Pi 3.14 Pizzeria

Excellent pizza here, I take my nephew after school once a week we enjoy s great slice with friendly service.

My family and I have ordered from this pizzeria many times. The food is above par, the delivery is fast, and the food is hot. The fried calzones remind me of a place in Brooklyn.

Great grandma pie and the upside down Sicilian is pretty damn close to an L&B pie from Brooklyn. The chicken parm roll was very good as well. However, I’d stay away from the deep fried stuff. We tried the deep fried calzone and it was a greasy mess. We will continue to order from here!

I just went and ordered a slice … I really don’t care about the $ 2.25 the slice was small and crust was dry… Not quite as tatty and filling maybe fill up a 5 year olds belly but not mine… not really happy I’m going to another pizzeria to get a real slice

Clean. Neat. Great service. Friendly staff. Had the vodka sauce pizza. Was delicious. Husband had the deep fried pizza, he loved his also!

We stopped here on our way home from an overnight trip to Brooklyn. Everyone there was super nice. I would definitely stop by again if I was driving through the area.

Have been going to PI Pizza for a long time. They make a delicious pizza, but you must order thin crust, well done in order to get your thin crust pie that you’re looking for. Otherwise, you’re going to get a thicker crust and you won’t be happy. Trust me. Thin crust, well
Done Will do the trick! Just look at the pictures that I’ve posted. As good as any on Staten Island except Deninos, which has a slight edge.

Best pizzeria in the neighborhood!!! The pizza is nice and thin and crispy. The staff is also very friendly and helpful, I always feel welcome!

Very nice people working here ! I love the crust on the pie crunchy ! But for me gotta admit I wish I loved the sauce and cheese, but I didn t ;(… Clean place, very nice staff … I ll try a meal one day but won t go outta my way for a slice !

After reading reviews here I was surprised when the crust on my slice was thicker than most S.I. crusts. I asked the pizza guy about it and he said it was probably just that one pie. I did appreciate that my slice was served quite hot without having to be put back in the oven. However the size and overall taste was average at best (not cheap at $ 2.25) and I could barely taste the sauce. I told the pizza guy I would come back for another try, but then I saw the B rating from the Health Dept. as I left.

When you see italians making the pizza. You know its going down. I order the Margherita pizzas and boy they were so delish! Thank God I order two slice :-). They have a seating area and one of the workers was sweet enough to throw away my plate for me. The owner is there and you can really tell that he cares about his customers. If you around this area, make sure to stop by!

Not a big fan of their pizza. Living on staten island, I was raised on great thin crust pizza. While the flavors of the sauce are not bad, the crust is overwhelmingly crunchy, making it taste more like sauce on a matzah than an actual pizza.
On the bright side, whenever I go in Pi I am greeted by the smiling faces of two superstar counter girls, one blonde and the other Indian. If not for the fantastic service I fear my rating may have been a lot more harsh.

Jes stopped by for a margherita slice… This is prolly the best slice i have had… Thin crust with a nice crisp not too crunchy but a nice balance between soft n crisp… Sauce has a slight sweet taste great balance between cheese and sauce… I highly recommend to stop by … Plus they have deep friend calzones! Will definitely be ordering from here from now on

Phenomenal! The best pizza around, once we tried Pi Pizza we stopped ordering from anywhere else! The Pepperoni Roll is to die for and the Nutella pizza is just delicious!!!

Pizzas are to die for one of the best in the island to be honest. I would recommended you to get the deep fried garlic nut.

Very good pizza although one time the cheese was too salty. I’ve done take out and delivery. Their prices can’t be beat. Will continue ordering again

Pizza was terrible. I love near this place and Ordered a large pie for delivery one night. The pizza took more than a hour to arrive and when it finally came, it was cold and undercooked. The sauce tasted like it came from a jar and cheese taste like Polly-​o. Crust was undercooked. Will never eat this pizza again!

The pizza is thin and crisp, the sauce is sweet and the cheese is nicely distributed. An overall delicious pizza.
HOWEVER
When I placed an order for delivery to my office building the pizza took forever to get there. An hour after placing the order I called to ask what was up: they said the ‘pi’ had just left. Another 15 minutes later the receptionist gets a call from the delivery guy for someone to COME DOWN TO THE GROUND FLOOR. The building I work in has a parking lot with security and there’s an elevator which is not at all that complicated to use. Eventually the guy came up and when I signed for the pizza he gave me the excuse «oh it’s company policy to not leave the car. The only reason I did it was because there was no food left. We’ve had stuff stolen in the past. Sorry, company policy.»
This is the only place which delivers to us that’s given us an issue about coming up to hand us the food (which was cold). If you’ve had stuff stolen from the vehicle that you deliver food from in the past, maybe you should be locking the door? If this is truly their company policy then I’m afraid my office will not be ordering from there again.

Their large Pi are nicely priced not expensive like most pizzerias. I had them twice. Overall taste is well. Crust very thin. Only a fan of that when I want that to order. I usually like my medium thick crust. Overall taste good.
I placed order they don’t use that pizza warmer thing so when I received the Pi it was a bit cold. That sucked.

Small pizzeria right on the corner of Jewett Avenue & Victory.
Really nice workers.
Great margarita slices, thin and crunchy.
Slice, garlic knots and a can of soda can cost you $ 6.00
Nutella pizza which anything Nutella is delish but I have not tried it
Deep fried pizza which also sounds really good and heard great recommendations to try.
Delivery & you also can eat inside but its small.
Marinara sauce needs to be much thicker I love thicker sauce much better flavor!