NYPD Pizza

The vegan pizza! Yes, vegan. NYPD does a solid for vegans and the lactose intolerant. Couldn’t get enough. The large is enough to feed my husband and I for 2 days. The whole experience is customizable. My personal favorite is sautéed zucchini, mushroom, garlic, basil, & olives. Delivery took about 55 minutes on a Friday night. Delivery guy was so polite. The pizza was piping hot and delicious.

Great pizza ordered the night of Cards game and they delivers on time. Pizza was good and hot and we ate the whole thing. Great service from order to delivery.

This was my favorite for 2 years. If you have it delivered make sure to order extra crispy. It’s a toss up between NYPD and Rays.

Pizza was thin, soggy and lacking in flavor. We arrived on a busy Friday night, so understandably service was lacking. Pizza was pricey and lacking leaving me feeling like it was money and time ill spent. I have been to this location several years ago and remembered it to be far better than what this experience was.

Waited on quickly and friendly. Greatly improved. The music playing I could do without.

Great white pizza! Try it with the balsamic reduction its to die for! The crust is amazing. Hubby had the chicken parm and for not being hungry he devoured his plate. We will be back that’s for sure. Service was fast and friendly

Great pizza-​calzones-​salads are AMAZING! Friendly !!
Beer and Wine!
Good lunch specials!
Had one issue with delivery one time and the manager fixed the problem immediately!
Kid friendly!

Better than pizza hut, but not real deal NY pizza. Crust was undercooked, had to knife and fork it, couldn’t do the true NY fold or the slice would have fallen apart.

Great pizza and service garlic knots were delicious and beer was cold they also have vegan options which is huge

My husband and I come here a few times a month. He comes for the pizza, I come for the salads. We have always received awesome service and the waitstaff have always been really friendly and upbeat. We get our food pretty quickly and my husband gets pizza be actually enjoys eating. Right now they have the harvest salad and it’s amazing!

Love their pizza, it’s def the NY flavor that I remember and it’s because of their NY filtered water ;-)

We went in to NYPD pizza for lunch since I always hear the commercials on KTAR. The lunch time posted on the menu board was not accurate and have been changed. Not really a big deal but the server was very rude about this and just provided terrible overall service for the rest of lunch. She got our drinks and then sat down with other employees at a table as they ate lunch and talked about inappropriate things within our earshot. She would get up from time to time to check on us and then go back to doing whatever she was doing with her coworkers as if we didn’t really exist. Although I did enjoy the pizza particularly the Wall Street and the bread knots were good. I’m not going to spend my money in a place that does not treat me well. I am not snobish and expect to be treated like a king or something just treat me like a human being.

1^st time here and it was a very nice experience, from the moment you walk in you feel welcome. Courtney M, and Trey made our day! Pizza was amazing and the NYPD ale was super!

We’ve lived in Surprise about a year and a half and have always heard of NYPD Pizza but hadn’t gotten around to trying. It was SO GOOD! The pizza’s are really large which is nice cause the whole family can share which makes eating here easy on the budget for a family. We got the mozzarella and a medium pizza, my husband, me and our two girls were able to share it all and still take some home. We will definitely be trying this place again in the future!

Great food, friendly staff. The pizza is as good as Grimaldis and the prices are better. Love the chopped salad and the tropical tea as well.

I live in California and I was in Arizona for a wedding. The next day after the wedding, the bride and groom’s family had a BBQ. I’m vegetarian so I wasn’t able to really eat anything they had cooked and I was starving. I was in the mood for pizza that day but I normally go to the same pizza place since I am really picky with my pizza flavor and texture. Well, first of all, thank you NYPD for being vegetarian friendly and having healthier options. Second of all, the pizza was really good and had great flavor. I would definitely drive out to Arizona for some NYPD pizza. Well, I mean, If i drive out towards the area, I will stop. Last but not least, our waiter was really really nice. He conversated with us and made sure we were taken care of.

I would have given this location 2 stars bit I love the restaurant. My friend and I normally eat at the one in 7^th Avenue but we’re near this one.
The pizza was good but my antipasto salad was so soaked with olive oil it was so gross. No balsamic in it just spices. It ruined the best part of the meal which I was looking forward to. When I brought it to our waitresses atten ton, showing her the half of a cup of oil in my salad all she could do was say. …“uhhhhhh“
I just went back to my both. Obviously she had not complaint to the manager. Very disappointed.

I will not come back to this location. My antipasti salad was so disgusting and the staff did not seem to care. This Location needs to work on that. I did have that awesome salad in the downtown location.

This is our first time at this location in Surprise. We were initially seated outside and asked for the heater to be turned on but were told that they ran out of gas. So we waited for a table to open in the dining room and moved.
My family loves pizza and wings so I tagged along and hoped to find something I could make Paleo compliant. I am Paleo because of auto immune disease, not to be difficult.
I struggled here. There are salads and that was my option, but a grilled chicken breast, instead of breaded, would have been great to add to it. So I will leave hungry.
But my husband really enjoys his calzone and mentioned that the cheese is just the perfect balance of salty and sweet. The crust was crisp and hit the spot.
The garlic knots were fun as an appetizer for the kids. They weren’t thrilled with wings and packed them to bring home.
So in our estimation, they are better than Streets of New York and Grimaldis, worse than Native New Yorker, and nowhere near the level of Barros. And for pasta, salad, and calzone, Babbo’s pours a lot more care into their food.

This is like 2 stars for the price and food but the lady on the phone and the ladies at the pickup counter/​front door were extremely nice, friendly and courteous (held the door open for me which I appreciated) so they get an extra star themselves. I always appreciate and enjoy good service!
I had a long drive home from CA and didn’t feel like making anything. I was craving some pizza and wanted to try something kind of close to home. I placed my order for pickup and drove on down. I ordered a Large Cheese Pizza. Price was a bit steep…$ 19.15 after tax and that is just plain cheese… if you got some toppings, it would easily be a $ 25.00+ pizza. Um… I’ll pass!
The pizza was flavorful… good sauce, good cheese but the dough/​crust was kind of whack. The bottom of the pizza was not crispy or browned at all. It was super white and doughy which wasn’t that good. The actual crust was ok. It had a decent chew/​texture to it. Probably could have been cooked a bit longer overall though as far as the bottom. The pizza is pretty large and I only ate 2 slices for dinner and was full… plenty of leftovers. For $ 19.00 though, I will probably pass going forward. It definitely wasn’t nasty, but the under cooked/​soft bottom of the pizza and the steep price tag left me wanting more. The only time I see myself coming back is when they have deals or coupons or something… even then, I would rather drive to some of my other favorite spots than come back here when I am craving a pizza.