Anthony’s New York Style Pizza

Had the Stromboli and Calzone they were delicious! We’re always satisfied with their food. If we’re out and can’t decide what we want to eat, we end up there! My favorite place to eat!

The never ending New York style pizza debate! Well let me start from the beginning… I placed my delivery order via phone. The woman that took the order had a southern accent and seemed to be pretty busy. HOWEVER, she was super friendly and very pleasant.
Reading previous reviews and due to the fact that is was lunch time, I was concerned my order wouldn’t arrive for a while. I was wrong. 35 minutes the nicest New Yorker ever was at my door with the pie. This guy is my favorite! He was very genuine and made me feel as though he’s been delivering to me forever.
Now the pizza itself… i was pretty satisfied! Growing up in the city I ate pizza almost daily and miss the authentic NY taste. Anthony’s hits pretty close to home (the cheese pizza could use a tad of seasoning but still tasty). The wings are probably the best wings I’ve had in a while. Food was great, customer service was phenomenal, I’ll definitely order again!

Yuck. Tried Anthony’s via delivery the other night and simply put, what we had was gross. The garlic bread was dried out, crunchy and burnt tasting. The pizza — I forget which we had, I’m having a brain fart (it started with a T) but it was mainly just a flavorless pile of cheeses & white cream/​sauce. Oh, and I spent the rest of the night in the john.

White Pizza is awesome, have had few times now, consistently good. We have tried couple other pies as well, they were quite good.

I order a pizza garlic bread and salad last night at 630! i get the pizza at 920!!! I called at 8 they said it already left.3 hours later I got a COLD pizza NOOO salad 2 starving kids… Linda was the lady the driver called to see what they could do about my bill… She said she GUESSES she will take the salad off I NEVER GOT… what???Never again will I go here. On top of that my coupon was 15.99 for all that but somehow my bill was 24.99!!!’
Rip off

Delicious pizza! We tried the bruschetta pizza, which was very good. The crust is also excellent, soft but not too thick. The garlic knots are also tasty, they are not shy with the garlic!

Have ordered pizza from here a few times and liked the sauce to pie ratio. Thin crust is what I grew up on so that’s always a plus. The pizza is better than most of the other places in the area.
Have also had the calzones. They are huge and can be shared and still have plenty of leftovers.
Only thing that has me scratching my head is, how does a restaurant, let alone a pizza place not have hours on a Friday?
Seems my pizza cravings more often than not seem to happen on Fridays. Can only imagine how much business they lose by choosing to be closed on a Friday.

Extremely tasty and very friendly service. They have a lot of loyal customers because it feels like your neighborhood pizza joint.

Was looking for real NY style pizza and I think I’ve found it. The crust was crispy and thin. Great flavor but I would of liked to taste more sauce on my pizza. Hands down one of the best cannoli I’ve had in a long time. The owners where super nice. We will definitely be back. I do wish you could have a cold beer there with your meal. This might become a Friday night thing for us.

All New Yorkers who read the «New York Style» sign will squint. We’ve played this game before with chinese food, hot dogs, bagels and of course pizza. Most of the time we walk away disappointed and betrayed.
The «New York Style» is a lot to live up to because New Yorkers are really spoiled with cheap, delicious food. We have a lot of strong memories tied to food and we know what tastes like home.
Anthony’s pizza tastes like home. It was nostalgic to eat a New York pizza again. Not the best from home, but New York has a large range of pizza quality. Regardless, Anthony’s pizza is what you can expect from a pizzeria in a corner of New York.
Another great thing is they tossed the pizza in front of me and made it fresh. Anthony is representing and I’m sure a lot of ex-​New Yorkers are grateful. I, for one, will now be ordering from Anthony’s instead of the nearby pizza chains.
Be warned New York Style pizzas have a very thin crust, a layer of oil, and Anthony’s serves it fresh and hot. Don’t burn your leg or your tongue when you dive in.

Ordered from Anthony’s for the first time and could not be more disappointed. Everything that I ordered had to be «Dr’d» up and recooked, except for the dessert, nothing could be done to save that. Both Stromboli’s that I ordered were completely undercooked on the inside and falling apart. The Ricotta Bruschetta bread had only 2 pieces that had Ricotta cheese on them, and all of them had soggy tomato pieces falling off. For dessert, I ordered the carrot cake, well I was told it was carrot cake, to me it tasted like play dough. I’m not sure where they get their dessert sent in from, but they should check out other options. I think it’s safe to assume I will not be ordering from here again.

Wings weren’t particularly tender– a bit chewy and dry.
Decent pizza. Nothing special about the crust. Ok flavor.

Me and my Hubby absolutely love this place! So yummy! They have amazing pizza! He’s super picky when it comes to pizza since he is from New York. So he was definitely impressed. We like to share a large pizza and sit outside and relax. The service was great.

Recently moved to the Citrus Park area and have been trying the local pizza places. Being from the Northeast I’m usually skeptical when a place calls itself «New York Style». I ordered a large pie with pepperoni, sausage, onions and mushrooms.
When I picked it up, I met the owner Vinny. Very friendly, the pizza was ready and piping hot.
After the first slice, I can say that the pizza is the real thing. Sauce, perfect! Toppings, excellent (not the cheap stuff). Cheese, just the right amount. Overall, outstanding.
No need to try any other places. I’ll be back for more.

We had a wonderful meatball parm sub .
Pleasant owner. They put their heart into their meals

We were craving a change from our usual pizza night and had driven past Anthony’s numerous times. We decided to try them out but were discouraged by the difficulty in finding a menu. I would have been much quicker to select them if they had their menu posted online. Needless to say, my husband drove to the shop and picked up a menu so we could look it over before ordering. Once we got our pizza we were not disappointed. It is your typical pizzeria pizza which is harder to come by than you may think. I look forward to trying their sandwiches and/​or calzones in the future. Anthony’s is a welcome addition to the neighborhood. :)

Tried this place for lunch. It was quick, friendly, tasty, and a good price. I definitely will return. The staff was informative and approachable. The slices were a good size for the price. The dining area was clan and looks nice. The lunch specials had a good variety.

I love this place! There is nothing better than good home-​made italian goodies!

It was a rainy night and after being out and about, we opted to spend some time out of the rain. Pizza and a movie sounded good to me, while remaining dry on the couch.
My friend had ordered from Anthony s before and was singing it’s praises. Okay, I was in, I love a good pizza (I really, really do). So we called and placed our order to have the pizza delivered. We settled in with a glass of vino and started the movie. About 40 minutes latter our tums were making audible hungry sounds. We smiled, tried to wait patiently and concentrate on the movie.
Finally the door bell, YEAH PIZZA.
It was warm, but not really hot, but at this point we didn’t care. The pizza was full of fresh toppings, both meat and veggies, which tasted great. Their sauce has a nice hearty texture and taste, not too acidic. I prefer a thin and crispy crust and this was a thicker, hand tossed pie. Overall it really had a fabulous flavor, unfortunately the crust was not cooked all the way through, so it was a bit doughy and chewy.
I think too many people had the same idea we did, to stay in out of the rain. We were hungry and even with the crust it satiated our hunger for pizza. I would have given it 4 stars, if the crust had been fully cooked. Back to the movie and wine.
What’s a girl to do? I am still in search of the perfect pizza pie.

Tried this place recently on account of a flyer in the mail. Once I called n placed my order I had a good feeling about this place, the guy who answered had an Italian accent like what I’m accustomed to back home.
Ordered my usual (Sicilian str8 up) and opted to have it delivered which unfortunately took over an hour.
However once I received my box of delicious looking eye candy the angst of waiting evaporated.
Good crust light well balanced sauce with low acidity (aka low agada occurrence) and a generous slathering of creamy moozaell with a touch of goodness that unfortunately only us Italians can provide.
I was very impressed and elated to find another pizzeria that serves the pizza I grew up back on LI. Angelo and his staff very friendly and will treat you like famiglia.