Fratelli’s Pizza NY Style

This is my second time coming here. Both times the service was a little slower than I would have liked but it seemed like they were understaffed and poor kid was trying his best to keep up. He was very polite though. The pizza is fabulous. I’m from New York so I love New York pizza and it’s not bad, not perfect but not bad. It tasted good and it’s decently priced. If you get a large you get garlic knots with it which is cool. I haven’t tried anything else on the menu yet. I’ll definite come back.

Food was okay. Cooked well and okay flavor but nothing to write home about. Service was beyond slow and it wasn’t that busy but the server was friendly. Restrooms were disgusting. We probably won’t be back.

So anyways, after a weekend trip to New York, I came home feeeeening New York pizza! I went to Little Caesars (I know I know) and LUCKILY they messed up my order so I Unilocaled this place and I ordered the half Meatlovers half Fratelli’s pizza, BBQ pizza, half lemon pepper and half Thai sweet and spicy wings, and garlic knots. I got there, got my stuff, got in the car and HOLD UP! They forgot my garlic knots. Go back in and bam! She gave me hella extra!!!
So my sons a vegetarian and I forgot to mention I also got him a slice of cheese pizza. He musta been really hungry which usually isn’t everrr or their pizza musta been reeeeaaaallllly good cuz he ate 87% of the pizza before we got home! And even said «Ummmm this pizza is good!» He’s 4 btw…
I was soooo hungry I ate sum garlic knots otw home and DAAAAAMN!!! That shit is BMB! I read a review about the wings being so big its almost scary and she ain’t neva lie about that!!! Them things are on steroids! I live in Lilburn so from Snellville to my place I ate a garlic knot, make that two, and 2 wings and I swear I was chewing on them wangs foreva! Got home parked and was still eating the damn wing.
So anyways… The meatlovers pizza was great! The bbq wasn’t wat me and my sister expected (Pizza Hut bbq pizza from 1988) but it was still good, and the Fratelli’s pizza is better than any supreme pizza I’ve ever had cuz sorry olive lovers… I hate olives! So if I didn’t have to pick them little annoying things out thats just fine and dandy Wings I could do without cuz I’m a health nut Don’t judge… Its a week before my period man GIMMIE A BREAK! But them garlic knots tho!!!
Yesterday I drove allllllll the way up there just for sum damn garlic knots!!! Now I know to ask for extra garlic but man, for $ 3.71 THATS THE BEST PIECE OF OILY GREASY GARLICKY ASS DOUGH ANYBODY COULD GET! I’ma try to not remember this place til my next period craving but damn! Thats gonna be hard…
Oh yea, I didn’t give it 5 stars cuz Why is it not the best New York pizza? Cuz of the (New York accent) Waater. I’ll still be back tho

Some of the best pizza in Gwinnett. I have tried many dishes on their menu and have not been disappointed. You don’t leave their hungary. The baked tortellini was outstanding? I highly recommend the Frutta Di Mar and the Calamari Fra Diablo.
Much more than a «pizza joint». Excellent Italian Cuisine.

Fratelli’s is a nice neighborhood Italian restaurant, you can tell its family owned. The service is always very nice.
I’m not a big fan of the pizza, it’s ok but my husband prefers it over commercial pizza restaurants.
I love the fettuccine and lemon pepper chicken, the wings are pretty big and it’s kind of scary so I only eat them every once in a while.
So when we go here it’s not just about the pizza, it’s everything else too plus the service.

This place is AWESOME! I’m from NY and this is the closest to NY pizza that I’ve tasted in the south other than Mellow Mushroom which is much more expensive.
It was a last minute party save and all the kids raved about it!

Pros: The owner was absolutely amazing! Stars just for him!
Cons:
Taste:
The food was terrible. I’m so confused as to what food everyone else was served because the pizza, wings and pasta were terrible. We ended up throwing it all out. Such a waste. Next time I’ll make the drive to Franco’s Pizza and stop being lazy.
Pasta: overlooked pasta, undercooked chewy meat and very oily.
Pizza: The dough was thick and chewy, reminiscent of play doh texture. The cheese was over the top and the sauce was bland. I like thin crispy crust with flavorful sauce. I can understand it not being exactly what I wanted, but I would have ordered Pizza Hut over this.
Oh Unilocal!You tricked me with this one!

OMG!!! I am SO SICK of Unilocal reviews from people who wouldn’t no good food if it bit them in the butt! I just spent over $ 30 on a pasta dish where the pasta was overcooked and was way too lemony!!! I would have done better going to Publix, buying a baked chicken, and preparing it myself… at least I know that I can cook!!! The garlic rolls… omg… are thick and unflavorable! The lava cake that I thought would make up for the horrible meal is a circle about the size of a disk that cost me $ 6! Thats what I get for being lazy today!!! I will never ever ever go back to this place again… did I say Ever! A waste of time and money because I threw it away!!! I HATE that I have to give it ANY stars AT ALL!

We ate here for the first time tonight, and we’ll DEFINITELY be back. The pizza is absolutely to die for. And the service is impeccable. We recently moved tot he area, and I can confidently say we’ve found our new pizza place!

I have visited here to pick up pizza several times and we keep returning. Daniel Gomez runs a good clean restaurant and makes great pizza! I believe it was voted best pizza in Gwinnett County too.

I loved my food I ordered the lobster ravioli I wanted it with a different sauce I just had a cheese craving they easily fixed that for me w/​no problems place was clean and friendly my lobster ravioli yummmm it was Delish my friend ordered hers was also a Delish meal and we both were very full and very happy we will be going back!

If you are from NY/​NJ area as I am these are the droids you are looking for. If you are not — this is how real pizza taste.

Delicious New York Style pizza! Definitely would come back when we’re in the area! Would love to try their calzones!

When you walk in and are greeted by a man with the thickest of NY accents you just know it is going to be great! We had garlic knots with cheese, a large cheese pizza and a chicken parm sub with fries.
Our friends told us we had to check this place out and I have to say it lived up to the hype! The garlic knots were gone before I could get a picture (and you know how is foodies like our pictures), there was no way to eat the pizza without folding it (amazing!), the chicken sub tasted homemade and the fries were great too!
The place was cozy and the waitress was really friendly. We will be back for sure!

Ahhhh well I think we got off on the wrong foot. I called in a carry out order and the girl who took my order was kind of short with me and at the end of the phone call said … «It will be ready in 15 minutes» and just hung up the phone. Well I am the kind of guy who likes people to be polite and say maybe «bye» or «thanks» or even «screw you». I got none of that.
I ordered the pepperoni Stromboli and the order wasn’t ready for over 20 minutes. Then it wasn’t cooked all the way through. The customer service did get a little better when I was actually in front of them.
I asked for garlic butter and they didn’t charge me for that.
I usually visit the restroom just to check cleanliness but after I paid my $ 9.00 my phone rang so I didn’t get a chance to check it out. The restaurant it self did look pretty clean.
I’m not sure that I will visit them again when there is a perfectly good mellow mushroom about 2 miles up the road.

Fratelli’s started out very good but has not been so good the last several times. The cheese slides off the crust and is quite soggy. I mentioned it to the owner one time and he said someone else made the crust and he had numerous complaints. He did give a complimentary pizza, but things never changed. I will say they have the best Greek salad I’ve ever had!

Like WOW! I ordered the Stromboli and it was ginornous! Had a small salad from the salad bar and ordered fries and got a bowl full of hot fresh fries. The atmosphere is great and the service was par-​excellence! I have found my new pizza place.

We’re originally from Pa. and this is definitely the best pizza we’ve had in Georgia. It is most like what we get when we visit up north. Today we tried the Fratelli’s Favorite: pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and garlic, Sicilian style. It was perfect! Try the Garlic Knots also, so good. We also had a Greek Salad and everything was fresh and crisp. It’s well worth the drive to get there!

Best NY slice of pizza in Atlanta (OTP). Best option in snellville area. Thin, buttery, crisp crust with fresh melted cheese over your toppings. The fresh cheese makes a difference. Too many ny style places just put the toppings on a ready baked slice. This place goes another step up.
The garlic butter bread rolls that come out are delicious. The pasta dishes are large portions.
Family owned. Delicious. Will now be my go to spot for pizza in the hwy 78 area.

Delicious! We have eaten here twice now and they have become our favorite pizza and wing place. The wings are awesome, big and delicious. The pizza was perfectly made and worth the price! You can call ahead and pick up your order or get delivery if you are in the area. The restaurant was a basic pizza place inside… I wouldn’t mind eating inside, it was nice and the woman up front was very kind. We are so happy we found this place!