Pie-Eyed Petey’s

Closed over a year ago
The one at tippy lake is still open

update 6/​19/​2013*** now appears to be closed***
Friday nite — not overly busy. Live music. Party of 4 on bar side.
Service and drinks were good. Bar food was maybe a bit above average. (Pizza)
Menu prices seem approaching absurd on sandwiches.
Live band — much much too loud and not much good. 2 of us rated a 2 star, 2 of us rated a 4 star. (I left w/​a pounding head ache — would have had even if seated in family dining area)
Choice between this one and one on Tippy — go to Tippy if weather is nice. Seems a bit pricey there as well though.

I’m thankful they made this place smoke free (the one on Tippy Lake is still allowing smoking and no kids). I miss visiting the other location on the lake, but I don’t miss the smoke. We enjoy their pie-​eyed pie (their unique take on deep dish pizza) and their non so healthy appetizers like cheesy pretzel bites and fried green beans. A this location, we love getting a bit to eat and a drink and then walk over to the local theater to watch a movie.
***Update June 2013. They Syracuse, IN (smoke free) Pie-​Eyed Petey’s is now closed. Not sure why. But it appears to have closed just before Memorial Day weekend this year. The restaurant on Tippy is still open, but to my knowledge is still allowing smoking but no kids. We very rarely eat there any more, but may to pizza takeout on occasion.