Lucky’s Pizza

True NY pizza. So good. We were just visiting AZ, and I have been wanting this pizza again ever since we left. Open a store in orange county, CA! We have nothing that ever comes close to this pizza. Mmm…

for dinner really not that great to be honest. the pizza at tailgater’s was so much better.
for the most part I would pass on coming here again. had 2 pieces out of a large took the rest and gave to a homeless panhandlers.
pizza was bland, greasy, and doughy.
I forgot one of the first rules of trying somewhere new check out the bathroom when you first walk in, if it’s not clean time to leave. needless to say the bathroom was like a truck stop.

My wife and I eat here every couple of weeks. They make a good pizza and we enjoy the lasagna dinner. Nice family run place. A really good value.

Good NYC pizza. Tons of cheese and meat with great flavor. A little pricy, but worth every penny.

The best Pizza in town! Great people! Family owned restaurant. I have come to this place for years and never had bad experience everrrr!! If you want to try the New York style pizza in AZ!, this is the place to test!

The food is amazing! The pizza crust is perfect and the wings are to die for. Oh, and they serve Coke! HaHa!

Never had a bad experience at Lucky’s for the 5 years we have been going there, as a native NY’er we love it there!
But today’s pizza was a shocker when I got home and opened the box… Shame on me for not checking it before leaving. Guess they ran out of medium size pies boxes?
By the time I got home, two kids… Wasn’t going to call or go back to get a replacement because simply didn’t have the time to drive 25 minutes back and forth!

If there was a Button for 0 stars that’s what I would rate them I made a Unilocal account just for this that’s how bad of an experience I had.
While I was there I noticed a worker in the back picking his nose and eating and serving food
Once I saw that I immediately walked out and notified all the customers inside how unsanitary and disgusting it was
I’m surprised the health department lets them stay in business this is the worst thing I have ever seen and to be in a family owned restaurant it should be a shame
Sorry Lucky’s next time I’m craving boogers on my pizza I’ll make sure to stop by again other than that you guys are better off going to us Pizza or Ray Pizza down the street

Love this place. 2 slices and a coke for lunch great deal. It’s my style pizza. Have been there many times and will be back. Family operated this place is the real deal.

I just tried this place based on the reviews and rating. They were right, this place was delicious had pizza and wings. Highly recommend

Family owned, been going here for the last 10 plus years. Great staff and food! My wife hates onions so we don’t get that! This is great pizza! I love to go up there because they have the coldest beer in Surprise. It turns into an ice beer slushy as you drink it!

Called in a large Lucky’s Meat Lover’s Pizza and 25 medium wings for pick-​up on a Friday night at 6:30pm. Was ready in 20 minutes, hot and fresh. Generous amounts of toppings on the pizza as described on the menu and the wings were served with a twangy buffalo sauce and tasty ranch dressing. Everything was delicious at a very reasonable price. Lucky’s is our new to-​go pizza place from now on!

Good pizza. I wouldn’t say it is anything too special, but for $ 4.50 for the two piece lunch special, the value is definitely there. Service was fast and adequate, and the food was hot and fresh.
As a side note, they do make calzones and sandwiches, so there are options available.

If I could give them 0 stars I would, I ordered two pepperoni pizzas, the crust taste like cardboard, the sauce is flavorless, it was very very greasy, and on top of all that it was over priced. I would not come back.

Family owned very friendly service, love the fact that you can watch your pizza made right in front of you, ice cold beer with many choices on tap, the wings are awesome!!! I will definitely be back!

The pizza was really good! It was thin and the cheese along with the other ingredients were delicious. The slices are quite large and you will definitely have left overs. It was very satisfying

I thought the pizza was pretty good, nothing mind blowing. We loved their pizza deal: 1 large pizza & 20 wings for $ 20 (if I remember correctly). I actually really liked their wings & I’m not a big wing person. And their lunch special looked pretty cheap.
My favorite by far though was the cannoli. It’s the only dessert they have, and it’s the best cannoli I’ve had. Super crunchy and fresh & sprinkled with cinnamon, you can’t go wrong with the cannoli.

Lucky’s Pizza, Reems & Bell rd., Surprise AZ
I’ve passed this restaurant many times and wanted to give it a try. I finally decided to try it since the reviews sounded good. I went in and placed a carry out order for a med pizza, large Italian salad, and an order of wings.
The staff, two gentle men who were working there were kind and helpful in answering my questions and placing my order. I don’t think I was there more than 20 mins for my order to be ready.
Everything was nicely packaged and delicious. Being of Italian decent from Chicago, I was surprised to find the pizza crust to be thin typical of pizza in the Chicago land area. The sauce and topping was great as well as the crust. The salad was plenty and fed three adults. It was made with fresh crispy lettuce, olives, and plenty of fresh tomatoes and peppers.
The wings were delicious and complimented the meal nicely.
I have no complaints and list it as a good experience. I would easily recommend it to anyone and will be returning.

I had a strong pizza craving and I didn’t feel like driving too far. My buddy Kate M. had written a review about Lucky’s Pizza awhile back and I noticed they were close (still not sure if they are owned by the same folks or not) by so I decided to give them a try. I called up and placed my order for a Large Cheese Pizza. They don’t ask for your name or phone number, instead they give you a number and tell you how long it will be. I was told I was #7 and that it would be 15 minutes. I drove on down, walked inside, paid the lady my money and took my pizza to go. Friendly folks working there. Now onto the pizza…
Large Cheese Pizza ($ 12.95) — This thing was nice and big. The first thing I noticed was that it had a ton of cheese on it. It also had a little «sheen» to it. That can be bad sometimes if the pizza is too greasy. This was not the case here. No drips of grease anywhere to be found. I picked up my first slice and noticed that it was just a tad droopy. I bit in though and was pleasantly Surprise (d) Arizona… bwahahaha… The taste was great. Good cheese, good sauce, decent crust. Next time I come back, I will ask them to cook it well done. If the cheese had a little brown on it and the crust had just a tad bit of a «crisp», this pizza would have been fantastic! It was good as is, but could be taken to another level with an extra few minutes in the oven. This pizza is one of those types that does get better the more you eat though. First slice I liked, second slice I ate faster, third slice I started to pick up little subtleties that convinced me it was a pretty darn good pizza. Is it comparable to my favorite, Grimaldis? Nope. Is it way better than any chain type place? Yep! Will I come back because its a good value, its a local business, it tasted pretty good and its close to my house? Definitely! They have multiple specials going on at all times plus they have sandwiches, wings and appetizers. They make a Sicilian type pizza too that I definitely want to try out. They have a decent sized eat in area too. I’m sure Ill be back in due time.

We’ve passed by many times and have wanted to try. Being from the East Coast, I’m really picky with my pizza.
Walked in, grabbed a menu and immediately saw a delicious looking pizza. I asked what the pizza was in the photo and the girl behind the counter looked at it puzzled, then she looked at the 2 guys working with her, pointed to the picture asking them what the pizza was. Both of the guys laughed and said «It’s just a picture». So I wanted clarification, and asked them if that photo was of their pizza or not. This time the girl laughed and said «No, it’s just a picture».
Really? What self-​respecting pizza joint uses a stock photo of another pizza for their pizza? And let’s say in some alternative universe they do use another pizza picture… at least be prepared for the question! Lie to me… say it’s a specialty pizza. Say anything! But to say «It’s just a picture» is just ridiculous.
We ordered a large specialty Sicilian pizza. It was PACKED with a ton of toppings. When I lifted the box off the counter, it felt like it weighed 5 pounds. It was at least 1 ½″ high… impressive! Taste… the toppings were delicious and so was the crust. The sauce was very good, not perfect, but very good. Overall, the pizza was fantastic.
It sucks to not be able to give them 5 stars. Honestly, the «It’s just a picture» combined with the laughing should deduct 2 stars. But I’ll be nice and chalk it up to imbecillic behavior
So yeah, 5 stars minus 1 for the foolishness. I’d visit again. I just won’t point to any photos on the menu.