Top That Pizza

Okay, apparently they have revisited their pricing model and adjusted it. You can get a 10 inch pizza for 5.99 during lunch time during the weekdays. So for that reason I’m giving them another star. If they had the same pricing all the time I would say they are worth 5 stars but this isn’t a great deal except for lunch during the week.

This is the best tasting, best priced, fast custom pizza we ever had. My wife is gluten-​free and she LOVES it. I like being able to go down the line and choose which crust, sauce, and fresh veggies and meats to add. To me it’s just pizza heaven!
2435 West Kenosha is the address, it’s called 71^st street too.

I ordered the 10″ with drink combo. I got their pre-​determined veggie pizza option and had them prepare it exactly as their menu described. It was quite good. The «angry alfredo» sauce had a decent amount of kick, but was not overly spicy. The only thing which I feel could use improvement is their dough. It was not full at all. It felt more like a flatbread. I prefer my pizza to be deep dish, so this thin dough was a bit of a letdown. Other than that, I was happy!

It seems like a great concept. I mean how could you go wrong with fast food pizza.
So we walked in and the place was filled with smoke. I’m not sure why but eyes were burning for hours after we left. We went to order and felt like we were being ignored for at least the first 10 minutes there.
Finally we ordered a large pizza which is on the menu but they had never made one before. They had no idea how to make one since they didn’t have dough that size. Rather than telling us that and just giving us two smaller pizzas for the same price they cobbled together some dough into a larger pizza which after it was «cooked» was still doughy.
They didn’t have any plates big enough for the large so they cut the pizza and placed it on two separate plates. No big deal, right? Well I was expecting the good old fashioned triangular slices and we got some random assortment of cuts, some triangles, some rectangles, some sort of undefinable polygons.
All I can say is that you can get a better quality pizza, cheaper elsewhere. Maybe sometime I’ll try out the BA location but I (and I don’t say this often about a pizza place) will never go to the Southroads/​Promenade Mall location again.

Love Top That Pizza. You can have as many toppings as you like and truly customize your pizza. Healthy options if desired. Pizza ready in a couple of minutes. Thin crust!

A neat concept, and its nice that you can add as many toppings as you like.
The pizza turns out pretty good, but both their dough and pizza sauce have WAY too much salt in them. I realize that pizza is generally pretty salty, but this was just too much.

GUD quality for decent price — 10“pizza & drink $ 8.99. —any amount of toppings!
Crust just thin airy crisp not much thickness to it. Made to order FRESH, staff was very polite and quick! New fav!

My wife and I were in Tulsa recently and saw the Top That Pizza restaurant in Tulsa Hills on Olympia. We stopped to check it out. Prior to this, we had not heard of the company. We ordered and shared one of your All You Can Meat pizzas on Honey Wheat. Awesome! We were hooked! Last night we returned to Tulsa and we both were craving another Top That Pizza. We stopped at the shop in Midtown on 41^st Street. We tried something different — same topings but on the Italian white. Again, a home run! (Sometime pretty soon we’ll just have to try another style.) Anyway, we are both impressed and are telling everyone who we encounter that they need to visit any one of your restaurants. Keep up your fine work!