Yogurt Naturally

Boring! I am so surprised by all the good ratings for this place on Unilocal.After perusing Unilocal for a good ice cream place, we were disappointed to see everything in Tampa area is mainly frozen yogurt or soft serve. Where’s the homemade creameries? There’s definitely a market to open one up here. Come on people, it’s hot all the time! Give the people what they want! Back to the point — we went here as the reviews said it has a lot of interesting flavors. Nope, not true. Just your standard flavors. Boyfriend had mint chip and I went with boring vanilla and rainbow sprinkles on top, that’s how desperate I was. Expensive ice cream and not worth it! We had a little more than a scoop and it was like 5 bucks for each of us. Frozen yogurt will never be as good as regular ice cream!

Great family-​run restaurant. Always has delicious flavors. Always better than the place down the street. You can’t beat this shop.

So after we called 8 places in the area to look for black raspberry flavored ice cream this was the winner. We stepped in and the place was a def mom and pop feel. The owner was the sweetest. Reminded me of a place you would go to as a kid. I loved the drive thru and the fact that this place has been around for over 20 years says something.

I wish I liked this place because I like to support local places, but their ice-​cream is just not good. I tried it three times, and this last time I just threw the cone out and went up MacDill to dough — their homemade gelato is AWESOME.

I really can’t tell the difference between Yogurt Naturally’s dipped yogurt and ice cream! We haven’t been back to Yogurtology since trying Yogurt Naturally a couple of months ago. I love the Oreo Fudge in a waffle cone and the fact that they have a drive thru! They put a marshmallow in the bottom of the cone so it doesn’t drip. Small but nice that they pay that much attention to detail!

Been going here for 20 + years. Still awesome. Sugar free is great, flavor burst is a hit with my kid. Drive thru so convenient. A little pricey but worth it!

Usually, there is not much to say about ice cream shops… & this particular shop doesn’t even offer a cute and pleasant interior to be honest… Its just a simple shop.
BUT:
1. The ICE CREAM… omg INCREDIBLE variety of flavors, plus frozen yogurt options, dipped flavors, home-​made waffle bowls, healthy sugar free flavors, low carb stuff. WHAT A VARIETY!
2. DRIVE-​THRU. DRIVE-​THRU. DRIVE-​THRU I mean it doesn’t get better than driving up in Pjs and getting a gigantic Ice-​cream treat all while sitting in the comfort of your car jamming to your music to celebrate how lazy and fat you’re about to be.
3. SWEET People. The service here is amazing. Just the perfect definition of a mom & pop shop offering an awesome product with a smile :)

This business has been here for 26 years?! Wowza! I’m about to become part of their legacy after last nights’ waffle cone with Chocolate Peanutbutter. How cow, it was good!
Service was with a smile on this rainy Monday, and the drive thru window was being utilized by others while I sampled in-​store. This is my favorite new sweet treat stop.

When I moved to Tampa I went to Yogurt Naturally ALL the time because it was close to where I lived and I love frozen yogurt with a fiery passion.
This is a very small little frozen yogurt place with a huge variety of flavors. There are dipped flavors, lots of toppings and the prices are pretty good too. Yogurt Naturally also has sugar free and low carb options for those watching their waistlines!
Some of my favorite flavors were the vanilla cherry yogurt and I think there was also a Spiderman yogurt that was interesting.
The service is always really good here. It’s a family-​owned place so the same people are working all the time.
I really like the drive-​thru option here but I have to say I have never used it. I do think the whole idea behind it is awesome though, because who wouldn’t like getting frozen yogurt and then eating it on the go? Mmm. Froyo is good anywhere, anytime so that sounds good to me.
Overall this is a really cute place. It’s no frills, but I don’t think that’s entirely necessary for a frozen yogurt joint.

YN is a little mom & pop ice cream shop. It has a certain old school feel to the place. There is even a drive through window.
They have variety of options and flavors. They have non fat and low fat treat options if you are into that.
Have given them many chances over the years & second time I have tried their ice cream and shakes recently & unfortunately I was not impressed. The shake was not tasty & the chocolate/​vanilla swirl which is a childhood favorite for many of us was too sweet and lacked the chocolate and vanilla flavor I was expecting. Just not what had hopped for walking into the place. Ended up not finishing either and that’s never a good sign.
As a small business they have the option of becoming a great local spot but they have missed the mark for me many times and I can’t recommend it to anyone unfortunately.

This is my second favorite ice cream /​frozen yogurt in the Tampa Bay Area. The Tanya and Matts Ice Creamiest in Carrollwood off Dale Mabry is my favorite, mainly because of the Smurf Ice Cream and cool décor (but they were out of Smurf on our last visit before moving down here to South Tampa). Since moving down here, my fiancée and I have been coming to Yogurt, Naturally and we have been very pleased.
We have yet to go inside but multiple drive through visit have been delicious and successful! There has always been other cars in line, but the line moves very quick, even if you get samples .
The staff is very very friendly, all smiles. Even the small scoops prove to be a good size.
The frozen yogurt is so good it actually tastes like ice cream. My new favorite is Spider-​Man. It is colored red but is actually vanilla flavored and have a combo of chocolate chips and Oreos inside. OHHHHH THE AMAZING SPIDER-​MAN!!!
If you cannot tell, my fiancée and I are still kids at heart. Her favorite ice cream flavor is Smurf and mine is Spider-​Man! Nothing wrong with that.
I highly recommend coming here as tasting the wonderful frozen yogurt selection they have at Yorgurt, Naturally.

Hidden gem, best in town. Better than yogurtology hands down. Family owned and extremely friendly.

What’s not to love? Its a frozen yogurt place with creative flavors that I can drive through in my pajamas! Everything is made in house, which makes a big difference to me. The waffle comes are awesome. The Oreo fudge, my favorite, has large chunks or Oreo in it. I know a lot of people associate frozen yogurt with being healthy. There are some lower fat options, but I wouldn’t come here with that expectation!

I really want this place to be better. I want to give them more stars and I want the yogurt to be more delicious.
I’ve been here several times over the years, before the make your own yogurt businesses started popping up all over the place. The drive thru is great and I love frozen yogurt as an alternative to ice cream, particularly that it is healthier and has the good yogurt cultures.
I used to really love this place because their yogurt was hard scooped like ice cream and their flavors tasted more like ice cream. Lately, my visits haven’t been that good. I almost always get the peanut butter fudge (chocolate yogurt with a peanut butter ribbon) and/​or cookies and cream. On my last two visits the yogurt tasted bland and seemed more ice-​y than creamy.
It’s ok for a healthier treat but I just wish it was more satisfying.

The milkshakes were great especially the mint and the peanut butter. The drive thru is very easy with the kids in the back.

I love this place! The yogurt is really good, although a little pricey in my opinion. I had a regular shake and it was like $ 5.50. I can make one at home for a lot less $, but it’s still worth it :) Peanut Butter Fudge and Mint Chip are my favorites.

The yogurt was good (I had mint with oreos and little peppermint pattie things), but the older gentleman waiting on us seemed very rude and grouchy. I guess ’tis the season it is not.