Presto Pizza

I placed a order and it took a hour to get here. I requested a status update about 48 mins in and was told my food will be leaving the restaurant soon and when my food did get here it was cold not even lukewarm. Just moved to the area will not be using eat24 service nor ordering from this place again.

Came here because I was craving buffalo wings and theirs hit the spot! Also got a chicken caesar salad that was way bigger portioned than I expected. Their garlic knots are so buttery and delicious. Service was great as well.

It was our first time at this pizzeria. We ordered regular slices and a sausage roll everything was delicious! The lady who took our order was very nice and place was clean! Would definitely recommend.

PRESTO ! …This Place Is Really BAD !
Pizza Is A Greek Style Pizza — Small Slices, Chewy, Dry
Steak & Cheese — Frozen Steak emm Taste Fake, Very Small Pieces Of Meat Its Like Biting In To Mush
Ordered A Buffalo Chicken Slice — Got A Buffalo Roll Never Said Anything Figured That Was Good Too Except This Buffalo Chicken Taste Like A Hot Pocket Fake Chicken With Indian Seasoning, Just Terrible
ALL IN ALL — I Think That The Only Reason This Place Makes Money Is From Drunk People Who Will Eat Anything

Prestos is awesome their pizza is good especially on sunday deal… all their food is delicious and the service is great…

SOLID PIZZA ON LONG ISLAND. If you go to Hofstra or NCC or any near by school THIS is the place to stop and grab a slice.
The chicken parm slice is UNREAL. The bottom of it is crunchy like a cracker and each bite is PACKED with chicken and cheese. It’s the only time I’ve ever seen such a heavy slice hold itself up :)
WHITE SLICE IS AMAZING AND ALMOST ALWAYS MADE TO ORDER. So worth the wait… the ricotta cheese and mozzarella just melts in your mouth when you bite into the slice.
The pinwheels and stuffed pizza is the bomb dot com as well! I wouldn’t stay and eat there just because I’m not a fan of the area, but it’s definitely an underrated spot. GO GO GO !!!

Not too into their food. Like their specialty fries. However their buffalo wrap was pretty good.
The pizza here is solid. I haven’t had one bad experience with it.

Presto pizza has an amazing cheesy pizza that goes prefect with an order of garlic bread. The employees are excellent always had a smile on their face as well as keeping communicated and working as a team to get the job done. They also got great prices 2 slices and a drink for about 5 $ can’t beat that deal.

Picture this … A fresh out the oven pie with lots of melted stretchy cheese and plenty of sauce and a liter of soda of your choice… interested yet? Well here’s the scoop, Pizza here is delicious and large enough to feed a family of four and their garlic knots when consumed right away are warm buttery and delicious. Ask for daily specials they have lots of great deals going on all the time. If you like toppings its $ 5 additionally, but personally I prefer the regular cheese pizza. If you are ever nearby and just want to grab a slice I suggest you give the caesar salad pizza a try. I know it sounds crazy to have salad on your pizza but hey salads are healthy right, it is just so much better when it is on a pizza.

The pizza is not to good it’s dry and is not fresh and is left wide in the open. Also the garlic knots are dry and stale which isn’t good at all. I don’t suggest this place but if you want go give it a try

I’ve ordered from here a few times, and there’s always something that is NOT good. The pizza is consistent and acceptable. But, this past order prompted the review. The food was 30 minutes later than the already-​long 60-​minute wait time. As usual, the pizza was fine. But, the dozen garlic knots were dry and stale, two words that also describe the garlic bread order. So, I think I’m officially done.

I looove the pizza there. 2 regular slices and a medium drink for $ 4.50. the regular slices are the best. their pizza is delicious and they are huge slices. it’s nearby my house and if i could eat it everyday i would.

I first discovered Presto’s when I was attending the local Uniondale High School over 15 years ago. I would walk from school during lunch to take advantage of the lunch special almost every day and hustle back to my 5^th period class! I even had my first after school date here! Fast forward 19 years, I no longer live in Uniondale, but I frequently visit family and friends out there. I ALWAYS stop in to grab pizza, chicken parm subs, pasta platters etc. when I am in town. I live in New Jersey and to be frank, I have yet to find a decent pizza out there; all pizzerias pale in comparison to Presto’s. Nearby there is even a Gino’s on Uniondale Avenue which had its heyday, but is terrible now in comparison, but I digress. My point is that after all these years, the food is still delicious, the place is still clean and the service is always stellar (I mean it is not a «5 star» fancy pants place, but for what it is, the service is always, at least, courteous). The recipe for the pizza and sauce has not changed over the years because it still retains its distinctive yummy flavor. Sometimes parking in their lot can be almost full at certain times in the early evening but you can always park nearby – it’s worth it. I always enjoy the food here and my family and I will continue to patronize Presto. I highly recommend them.

I finally found delicious, affordable pizza in Uniondale. No longer do I need to suffer! Good food, Great daily specials promoted prominently in the front window. No silly time specific specials, ALL DAY LONG specials! 2 slices and a fountain drink, for under $ 5 with tax! Delicious full-​sized slices, perfectly cooked, sweet sauce/​real cheese!!!
Gyros, soup, salad, cheesesteaks, menus! Menus, still can’t believe Gino’s doesn’t have menus! You know whatelse Gino’s don’t have? This good a rating!

Ordered a meatball sub via Eat 24 delivery service. I think I’m in love. Can’t wait to try the pizza.

I graduated from the nearby high school and this was one of my go-​to places when I decided that I deserved early dismissal for the day. The pizza here is extremely good when warm! Not the best pizza when cold so stay a while and eat in shop. They have great specials offering two slices of cheese pizza and a drink for $ 5, if I am not mistaken. The staff are nice and the tables are always clean.
The pasta is also worth a try.
Tip: Try and avoid the after school rush it can get really full and crowded around 2:30pm. It’ll be hard to find a table to sit and it will take a while to place your order.

Still, hands down, the most delish NY pizza ever!

TERRIBLE service. When I called and complained that they messed up my order, the manager was extremely rude and unaccommodating. When I told him that my girlfriend was allergic to cheese and that’s why we ordered it without cheese, he recommended: «just take it off.»
Not to mention the food is gross and super greasy…

The pizza here is scrumptious! Perfect amount of cheese and sauce and the slices are huge. Much larger than a typical slice. I’m a two slice kind of girl and I could not, no matter how hard I tried, finish both. I wanted to so bad but it was just too huge.
They have a special for 2 slices and a medium soda. Get that.
As far as service goes, the workers here are darling. Very friendly and patient. Of course I take a million years to decide what I want. I went back and forth with my sugar plum about who would pay, would we stay or go… yada yada yada. They stood there quietly giggling at us.
The place is very clean and not the hugest but the picnic like tables do. As long as you don’t mind sitting with a stranger or two plenty of people can fit in here. They also have a huge tv and was showing «How I Met Your Mother» (SO funny!) while I was there instead of some silly news or political BS that I would not have been even slightly interested in while trying to eat some pizza.
This spot is awesome and I only wished I had more reasons to be out in Uniondale for a little slice of heaven.

I haven’t actually been in the physical location for Presto Pizza, but after starting law school, and having to adjust to the dorm life, this was the first place I ordered from. Unlike most would expect, I did not in fact order pizza, instead of went for the Rigatoni a la Vodka with Grilled Chicken, Buffalo Wings and Garlic Knots.
The portions I received for this were enormous, more than enough to feed 3 (for those times you’re staying in and still somehow have a third wheel)…Needless to say my roommates were more than happy to know I had an abundance of food and the willingness to share.
The food was phenomenal. At the price, and especially out in Long Island, which I have little to no dining experience, I was very pleased with the quality and amazing flavor. I would say that I plan to order from them again, but I’d be lying, since I already have. If you live out in LI and trust what I’ve written even a slight bit, you should obviously give Presto Pizza a try… they deliver so it’s really a minimal amount of work on your part.