Sons of Sicily

Food is delicious. Staff and owners are super friendly, helpful and professional. Very small for the kinds of crowds that they get. We pull up and see if there is a table available before going in. We haven’t been in to eat lately as there isn’t anywhere to sit down so we go somewhere else. The lines for carryout can get very long and then you have people standing in all the aisles which makes me feel claustrophobic. It’s not their fault as they are good and very busy and the business space is small but it does affect how often we go there to eat now days. My only other complaint is half the time we go in it’s smokey and smells like something got burnt. I’m not sure if their ventilation system is poor or what but it’s very off putting. We have been sticking to carry out and we’ve also used their catering and we got a lot of compliments on the food.

The best pizza, subs, and gyros on the east coast. hands down .if you
haven’t had them you must try them, great staff also… professional and
considerate ‚
great location too their like 1 block
off the Shrewsbury exit

Solid pizza place. I’ve gone twice now and it’s been exceptional both times. –1 due to the cleanliness of the booths but other then that great food

Best pizza we have ever had. Staff is always friendly and polite. Food is Always fast and most importantly always consistent. Great wings too!

Great pizza, stromboli, lasagne. Have been here multiple times w/​family and during road food pit stops off I-​83. These guys are good. Great specials also: wings, combos, cheese steaks.

My favorite place for pizza in the shrewsbury/​new freedom/​stewartstown area. Not too doughy, not too saucy, not too cheesy. The sauce is nice and zingy not overly sweet or flat. Very flavorful pizza.

Love the pizza, best in town. Really. Even have two types of sausage though I am a fan of their white pizza.
Not a fan of their wings though they are usually undercooked so order them crispy.
They do a lot to support the community and their store and staff are always clean. Look no further for great pizza.

There subs are HUGE and tasty for the price. Pizza is decent. Only complaint is that it takes forever to wait for food. Suggest to order on phone first so it’s ready to pick up when you arrive.

Good, tasty pizza. My wife doesn’t like tomato sauce, so we get the white pizza often. It’s swell. One quick note: the place is on the corner of 851 and Mount Airy Rd. It’s showing up far south of that on the map…

The pizza is the star here. Very good tangy pizza sauce. Wings are okay. Cheesesteak was unimpressive.
The restaurant and take out gets too crowded at peak times.
The biggest negative is that the place is not that clean. The floor is always dirty, for example. Sure, it will get dirty because of the amount of customers, but it should also then be cleaned more often.

Amazing pizza!
Dough — round pizza dough was crispy, thin and had a great taste
Sauce — almost as good as it gets. Not too much or too little and the taste was great.
Cheese — excellent blend.
Overall a great location in South Central PA to get a slice! Mangia!

Always friendly and attentive service. The food is very tasty, especially the Meatball Parmesan. Pizzas are consistently good. Hats off to the owner for caring about the customer and keeping the quality high along with reasonable prices. Only wish they had a larger dining area since they do get crowded at times .;)

The pizza used to be great. USED TO.
The quality of the pizza here has severely dropped. It started off with the occasional slightly burned pizza which became progressively when we came almost always quite burnt. The overall taste isn’t bad but the lack of good preparation is making what could be an amazing pizza place into a mere less than average pizzeria. The main reason I am actually giving three stars is because their meatballs are definitely the BEST in the area I have tried. But other than that just meh.

One of the best pizzas I have ever had delivered! No greasy and the crust was excellent! Will be ordering from them whenever I don’t feel like cooking dinner!

Simple, fulfilling, reasonable prices. Not where you go for fine dining but rather a quick meal on the run. Typical Italian fare. Very young staff but they are doing a great job. Clean, speedy service. I have rarely had to wait long for my food.
Stromboli is good. Subs good. Pizza is good. Fries are fries… Generous portions. Good selection of soda and tea.

Very friendly staff. Large portions, good value and hearty Italian flavor. Only 4 stars because the broccoli and spinach inside my veggie stromboli were still cold and it wasn’t heated all the way through. I would have sent it back to the kitchen but was in a rush to go out of town to beat a snow storm and only ate half.

Never had issues with eating there. The pizza is better there than taking it home. The only topping that I get is slice sausage and sometimes mushrooms but the mushrooms are not fresh mushrooms. The salad is loaded with cheese and isn’t always as fresh as it should be with the lettuce and red onion often being wilted. The chicken Parmesan and eggplant Parmesan are good but as the other reviews have said the quality is not always consistent.