Jersey Mike’s Subs

The employees are great here. Good is consistent, I’m here all the time. Great sandwiches and really fast service. Really clean

Had the Club Supreme and it was very good. I’ve been here before and every time the hoagies were good.
One caution for you first timers is that when they ask you if you want it Mike’s way, which is lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & OIL. They put a ton of oil on. Now I enjoy a bit of oil but my god its drenched in it. Just my opinion as to what is to much. Other than that I have no problem with their hoagie. I do like them very much.

So good. This place is fast and delicious. I usually always get the Reuben. But, I’ve also had their cheesesteak with mushrooms, jalapeños, cheese, onions etc.
The sandwiches can be pricey but it’s 100% worth it. Meat is fresh and always cut right in front of you.

My go-​to place for subs. Ignore the rest of the places and head here. Get your sub Mike’s way and enjoy.
The service is friendly and the staff is extremely quick with its work.

I’m never disappointed when I see a jersey mikes! These are like the Morton’s of sandwich shops! Today I got a #9 and cup of French onion soup. I always feel good after eating here. If your looking for a killer sandwich that actually tastes awesome this is the spot! This location in particular had a very attentive staff. Adam was awesome at helping us out. The bathrooms were clean and the dining room as well.

It is what it is in terms of the food — good in my book — but what made me take the time to write a review was that when I ordered a veggie sub, the woman making my sandwitch (she had a bunch of ear piercings) without my asking took the time to wipe down the slicer before she sliced the cheese. Bravo. It was a small touch, but as a lifelong vegetarian I really appreciated the gesture. Give these guys your business!

Girl that waited on us today was passive aggressive obnoxious. She rang us up and the register /​pinpad asks automatically if we want to tip. I find that rude too… shes not a waitress, and was obnoxious. Also, my Italian sub was ammmmmaaazzzzing as always, but hubbys cheesesteak/​hoagie roll, was far smaller than my sub. For such a high priced place, he shouldnt leave there feeling like he got ripped off in comparison to mine.

Excellent subs, but roughly twice the price of a sub from most locally owned sub shops. Not worth the price in my opinion. And unlike the local shops, most of the profits leave the local area and go to CEO’s and shareholders. I’ll keep going to Penn State Subs and others.

Yummy. If your in a hurry and want a fresh sub this is also a great choice. Fresh, made exactly as you want and fast friendly service. The only negative is I’m not fond of Pepsi products. The ice tea was good so I was pleased.

Food is good. Everything seems fresh. The place is bright and airy. The people are fast and friendly. They’re a bit pricier than their most aggressive competitor but you get a lot for your money.

So happy Jersey Mikes opened up a more convenient location then downtown. Plenty of free parking, which is a big perk. Since I grew up in NJ, this place hits home. Great subs all around. My only gripe about them is they are a bit pricey, but worth the little bit extra compared to Subway.

Was in the North Atherton area looking for a bite. Saw the new Jersey Mikes and figured why not. So glad I tried it. Got Reuben as a take out. Was very meaty and fresh. I can’t wait to take my family to try some other choices. The staff is very friendly and wait time was minimal. They shave the meats right in front of you.

It’s simple and it’s awesome. Ways it’s awesome: quality ingredients. Freshly sliced deli meats. As in, you order your sandwich, they start slicing. They bake the breads in-​house. It’s December, yet all the vegetable toppings look decent.
The staff is pleasant and efficient. In food service, well, the default is for the job to suck. If staff seems un-​miserable, the manager deserves a great deal of credit for doing something right. That appears to be the case here, at least from a customer perspective.
I chatted with the manager (owner?) for a few minutes and he seems very invested in the business and on keeping customers happy. It’s rare to feel like the manager actually cares whether you had a good lunch, but it’s really nice to see.
They haven’t been open long but I’ve already been here a few times, with a great experience each time.
The space is sizable and bright. It’s in the first floor of the Fulton Bank, and there’s a huge sign, so it’s easy to find. Do stop in for a decent sub on this end of town!

I’d give it 5 stars but I think it’s a little bit pricey. If you get the meal (drink + chips) it is $ 2.49 extra so it will be about $ 9.50 for a meal.
Otherwise, the service is good and the food is tasty and fresh. I like how the meat is cut per order. Since this location is brand new, it’s very clean and inviting. When I stopped in earlier today, all of the employees were smiling and happy to help which is refreshing.

As a native son on NJ it’s great having this taste of home here in central pa. The staff is always fast and the food is awesome. The bread is always made fresh and veggies are great. The best part? Going to a sandwich place where the meat isn’t presliced. This new place on North Atherton has plenty of space for sitting and you can order the subs ahead of time for a quick run in and grab to go.