New York J & P Pizza

Food was pretty good but they were out of several items on the menu.

An embarrassing representation of Italian food. Ordered Lasangna with a Caesar salad. As Italian as it gets, right.
First the salad comes out at the same time as the Lasangna. Annoying, but fine. Of course it is a Caesar salad, so my expectation is a premixed romaine with parm, and maybe anchovies. What did I get? Romaine, got that part right. With mushrooms? And a cup of dressing with a lid pulled out of the fridge. And some tiny out of a box croutons. Why is an Italian restaurant not making their own croutons? It’s unbelievably easy to do. After I pull off (most) of the mushrooms I mix the salad. Only to find the dressing is oily and bland. Awesome.
My daughter got pizza, that I noticed was undercooked after a while. Hoping she doesn’t have a stomach ache later. Bland frozen fries, but they did manage to not screw up my son’s grilled cheese.
As for my lasagna. It was served in a boat with garlic bread on the side. It was just bland and over cooked. Meat looked like it was pulled from a Taco Bell taco, but with less flavor. The garlic bread looked to be teaming with seasoning, and looked promising. Then I tasted it. Surprisingly bland, wow. How’d that happen? Whatever, even if the garlic bread was amazing it wouldn’t be enough to get me back in the door.
I wish Frank’s Pizza would buy this location. That would be amazing.

A nice casual full service dining place with much more than pizza. Their seafood pasta dishes are excellent. Our teen age kids liked the pizza. Overall we found it to be good food and reasonably priced with daily specials on appetizers during happy hour. They have a new bar area with big TVs. Staff is friendly as well. We will definitely be back.

I love a good Italian Cold Cut sub. And while I appreciate the authentic cured meats, I can even get over some minor substitutions… IF the meats are a good quality. I don’t know why but if I’m at all suspicious of deli meat, I might as well toss out my sandwich… I’ll never be able to enjoy it.
All that said… I LOVE the Italian Cold Cut sandwiches here! They hold up pretty well as a to-​go item too, so I regularly grab one (or have my wife pick me one up) on my way home.

Good people! I don’t eat a lot of pizza, but they donated 6 XL pizzas to a charity event i held once! Thanks again guys! Supporting philanthropic businesses is a good choice for anyone!

Even though I haven’t been here yet, I think it’s fabulous that they sent us a «Welcome to the Neighborhood» $ 15 Gift Certificate. I will be sure to grab a pizza this weekend! Thanks. Also, on their website, they have a coupon of the month. Can’t wait to try