and mortar restaurant with a loyal food truck following. It was really neat to see the owners Mom working in the kitchen and greeting customers as they picked up there food.
Your restaurant will be successful as it is obvious you are willing to do what it takes to provide fresh really tasty food for us the customer.

Went here for lunch and was surprised how good the gyro was. I heard from people about it and wanted to see for my self and i was not disappointed. They just opened up so they book a bit too long but the food is great. They have a lot of options and also have some really good tea!
Would recommend going here!