Thorncroft Inn

Absolutely disappointed
I am writing to you concerning Thorncroft Inn (Martha’s Vineyard) about a recent booking. I made an online reservation through
⁷⁄₂₆ for this weekend regarding a three night stay. I considered the booking to be complete because I received a confirmation number and usually that indicates satisfactory confirmation of the stay. I received a voicemail from Karl (owner) to give him a call that was dated from yesterday. Unfortunately, I was at work for the 24 hours and did not have access to my phone or personal email. He notified me that he had cancelled my reservation for that weekend because he did not have my billing address and stated that he had booked the room already. Instead of holding the room from
reservation or contacting
for further information, he cancelled the room abruptly. There is no where listed that we needed to personally verify or confirm the reservation. We are now forced to cancel the weekend where I was to propose to my girlfriend. I am extremely disappointed and annoyed regarding this situation. I would be absolutely embarrassed if I partook in this establishment.
Dr. Abie L.
Attending Physician
Emergency Medicine

Spent a delightful weekend on MV celebrating my wife’s birthday and stayed at the Thorncroft Inn in Tisbury — I’m so glad we did! The Inn and service we received there from the owners, Karl and Lynn, were outstanding in every way. From Karl’s warm greeting and knowledgable introduction to the inn and all things MV, to the spotlessly clean and well-​appointed room, to the beautiful inn and impeccably maintained grounds, to the inn’s quiet location, to the elegant and delicious breakfasts and friendly good morning chats with Lynn, we were impressed by everything and felt right at home. The rose and nice birthday note to my wife that was waiting for us in our room when we returned to the inn after a day of exploring the island was kind and thoughtful and illustrates the care and attention to detail that Karl and Lynn bring to their inn. My wife and I will definitely stay here again and I recommend highly the Thorncroft Inn to couples looking for a first-​rate place to stay on a romantic MV getaway.

This place was great. The inn keepers Karl and Lynn are very sweet, and funny. They took great care of us, from a personal phone call the day before we left to arrange our travel, to personal dinner and sight seeing recommendations, to buying my wife flowers for our anniversary.
Because it was our anniversary, and the offseason, they offered us a free upgrade of rooms. The rooms were spotless. With great attention to detail. We stayed in room 10 which was very private with our own hot tub, and fire place. The bed was comfortable and warm
The breakfasts were also incredible. The cheese stuffed French toast was fantastic. And the biscuits and muffins were fresh and warm.
My wife and I highly recommend Thorncroft Inn and will stay here again on future visits.

We came back from MV just yesterday and I’m so in love with this inn that I can’t forget the immemorable experience it gave me. The inn keepers are wonderful as the place. It’s so wonderful and Victorian plus comfortable. We stayed there for a night and we just loved it. It’s very neat and clean and the bathrooms have all the toiletries you would need. They also have a hair dryer. The bed we slept on was very comfortable. We had a good nights sleep. The breakfast was scrumptious and they served it with such a warmth that u feel so at home and cared. The lemon and poppy seeds cup cakes were out of the world. I would highly recommend this inn to everyone who’s looking for a stay in vineyard haven.

If you are looking to decompress this is the place for you. Very, very quiet. Very clean and personnel very nice. Our room under the stairs was a little tight.

Although it is not located right at the center of town, it deserves 5 stars for the really caring service of the inn-​keepers and staff!
My husband and I went to MV for our first time and we were greeted by the inn-​keepers even before we departed with a very nice phone conversation and willingness to help make our weekend as lovely as possible. Breakfast is made by the inn-​keeper and it is Y.U.M.M.Y. This is where I discovered the Cheddar-​stuffed French Toast topped with Peach sauce… sounds strange but out of this world!
The room we stayed in was really comfortable, lovely and immaculately clean. If you don’t mind staying just a bit out of the central area, I highly recommend staying here.