Brusters Real Ice Cream

Fantastic service, delicious ice cream and crispy corn dog nuggets made with Nathans hot dogs!!! Awesome place!!!

We pulled into the parking lot about 5 minutes before closing… There were cars in the drive thru still being served. I don’t usually go to restaurants right before closing because it is rude, but we were just going to grab a quick cone and be on our way. When the teenage girl working the front window saw us walking up she literally ran outside to turn the ‘open’ sign off. They finished helping the drive thru customers and never acknowledged us.

This is an old-​timey sort of walk up and drive-​through only ice cream place. All the seating is outside. There’s a decent selection of flavors; however, my biggest complaint is that the ice cream comes very soft and has already begun melting before you even take the first lick. We ordered five cones with five different flavors so I suspect the problem is with their freezers. The staff was friendly, but that’s not enough to make me go back.

This is the best ice cream in town but a little pricey for ice cream. The brownie fudge sundae is amazing.
The ice cream flavors do change. The apple crisp flavor is my favorite but I haven’t seen it back yet. My husband loves the thin mint flavor which I believe is another seasonal flavor.
Doggie sundaes are free. My dog Sadie usually ignores the biscuit and goes straight for the good stuff. This is such a nice tradition. Dogs love ice cream, too.

We were out and about driving around and randomly found this place. First thing I notice is that you can get $ 1 off a banana split if you bring your own banana. Very cool. I don’t carry bananas with me very often but nice gimmick to set them apart from other ice cream places. I’ve been back a couple of times and each time the employees are always friendly and prompt with the service. The ice cream is spot on and they do have Nathan’s hot dogs and other stuff. I don’t mind the 20 minute drive for this type of quality :)

Great ice cream! Always have different flavors every time we have gone. No issues at the drive thru or at the counter. Some flavors I’ve enjoyed are:
Key lime pie
Red velvet cake batter
Strawberry cheesecake
Graham central station
All you need is the ice cream in a cup or cone and nothing additional.
Best ice cream I’ve ever had!

This place used to be amazing. Then they were sold to someone that brought in Nathan’s Hot Dogs and ever since its been sub-​par. We couldn’t even stomach the frozen yogurt we bought last time.
The service is also horrible. We can tell it’s the owners and not the staff. Like when we go through the drive thru and have to argue to have lids (because we don’t want to drive home with open cups of ice cream), or being charged for a cup for a doggie sundae when they’ve never done that and there was no notice of the change. Customer service here obviously isn’t a priority.
We don’t eat ice cream a lot, but from now on I think we’ll just buy a pint from the store.

I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice scream! Yes, we had the banana split! It was just the right, if not overly generous amount, if you come on Thursday, bring your own banana, the banana splits are HALF price! Wow, this place is great! And a covered picnic table to enjoy your treats!

I love their ice cream and my hubby loves the chocolate shake (he’s old school no new fangled ice cream creations for him), however, the prices are high for ice cream… I mean we don’t have a patent for the cure for cancer here. The staff is always friendly, but as far as efficiency I can’t say the same. I just go prepared to wait. It seems from the time that I have had watching them that Bruster’s require that the products be weighed for consisentcy in product volume and probably to try and cut back on product loss… however, it can be downright painful to watch the employees weigh it take away weigh it add to it weigh it do the hokey pokey and turn around before giving you your cup of ice cream.
I by no means am saying the employees aren’t doing their best I really do think its just that they are required to follow protocol that seems a bit excessive.
Oh back to the ice cream… birthday cake is the best flavor, with cake batter ice cream, a ribbon of buttercream icing, and sprinkles… its super sweet though so don’t order more than a scoop because the flavor is sooooo dead on and sweet that it will coat your tastebuds and you won’t be able to finish more than just a scoop.

Most of their flavors are a little more sugary sweet than expected, but the quality is still pretty good. They’d get a 4^th star if their prices were a tad bit lower.

The newly opened Bruster’s is a much needed ice cream café in Titusville located off highway 50. Bruster’s offers a large selection of ice cream, low fat yogurt, milkshakes, sundaes, etc. It features a drive through and a walk up window for ordering for your convenience.
This Bruster’s seemingly always has someone waiting in line, though with the friendly and efficient staff it never has become a problem. There is a nice little covered table besides the building which is a great place to sit and hang out with your tasty ice cream.