Mikeys Wicked Good Pizza

So… We really like Mikey’s pizza. The crust is good, the sauce is good, they’re generous with their toppings. That’s the good…
Unfortunately, with very little exception every time we’ve ordered from them, they’ve screwed up the order. Tonight was typical — we ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a medium mushroom/​pineapple pizza with no cheese — both with regular crust. We received a large cheese pizza and the medium had their herb crust.
Taking orders accurately and filling them should be an essential part of running a restaurant. Mikey’s unfortunately doesn’t have this figured out.

The food here is pretty okay. I don’t personally like the pizza but their homemade chips are awesome when they have them. The past 2 times I’ve asked they’ve been out. There’s a woman who works there that is just the sweetest thing ever but otherwise the service is pretty sub par. I feel like I’m bothering them whrn I call to order. which is odd. Their italian subs are good, as is the pastrami. It’s worth trying!

Orderd pizza to be picked up last night. She said it would be 30 minutes and it was not a minute longer.
Pizza was very good crust was thin and crisp. Had bubbles in outer crust. Not a fan.
Had this pizza when the were in other location. Much better this time. Now i never have to go to house of pizza!!!
Pizza was very good and big for the money. Had 3 topping large for 17 bucks!

Mikey’s is one of the best pizza joints that I have ever visited. Every single thing I have ordered has been delicious and their customer service is excellent. If you have not tried their food yet, I highly recommend that you do. Trust me you will not be disappointed.

Love the sweet sauce on their pizza. It’s thin crust and always tasty. I’ve also enjoyed their Chicken BLT’s AND Homemade Potato Chips! They’ve been in SoBo about 2 years and I’m thrilled to have a place to go for lunch/​dinner that is affordable, friendly and literally know your name when you call!

My husband and I really enjoy this pizza place. The pepperoni is really big which leads to a more greasy pizza but besides that everything is really fresh and tastes homemade. The people who work there are extremely nice as well! They even stayed late to make our pizza!

Mikey’s has very good pizza! The sauce is on the sweet side and the crust seems to be homemade and is quite thin, but they make up for it by having a very large, square shaped pizza so you get more in the pizza box than you would with a regular round-​shaped pizza.
Currently on Monday-​Wednesday they have large cheese pizzas for $ 4.99 each plus tax, a FABULOUS deal for a local pizza place. Sometimes you can get a similar price on pizza, but it’s from Domino’s or Little Caesar’s– we had yet to find a local place that compared price wise… and it’s a great bonus that this little place is walking distance from our house. The pizza was not too greasy, well seasoned, and the size was more than generous.
We are pretty picky when it comes to pizza but we really enjoyed theirs, and all we got was the cheese special this time. We will be back again for sure, and try out some of their specialties. Mikey’s is definitely worth a try!

love the people, the prices and the food. the only recommendation I have is to cut up the topping (meatballs) and scatter all over, we want some in most every bite.

While i appreciate that the crust seems homemade… it was incredibly flat and burnt on both my husbands pizza and my own. I asked my husband if he ordered thin crust and he said that wasn’t a choice. I ordered two toppings… both extremely scarce. My husbands veggie seemed loaded with veggies but they were sliced very thin and just kind of wilted on top of the cheese, flavorless. We definitely won’t be going back.

We ordered here after our daughter suggested them. We had given up on good pizza in south berwick quite a while back. We ordered a barbecue chicken pizza. Loved it! Square pie, great crust, great fresh chicken! Next pie we ordered was a Hawaiian. Very fresh! Nice chunk ham and pineapple. Plus took our credit card over phone. Friendly too.

We ordered from MWP a couple of weeks back. It was okay. I liked it and my husband did not. Square pizzas, good flavor, nice crust. Worth a try.

Pizza was good, best we’ve had in the area for sure. Prices are phenomenal for what you get. My wifes Chicken Finger Sub was HUGE and the XL Pizza was square and just fit in the box. If you want square slices make sure to ask as they cut it like a normal round one and we needed to cut again.