I can’t believe this place is rated so high on here. We went for fish fry. The food was terrible and it was over priced.
Thomas P.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Madison, WI
Went to brunch. The food is good(buffet). My only suggestion is that the two men working th he buffet and bar need to stop wandering around, standing in the customer’s way, and try being less awkward.
Ann B.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Madison, WI
Went for dinner without the kids nice adult night out started out with a couple of well made cocktails menu classic supper club fare which is fine with us unfortunately they were out of the porterhouse hubby settled for seafood combo shrimp scallops & lobster tail I went with the filet both of us enjoyed are entrees meal started with a excellent salad bar which included soup some pasta salads didn’t try it but they had spinach with hot bacon & vinegar dressing which I hadn’t seen in awhile had a excellent raspberry torte for we will be back bottom line good solid food and drinks excellent service priced about what I expected 90 with tip
Debbie B.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Madison, WI
We have now become regulars mostly Saturday night, but did Friday last week. We are from northern WI and are used to lightly breaded non-greasy fish. However, the baked fish and crusted fish is great. Prime rib awesome, filet steak is always tender and done to perfection, scallops and shrimp very good. Salad bar is good but was better with spread cheese, liver pâté and stick crackers, as well as the additional variety of salads available all nights, not just on Friday. Please bring them back. French onion soup is fantastic!!! Love the bar area, great drinks and bartenders, especially Kevin. ***** if salad bar improved.
Tony M.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Sun Prairie, WI
Sunday brunch was excellent, food was good, good service up to the point of paying for our meal. We used a coupon for $ 15 off a $ 30 purchase that our server, Cindy, honored for $ 13.95 and proceeded to argue over honoring for the actual $ 15… Granted it was only $ 1 but the scene she created and the sarcasric, rude remarks she made make it impossible for me to come back or recommend eating here to others. The manager did correct the situation eventually but the damage was done.
Norm M.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Spring Green, WI
This was our first time here and it was excellent! The pork chop was done just right the potatoes and asparagus were also very good. the Mahi Mahi and salmon was done perfectly. The salad bar was very fresh and well maintained everything was tidy. Will definitely return Norm M.
Julie G.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Madison, WI
This was our first visit and we’d go again. We went Monday for the ½ sandwiches but ended up trying the Bistro steak and the shaved prime rib open sandwich. The salad bar was well stocked with good variety. Fabulous Manhatten clam chowder. Steak was tender & tasty. Prime rib on texas toast with mashed tatoes was yummy. We split a huge dessert and still took some home. Nice quiet ambiance with oldies music playing softly. The bar is separate and had Monday night football on. See you again soon!
Andi S.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Sun Prairie, WI
This was our first visit but definitely not our last! We had a wonderful experience! We wanted to take my husband’s mom out for her birthday. We looked into the reviews for Watertower and decided to «take a chance«. Great decision. Between the 6 of us we had the scallops, crab cakes, calamari, lamb, prime rib, beef tips and lobster ravioli! I highly recommend this place and can’t wait to go back!
Brian J.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Sun Prairie, WI
Visited the Water tower chop House recently on a Friday night, the fish was good, customers and wait staff were friendly, they made a tasty old fashioned but I liked the well equipped salad bar the best! Located in downtown Sun prairie on main street with parking in back
Thomas C.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Madison, WI
This is one of those times I wish I could give a half star to the rating, because this place is not a full 5, but better than a 4. Food, good, really good. Décor, classic and feels like home. Staff, busy, friendly and willing to make sure you had a perfect meal. The only reason I wont give a full 5 stars is simply for the reason they need more staff. The waitress we had was running all over the place and had way to many table to deal with. There was only one other person in the room working with her, and she even seemed over whelmed. So getting service right away did take a little while. But when you did get service, it felt like you were the only table she had to deal with for the rest of the night. Super friendly staff from start to finish. The Friday night fish fry is a classic Wisconsin fish fry; big pieces perfectly fried and lots of sides to pick from. There is a good German influence here with the different items you can get. The potato pancakes are killer, and the bacon dressing is good; not an Amish style dressing that I am use to, but more closer to a German potato salad dressing with that good vinegar bite to it. This is a classic Wisconsin Supper Club venue and one that I am SO coming back to.
Ginger S.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Stoughton, WI
First time visiting a few weeks ago. It’s your typical Mom & Pop supper club with a fabulous salad bar. The service was good and the fish on Friday was outstanding! The interior’s a bit dark and dated, but don’t let the looks fool you The food is pretty good, and presents a good value for the $$$. We’ll definitely go back again.
DM H.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Madison, WI
New York Strip was only $ 24.00 and was awesome plus nice selection of sides. Lovely salad bar is worth the extra $ 5, especially since it includes a soup. Pass on the fried shrimp next time. Be sure to have a Grasshopper… Super yummy!
Mama M.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Sun Prairie, WI
This is our 3rd visit to this restaurant. Service was great, cocktails spot-on, but everything was so salty. Calamari, French onion soup, and scallops. Server was great about taking the soup off my bill. I’d go back for the cocktails and the salad bar – leave the kids at home.
Amber V.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Fall River, WI
The first impression when we walked in the door was not good. For lack of better words the hostess was dressed very slutty. Super high heels and a dress that barley covered her butt. Not the imagine I’d want for a restaurant like this. Also, not very smart. We brought 3 small children in with us and she asked if we needed kids menus. Umm… Yeah? Duh! So onto the waitress. Very nice. Not super exceptional service but she was efficient and earned her tip. As for the food. The salad bar was good. Slightly better than an average salad bar in a restaurant. We ordered calamari as an appetizer and was disappointed. Very bland and no flavor in the breading. And where is the lemon that I’ve always had come with any calamari I’ve ordered? I ordered the chicken and spinach manicotti. It was good. Not exceptional but good. My fiancé ordered a Bloody Mary(not the greatest) and the whisky bourbon pork chop(no complaints) and I also tried a little piece of my kids Mac and cheese pizza and it was good. The prices are a little high so unless someone else suggests coming here I don’t think I’ll be back.
Tom R.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Milwaukee, WI
Went for the Friday fish and really enjoyed this place. The salad bar was exceptional, the clam chowder had a tremendous flavor though it should have used a few more clams. The fish fry was ok. The perch has a panko crust but it lacked something. It just didn’t have a lot of flavor like something was missing. The potato pancakes were tasty. I know perch is expensive but 18 $ for a perch fry is a lot though you do get the salad bar and soup. Overall it seems like a nice place to move into the space that herremans occupied.
Alessandra G.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Madison, WI
The restaurant was a pleasant surprise. We went for Friday fish fry and I ordered the perch, my husband the cod. The lake perch was something out of this world! Extremely crunchy and delicious, not dropping in oil and full of flavor. I love the concept of the salad bar as you can put together your own salad included with your meal if you want. Their clam chowder is amazingly good, very fresh and not sure thick. By far this is my top restaurant for fish fry in the madison/sun prairie area.
Onotse I.
Évaluation du lieu : 3 Madison, WI
Watertower is an old school Supper Club. I was told that there were a few other places in here that didn’t do as well before this place finally ended up here. It doesn’t seem like this place has done much to update the look on the inside because it looks a little dated. That’s fine though because it adds to the charm of the location. The inside appears to be sectioned off into a few different rooms. There is a bar in the front with very friendly bartenders. I ordered a vodka gimlet and was pleasantly surprised at how good it was. Our server honestly seemed a bit off that night. She was pleasant enough but just seemed a little odd. As it was Friday, I ordered the fish fry with the salad bar. The salad bar was much better than your run of the mill salad bar. It was very fresh with lots of different options. Our food took a while to arrive so that was a bit dissappointing. When our meal arrived, the presentation was good but there just seemed to be something a bit off about it. The meal seemed to be lacking in flavor. If it just had just a bit more flavor it would have been very good. Though I did not really enjoy my meal, I am really looking forward to trying a few other dishes here. The prime rib is supposed to be really good and it may be a place to come for a drink.
Tamara C.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Sun Prairie, WI
The Prime Rib was sold out before I could try it. I did get the filet mignon lobster oscar. I got it with the asparagus as my vegetable and mashed potato and salad bar. the salad bar was very hearty. The Filet was decent and I’d like to go back to try the Prime Rib. the waitstaff really was good to me.
Sarah Z.
Évaluation du lieu : 4 Madison, WI
I’m always excited to hear that a new restaurant opened up in Sun Prairie, so the opening of Watertower Chop House made me happy! My husband and I tried out Watertower on a Wednesday night. They have a «date night» special on Wednesdays with a deal on appetizers, so we were excited to try it. We were served crunchy bread and cheese spread when we sat down, real supper club-style! We each ordered an entrée(prime rib for my husband and salmon for me), so we both got salad bar included with our meals. We were both pretty impressed with the salad bar. Our meals were also very good. We’re planning to come back to Watertower Chop House for sure!
Mytoan N.
Évaluation du lieu : 5 Seattle, WA
This business has recently done a «soft opening» as of last week. Since I live down the street from them, I’m familiar with the ebb and flow of Main Street Sun Prairie restaurants opening up, staying open for a little bit, and closing, as demonstrated by the previous ownership of this restaurant space(see this article: ). It’s a Supper Club with a soup and salad bar, main entrees, and dessert. It’s a table cloth, low mood lighting with candle light, and multiple utensils on hand kind of place. Everyone in my party of four ordered the Thursday special of the day, the slow cooked BBQ ribs. It came with multiple options for a side, I chose the sweet potato french fries, my companions chose the potato pancakes or the mash. Everything including the salad bar was divine. The turtle cheesecake was HEAVENLY. And on top of that, they know about professional wait staff service. The test of a great Supper Club will be consistency. It remains to be seen how this quality will continue, but we can certainly be optimistic about the possibility.