Chicago’s Pizza

Good pizza and fast service. The place is somewhat small, so if you want to eat in get there early. Servers worked together well and food was brought out hot. I recommend the Skyline if you like a supreme type pizza.

I love this place! You can get a Large deep dish pizza, 2 salads and a pitcher of Goose Island for $ 35 and the food and staff is really great!

I was just passing through and found this place. Food was pretty good and a great price on the pizza buffet. Service was with a smile and I really liked the home town feel inside with the type of decorations.

Best thing was our waitress. The food is average style for a buffet. The pizza did not have much variety but there was not much of a crowd there.

Chicago’s Pizza is definitely a gem of a find for small town southern Indiana. We’ve been several times now and have yet to find a local (we’re from Santa Claus) pizza joint that comes even close to the quality of Chicago’s Pizza.

Seriously the best pizza place within a 30 mile radius of Holiday World, and worth the drive if you’re looking for a good pie! I agree with the previous reviewer that said it wouldn’t garner a 5 star review if it were in a large city… but we’re not, so it does. I absolutely love the pan pizza and the crust is «to-​die-​for». Their selections of specialty pizzas are numerous, including my personal favorite, the Barbecue Chicken Pizza. When eating in, be prepared for minimal seating and LOTS of kids/​screaming. However, the beer selection is decent, so a few beers and you forget about the kids! Their carry out is well done with a window right up front.
The best things is the prices! My husbands and i were shocked at our bill. The price is what added one last star to my review.
Note: The have a HUGE pie that serves like 20 people. Pretty sure you’ll have to strap the box to the top of your car to take it home though… it’s THAT big!!!

Pizza is good and the staff is very nice. Great service! Might not garner 4 stars if it was in a big city with lots of pizza options, but is definitely one of the better pizza places in the area.

Better than Domino’s