Aurelio’s Pizza

Their pizza is an embarrassment to Aurelio’s. I grew up around the original and have had other franchise owned locations and NONE have been as consistently bad as this one. I’m surprised corp hasn’t shut this location down yet. Every. Single. Time I’ve ordered from there it’s been bad. After at least five tries I’m certain this location doesn’t know what it’s doing. PLEASE do not base your opinion of Aurelio’s on the food you eat at this location. Try pretty much any other store for a try of their real pizza.

Things have greatly improved since my previous review. Employees are courteous although a couple could use some customer service training. I custom order the amount of sauce/​cheese, etc. and it’s fairly consistent. Sometimes I do get someone else’s pizza. But, even on their worst day, they are still the best pizza in Valpo. Gelsosomo’s is close but doesn’t have the flavor you’ll get on an Aurelio’s pizza. Good place for carry out; dining area is too small to be comfortable but you can eat there. And the pizza is ready when they say.

Best pizza ever with super friendly service pizza always ready on time always a great place to get pizza

Having been to several Chicagoland Aurelio’s locations in the past, I was happy to learn that a Valparaiso location existed; I’m happy to say that my one experience so far with this Aurelio’s location was a positive one, and I plan on doing business with them in the future.
This location isn’t one that I would dine-​in at due to its cramped space, but if you’re interested in pick up or delivery, I’d highly recommend it. The staff was friendly and seemed happy to have me stop by on a Friday night despite whatever stresses they might have been having at the time.
The food was great, just like all Aurelio’s, and my food was ready exactly when promised. It is somewhat on the pricier side, but in this case you definitely get what you pay for!