Palumbo’s Pizza

I eat here a lot ! Talk about delicious food! From pizza to baked ziti, chicken parm, calzone. Yum top notch. I hate to say this but I agree the owners need courteous counseling lol. Everyone else is so nice ! Love these guys !!

Great Mom and Pop Italian-​run Pizza and Beer joint, that looks like time passed it by… and guess what? They make solid pizza.
The traditional/​Neapolitan slices are thin and crisp, and the Sicilian are thick and airy. Good quality sauce and cheese, as well. My only complaint (and it’s nitpicking) is that the traditional crust isn’t ‘chewy’ like the very best places in NY/​NJ have mastered.
One thing I really like is that the prices for all the many specialty pizzas are reasonable, and also clearly on display in front of each pie under glass.
There’s nothing worse than buying a Coke and a couple of topping-​laden slices and then finding out it’s $ 9 bucks! Not here!
They also do rice balls and calzones, etc. Truly an old school, hidden gem of the area.

Tomato basil pizza is delicious! I don’t know what the cheese blend was but I’ve never had anything like it. I should have asked!
Service was quick.
Would definitely go back.

The owner of this restaurant very rude to my wife and I, after we finished our dinner, we got up to leave, the owner commanded us to bring our plates up to the counter, he yelled at us in front of the whole restaurant, I think if the owner ever smiled, his face would crack, as a repeat customer, this is our last visit, I don’t think this nasty a hole gives a sh! t.

Love this place. Great pizza. Great staff.

Although a bit out of the way and not on a major strip, this little place has good business. They do have one of the best pizzas in the Poconos and if you’re from New York, then you’ll be surprised.
If you’re a party of 3, I highly recommend ordering the large pie and pitcher. It’s a Great Deal! You’ll definitely want to have minimum of 2 slices.
I love the fact that the crust is thin and crunchy. It’s especially good when it first comes out of the oven. Just be careful with burning your mouth.
They also sell cold beer to go and there’s constantly someone at the counter buying.
So, overall, if you’re looking for great pizza, this is the place for it.

Absolutely the best pizza place in the area.

We love the cheesesteak stuffed pizza and hot wings. As good as it get.

Second best pizza place in the stroudsburg area next to Tony’s. I go here all the time. The one on 611 delivers and is a lot nicer than the on in east stroudsburg but both have awesome pizza/​everything!

I am gonna take a risk and tell y’all about THE BEST pizza in the Poconos.
There are many pizza options thanks to all our NYC imports but Palumbo’s does it best. Don’t be scared off by the clientele or the diverse selection of 40s — this pizza rocks. The crust is thin with a crispy bottom and doughy top. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio and the sauce is homemade daily — a little sweet a little savory and all around tasty.
If you are a cheese-​a-​holic like I am go for the Large Double Cheese — it’s EPIC!

Been a Stroudsburg resident since 1994, and the first place we ever got Pizza was Polumbo’s.
It was fresh, thin and perfect. Pizza is not that expensive, and still
14 years later, the BEST pizza around town.