Yoder Popcorn

Best popcorn around. Non-​GMO with a great variety of kernels. We buy it for our movie theatre in Angola and everyone loves it.

If you can’t stop at Yoder Popcorn itself but are able to go to E&S Sales in downtown Shipshewana, you’ll find a limited selection of the varieties of popcorn available at Yoder Popcorn. But if you want the full selection, it’s worth the trip to go to the source.
Red, Blue, Purple, Tiny Tender, Mushroom (pops up really big!), Lady Finger + others and all kinds of popcorn making equipment and salt blends and serving containers. Most popcorn varieties are available in a few different sizes. The two pound bags seem to be the most popular size, but there are smaller sample sizes, really big bags and even gift packs with small bags of several varieties in a gift box.
While you look over their wares, you can sample a free bag of popcorn. It smells fantastic in there. I said to one of the young ladies running the store, «You have a great job! You feed popcorn to people and then they’re happy. You make people happy.»
Definitely worth the trip if you are in the area.

Great selection of popcorn, some varieties are hard to find (I’m looking at you, Yoder’s Baby Blue, competitor’s BB just won’t do, wish you were available in larger quantities). Helpful staff. Free samples. Close to Shipshewana, but away from the main tourist traps and in the beautiful countryside. We go and stock up whenever we can.

Great popcorn, but BEWARE if ordering via mail order. I recently ordered 24lbs of Lady Finger (over $ 66 after shipping). When product arrived, the entire batch was dried out and flaking. When I talked to Yoder, they told me I should pack it back up and ship it back, or I could dump it into a different container while standing outside in wind. The dry hulls would then just blow away. Come on, I’ve placed more than 5 large orders with these guys over the years. Why send a good customer an old batch and then make them work for it. Anyway, I found a few other places on Amazon and Ebay that I think I’ll try next time that also have free shipping.

Great place for popcorn, Small & limited, But great. Especially with the complimentary popcorn & the flavors you can sample. Absolutely great.

Fact: We eat a lot of popcorn in my house.
Fact: We buy ALL of our popcorn here. Tiny Tender is what we get.
On our last trip we also purchased a few of the flavored salts. Not sure I am convinced they are better than just plain salt & butter, but we’ll give it a shot.
And how can you go wrong when there are free & fresh samples of popcorn when you walk in the door!

for 20 yrs i’ve used YODER for my popcorn related needs through mail order because athough they have a walk-​in shoppe too in topeka it’s not exactly right across the ill/​in state border (150 mi. from chicagoland, but if you’re driving east…)
you’ll find your fresh kernel varieties here (largest size is 50 lb bag), stainless stovetop popper, fine popcorn seasonings, and jars of coconut popping oil (actually coconut butter unless you keep it too warm). would i serve you a saturated fat? let’s talk guilty pleasures between friends. go to yoder online site or call their tollfree number 800÷892−2170. the best prices around too
my dear dad always made popcorn stove-​top and since that’s how i was raised no microwave popcorn in my home, and – no lie – not a single un-​popped kernel in my stovetop popper either. (yoder does sell microwave type too, gift tins/​baskets). my dad also ate popcorn one kernel at a time. the things i miss about him
yoder popcorn is a member in good standing of the shipshewana retail merchants association

Our family is popcorn fanatics. Yoder is simply the best. We have been buying Tiny Tender since the 1970’s — there is nothing better! I now live in California and get «resupplied» on-​line. Their web site is easy to use and deliveries always prompt. Along with «Tiny Tender White» make sure to try «Lady Finger». Also if you are ever in Northern Indiana make sure to stop by their little store and meet Sharon and her team.

I have ordered Yoder popcorn by mail for several years and am hooked. It is always very good popcorn. My family especially likes the tiny tender white variety. Although it costs a little bit to send a 6 pound bag of popcorn by parcel post, it is well worth the expense to have good popcorn.

There are no words to truly describe this popcorn! If u r anywhere near the area u must stop here! We received free bags of freshly popped popcorn to snack on as we shopped. They have everything you could ever need for popcorn! We have a popcorn machine so we r familiar with the prices of the oil, seasonings and so forth… they r the cheapest priced. U can even order online but the experiance of going there tops it all. Such friendly informative people, so many different types of popcorn, weither u want the microwave bags or for a popcorn machine, red, blue, big, tiny kernels, you name it they got it! Highly recommend! We will be repeat customers when we return to the area and we will mostlikely have to order online too. Don’t forget Tiny Tender… a popcorn you will grow to love!

This is the best popcorn around! Amazing service and it feels great to support a family owned business.
I recommend the Tiny Tender.
Plus, you get free popcorn if you go to the store! If you can’t make it out there though, I know you can order online.